What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Search results

  1. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    At this rate I think we just hammer Tildey and move on to Robo tomorrow

    The Dumbledore theory is interesting, but I don't think it really stops Tildey from being that character regardless of whether it's true or not. If anything, it reads more like someone who knows the truth and is revealing it like it was a solving revelation
  2. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Who do you think is dumbledor? Psycho
    Click to expand...
    It has to be either Robo or Tildey
  3. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    There's a chance I'm wrong about Xan for write-up fuckery, but I think you always find scum in Tildey/Robo first.
  4. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I'm going back over everything and from my perspective, Robo/Randolph/Tildey/Xan can all be Nagel, too.

    I had actually thought Tildey was Dobby for protecting MTR multiple times after his kill last game, but that's out the window now.

    There's something weird going on with that write-up because certain characters shouldn't be there, but based on everything I have, Xan or Randolph is Nagel, heavily leaning Xan on that. If right, Randolph is clear. That leaves Tildey and Pettigrew for Dumbledore and Pettigrew.

    I'm good with chopping Tildey first if you're all seeing the same possibilities I am. Randolph could technically be Pettigrew, but I still think them intending to target him for a rolecop means he wasn't on their team at the time.

    Pablo's hard clean off of that Future kill, so I think I know who he is now if everything has been mostly correct.
  5. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    So much for Satsu not being able to be Voldemort. I whiffed on that and Dreyski.
  6. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Ok, that's a lot to process

    But scum teams isn't great
  7. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I swear to god, Hagrid, if you have another lynch save, hold your damn load.
  8. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Randolph said:
    What do you think Satsu is? Do you think he's blue?
    Click to expand...
    That's my thinking. He can't be purple from what I can tell, and I think he's likely not Voldemort because Dumbledore hid behind him on a night where Voldemort was killing, and then he was roleblocked when Voldemort used that 3 person target action. He could maybe be Pettigrew, but I doubt it.
  9. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Nagel i believe your queenie
    Click to expand...
    I meant player, silly
  10. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Id just ignore psycho 🤡 hes gunna be desperate to save his purple people and make ppl go for others
    Click to expand...
    Who am I trying to save Claws?
  11. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Loras been pretty lora aswell
    Click to expand...
    Lora probably really is Peeves tbv
  12. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Unvote:

    i think dreyski may be the way due to psychos weird doesnt "has" to be him today that just strikes me fucking odd
    Click to expand...
    I just don't like that this is taking a repeat of yesterday where everyone is voting one person without really putting much into it. Only that phase at least had some other discussion going on. And some are unsure about who to vote or haven't really piped in, and I just want other names to be discussed and we're not getting that.

    You said Future needs improvement and Dreyski's meh but needs resolved(and now you think I'm trying to steer away from a Dreyski lynch even though I've been calling for his head since the original lynch). Do you have anything else on them? Other people you're worried about?
  13. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    You know my suspicions, but so I don’t get tunnel vision, Future and Tildey have both only passively appeared in write ups (no action shown on them) so they are both wide open for Death Eaters and Alliance.

    Pablo and Robo being subbed in indicates they might be important characters, which matters more for scum if the players are inactive in a numbers game.
    Click to expand...
    Any thoughts on them as far as how they've posted at all?
  14. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Val the Moofia Boss said:
    Vote: Psycho
    Click to expand...
    You know I'm dead, right?

    Who else are you suspicious of?
  15. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Like I'm open to lynching any of Pablo, Robo, Val, and Future by virtue of them being completely open for red and purple.

    I don't think it  has to be Dreyski today.

    And based on what happened last phase, I don't think it's good to go all in on one person and not consider/push other options.
  16. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    I don’t have an investigative role and I’ve not been able to spreadsheet this one, so I can’t even defend myself properly.
    Do what you will, or are told to, but consider your next steps after I go, because apparently no one else is under suspicion :shrug:
    Click to expand...
    Do you have any suspicions of your own?
  17. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I don't really feel like Satsu's handling of the push on you was as fishy as Dreyski's
  18. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Jarrod1983 said:
    I'm willing to go Satsu too. I think both Dreyski and Satsu kept pushing me and not listening to what I was saying. Satsu didn't as hard but both tried to shoot holes in my honesty.

    I have no hard information though so if someone else has ideas I'm all for it.
    Click to expand...
    I'm not for chopping Satsu
  19. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    We should be discussing more and considering other suspects instead of just dogpiling on Dreyski. We should at least have a solid counter-wagon
  20. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Randolph said:
    Vote: dreyski

    Not a hard vote. Just putting it there until I can get caught up later today.

    Any spreadsheeters got a list of who people could possibly be?
    Click to expand...
    I have my list of possibly purple or red that I posted. You could throw in Satsu as potentially Pettigrew, and Tildey is technically an open field, but I have a theory on who she is that I'm not willing to share. Though I'm less certain about it than I am with Jarrod.
  21. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I'm good with Dreyski as he's literally done nothing to make me change my stance since I originally voted him.
  22. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Pablo Diablo said:
    It is true that normally I do take things a little slower in the start. But that's mainly because at the start of games we have no information and nothing to work on. Coming in midway there is more information to work on. Also this particular game I know that I can't just sit by and not contribute.

    Last night I'm going to assume that some red killed Listo and it was hidden by Peter.

    Peeves is definitely a problem.

    I still don't fully trust anything Psych says, but I'll accept his list of possibilities for now.
    Click to expand...
    But I wasn't lynched based on info...
  23. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    I did see you said he has alot crosses off but i think reds still a possibuility unless im missing somthing
    Click to expand...
    Red is a possibility, but I think the way they've played has been towny. And his read on you not being red doesn't seem like something that would come that early from someone who's red
  24. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For possible red, I have:
    Dreyski
    Pablo
    Robo
    Val
    Future


    For possible Purple, I have:
    Dreyski(longshot)
    Pablo
    Lora
    Robo
    Randolph
    Val
    Xan
    Future

    Also forgot to take out Listo

    I think you should seriously vet Pablo. His behavior entering the game was very un-Pablo like. I've never seen him enter mid-game, but he's usually a little more careful and not so gung-ho. Usually when he is more gung-ho, he's scum.

    Dreyski has still done nothing to make me feel differently about his tone and posting.

    Also, Xan can't be red, but he has the most town roles marked off other than Satsu
  25. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Forgot to take out MTR

    For possible red, I have:
    Dreyski
    Pablo
    Robo
    Val
    Future


    For possible Purple, I have:
    Dreyski(longshot)
    Pablo
    Listo
    Lora
    Robo
    Randolph
    Val
    Xan
    Future
  26. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For possible red, I have:
    Dreyski
    Pablo
    Robo
    MTR
    Val
    Future

    For possible Purple, I have:
    Dreyski(longshot)
    Pablo
    Listo
    Lora
    Robo
    MTR
    Randolph
    Val
    Xan
    Future
  27. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Yeah, I don't fully know what's up with Filch, but in the least he's got a protection ability that isn't guaranteed. I still feel like he's probably one of the traitors.
  28. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Jarrod1983 said:
    So do we know what character Psycho is? Is he remaining unknown? I could see a scum stump working that way because you wouldn't know he was scum.
    Click to expand...
    My guess is I was kept hidden just so people could ask this question. If I was confirmed town then it would be a lot easier to believe my words
  29. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Well, now that I can't vote, hopefully you people will actually listen to me. I'm kinda sad I didn't get to haunt The Homely Man, but Peeves has a ghost brother"s back
  30. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I told you guys
  31. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Why cant snape be a traitor? He was also an og death eater?
    Click to expand...
    I don't think it'll be that obvious, and the oracle ability doesn't feel like a scumsided one. They already have more info than the rest. We're the ones who need that info.
  32. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    PsychoSoldier said:
    as well as figuring out there was a traitor.
    Click to expand...
    And that's a whole other thing

    My money's on Filch at this point based on how Protego has gone down, plus it would make sense theme/flavor wise.

    Draco's probably too obvious. And if it's a surprise turn, my money is on maybe Ron or Harry. Don't think it's Snape based on the kind of info he can receive.
  33. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I think Snape is some kind of Oracle. Or a potion JOAT or something that lets him ask questions about the game's setup. I think it's how he figured out the roles that targeted him as well as figuring out there was a traitor.
  34. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Jarrod is Snape
  35. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    why is he clean?
    Click to expand...
    If he wants me to out him, I can. But I literally just explained as best I could in response to Tildey. It's really obvious if you pay attention to the write-ups and Jarrod's posts.
  36. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Robozerim said:
    Still reading, obviously, but hard not to notice that Psycho is a clear favourite for lynch based on both start of day and very recent posts. Something like never getting targeted and that's suspicious? Mister Homely seems to be a pusher (as of the posts I've reached) of him, though it was at least in part as a counter to being called out himself. Psycho pointed out that Homely hadn't been targeted by somebody I think except when a bus driver was in effect on him? Always a headache, and certainly suspicious. A lot of other people with less overt reasoning than Homely at around the same time. I hear multi ball or w/e the terminology is now is in effect (and the day's write up indicates it too), so I honestly could see them both being scum on opposing teams. Kill em both and things probably go well or at least not terrible. Of course, this is just the currently clueless guy putting in his 2 cents.

    Questions...the first post seems to not be updated past day 3 for deaths and such, is there a good place to see a full list of the dead and their roles/alignments? It'd be nice to get an idea of how the game is going overall.

    Secondly, is this Homely person somebody I've seen before with like a name change or something? I don't recognize the name at all, but he seems the persuasive sort that probably has experience.
    Click to expand...
    Homely Man is Mazer. I believe you played with him once or twice.

    The best bet for a dead list is to click reader mode at the top of the thread and it'll show all the writeup posts. That'll at least have all the flips, even if they're not in one neat and tiny list.
  37. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    You're probably all going to lynch me instead of looking at the info right in front of you. That's fine. Just listen to the info I've put in thread after I die. I'm certain I'm right about The Homely Man, and I'm certain on my townreads and who can be purple/red. It'll be on you to actually listen to it.
  38. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    Which is a reason I would think a town person would help him if they could help clear him as town.
    Click to expand...
    I've been defending Jarrod hard from the get to. Leave him alone. He's clean. And any info he presents will be legit.
  39. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    Are you able to offer more info on this? Jarrod has seemed frustrated that he isn't able to offer clearly info to support his town status. It sounds like you may be able to help him?
    Click to expand...
    Without giving anything away, he's someone who's shown up in the writeup and as far as I can tell, his info is completely legit. There's a certain roles that lines up with the way he's been dispensing info and the people we've seen in the writeups
  40. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    PsychoSoldier said:
    For possible red, I have:
    The Homely Man
    Dreyski
    Pablo
    Robo
    MTR
    Val

    For possible Purple, I have:
    Dreyski(longshot)
    Pablo
    Listo
    Lora
    Robo
    MTR
    Randolph
    Val
    Xan

    Pablo, Robo, MTR, and Val are the most open. I don't really have any feels on Robo or Val, MTR as been okay I guess, and Pablo's entrance doesn't sit right but I'd give a "catching up" pass

    Everyone but Homely Man is pretty much completely open for the red. It's all the people that haven't really shaken up the tree very much.

    I think it's likely Randolph could just be town, though I'm pretty sure he's not red since Lucius was trying to rolecop him.

    I could have been barking up the wrong tree about Dreyski. I still think his posts have a certain bite and manipulative tone to them that doesn't feel like town Dreyski. But if we're to look anywhere else other than The Homely Man, I'd look right into Pablo/Robo/MTR/Val. There's also Listo, but he's not red unless he's a godfather if I'm reading Matthieu's info right.

    Peeves is also pretty wide open other than Claws, Jarrod, Satsu, and Tildey. I'm still thinking about the Lora!Peeves possibility but it could be just about anyone.
    Click to expand...
    Future's open for both sides, too. He hasn't really been targeted by anything yet other than the out-of-phase post restriction
  41. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws
    Jarrod
    Satsu
    Tildey

    This is my pile of townreads, by the way. Everyone else is still open wide
  42. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    Not until an update is posted. I've tried Reader mode and I can follow the Threadmarks that are out there but there doesn't seem to be an easy way to see where the counts stand (without going back through posts and counting) until the mod posts an update.
    Click to expand...
    Oh, yeah, if you want some kind of automated vote count for any point in the thread, we're still a ways off from that unfortunately.
  43. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For possible red, I have:
    The Homely Man
    Dreyski
    Pablo
    Robo
    MTR
    Val

    For possible Purple, I have:
    Dreyski(longshot)
    Pablo
    Listo
    Lora
    Robo
    MTR
    Randolph
    Val
    Xan

    Pablo, Robo, MTR, and Val are the most open. I don't really have any feels on Robo or Val, MTR as been okay I guess, and Pablo's entrance doesn't sit right but I'd give a "catching up" pass

    Everyone but Homely Man is pretty much completely open for the red. It's all the people that haven't really shaken up the tree very much.

    I think it's likely Randolph could just be town, though I'm pretty sure he's not red since Lucius was trying to rolecop him.

    I could have been barking up the wrong tree about Dreyski. I still think his posts have a certain bite and manipulative tone to them that doesn't feel like town Dreyski. But if we're to look anywhere else other than The Homely Man, I'd look right into Pablo/Robo/MTR/Val. There's also Listo, but he's not red unless he's a godfather if I'm reading Matthieu's info right.

    Peeves is also pretty wide open other than Claws, Jarrod, Satsu, and Tildey. I'm still thinking about the Lora!Peeves possibility but it could be just about anyone.
  44. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tightening up my spreadsheet a bit, and thinking about it, Mazer could technically still be Lucius. Bus drive results are usually the only way people can self target under most Rajah rules. Not really sure how Void would play that, though.
  45. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Pablo Diablo said:
    Is there some way to check vote counts quickly on here?
    Click to expand...
    If you want final vote counts, you can click reader mode at the top of the thread page. The Discord server also generally has the final counts documented, though not always final vote accurate.

    Otherwise you can find a Void post and click "ISO" and all the vote counts he posted will show up there
  46. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Also, to be fair to Hagrid, the flavor implies it was a low-poster kill, so it's not like he had a lot of options if that's the case.
  47. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Jarrod1983 said:
    Wrong again on me being purple. I can only do so much. Quit trying to paint me as scum. I am town.
    Click to expand...
    I'm pretty sure I know who you are
  48. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Mazer, it doesn't matter how narrowed down you are because the probably dead cop voted you after investigating. I may have let it slip by when it shouldn't have, but it doesn't change the fact that odds are there's hard evidence against you for the one red role you can be. Try to get your mislynch while you can, but people will listen when they see my flip and they'll get you.
  49. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    so your fake clearing ppl or you know they are probably town since they arent on your team
    Click to expand...
    I wasn't clearing them as if I had info. Satsu had made a comment about you saying you're almost never red, and it seemed so specific that I thought it came from info. Matthieu said we shouldn't worry about you and Listo, particularly after I was poking at Listo, after a Weasley had targeted Listo. I thought it was maybe a claim, and then when I thought they could be masons, I figured that would explain a lot else. Which makes me have you as a hard clear and Listo as "not red"

    Matthieu's flip pretty much confirmed my thoughts and I'm honestly surprised he wasn't killed sooner.
  50. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For the record, I still think Dreyski's up to no good and I'm annoyed no one has bothered to look into him after his wagon came to a halt. That whole wagon is just a waste.
  51. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    I was hit by red. Didn't miss me. And even in your theory, I'm ruled out of stuff. Also I note that purple targeted me that night too. Interested.

    The thing is this....I was trying to figure that out when it happened. Because that vote did catch me off-guard. Was caito false-claiming as scum? Did Did scum have an ability or wish that corrupted things? Badger's potion reading as corrupted made me wonder. Trying to figure out if vk was fucking around. Or foxxi. I also thought about grim mafia, but was too horrific to spend to much time on how caito snaked a claim there.

    Fuck, because i still don't know there.

    Tried to figure out what was going on, because I only had theories.

    I was shocked when you didn't come right at me, because you had communicated with caito. Which does show that kareemah didnt trigger you there. And then purple immediately got him, and there was no more vetting.

    I actually thought you were maybe town there, because you would have seen my playstyle, pushes, etc, and assumed the same

    I would still wonder if I might have you wrong, if you has cited anything where you now read me different. But I'm supposed to accept that you sat on this for days. Were triggered by kareemah, and then waited, instead of pushing me when there was uncertainty with kills?

    You have that read and you let the dreyski train happen? That's not town psych.


    And you've never been targeted? Even on a night like last? ...

    Ok....



    if I'm this wrong, everyone kill me tomorrow.

    Not sure if you gave kareemah this to try to get out of jail and the purple kills have made you throw the hail mary, or just picked up the bones from the other chat.

    Just trying to figure your teammates at this point.
    Click to expand...
    You were hit by red because of the bus drive. That is it. Which means red was actually trying to target Randolph. So that doesn't clear you of anyone but Lucius.

    Meanwhile, Hermione is dead and the most likely player, Caito, opted to vote you right after targeting you. These is hard facts.

    I caught it, but I wasn't certain because Caito wasn't gunning for you hard, and I wasn't sure whether that was because Badger was already "outed" or because he was actually scum bullshitting. But then he died, and Hermione disappeared two nights in a row. And then the cannibal kill with Kareemah's behavior sealed the deal for me.

    Also me being targeted doesn't mean anything. We have three alignment threats. Even if I was scum, I can't be all of them. So the logic that "Psycho hasn't been targeted" is a weak one to try and push me.
  52. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Pablo Diablo said:
    I wanted to go back and look at some of the night phases before voting. But looking at the people eliminated and how he is still alive. Psycho is high on my very early vote list.

    Vote: Psycho
    Click to expand...
    You and Mazer are the two most stinky on my wagon. Pablo just hopping in the game and voting me with not much else to go on doesn't feel right.

    You're good at analyzing actions and roles. What do you make of Hermione's actions vs. Caito's posts?
  53. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    I did go back and look at things. I've got a few theories. There's still some order stuff I'm working on.

    But somebody take a look at the filch action and cwe's death and tell me if you see something interesting right before Ms. Norris dies.
    Click to expand...
    I get what you're angling at, but the same thing could be said about filch targeting you and Xanjori and nothing bad happening.

    I have a lot of trouble believing Filch can just double cast protego every night. I know we got a lot of death but that's a lot of power for one role.
  54. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    If you're gonna waste your time voting me because of paranoia, then so be it, but make sure you follow this
  55. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    VoidKitten said:
    Hermione Granger had spent most of the night in the restricted section looking for clues at what could be happening to everyone. She heard a noise and quickly dimmed her lantern and listened. Hermione saw Mazer walking into the library and decided to talk to him. The most recent book she read had a ton of information about Death Eaters so she was sure she could figure some things out.
    Click to expand...

    Caito said:
    A lot of of potential decent discussions now that we all actually have something to go off of instead of the ubiquitous D1 bullshit.

    This is all very interesting…..


    Vote Mazer/Homely Man
    Click to expand...

    PsychoSoldier said:
    Riveting

    And your thoughts on The Homely Man?
    Click to expand...

    Caito said:
    ………



    Are you serious?
    Click to expand...
  56. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    Psych should be able to see all the holes in this.

    I'm targeted by a red. And it wouldn't make sense for me to be a purple.

    And we've had power and role tomfoolery.
    Click to expand...
    You were targeted by red when they meant to target Randolph. Pay attention to the bus drive
  57. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Also beginning to think Lora's constant fucking with the rules is more malicious than usual
  58. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Ok, so, I'm not really around, but I have some thoughts.

    No Hermione again. Caito has been dead. And he posted this:
    Caito said:
    A lot of of potential decent discussions now that we all actually have something to go off of instead of the ubiquitous D1 bullshit.

    This is all very interesting…..


    Vote Mazer/Homely Man
    Click to expand...
    And then you have the fact that Kareemah was randomly screaming about Mazer, which is some odd info to have when you're as new as her. Which makes me think she knew Caito's role because she cannibal killed him.

    Vote: The Homely Man

    Next best place to start from my perspective
  59. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Well that's a lot of death, but at least Blind flipped Alliance.
  60. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I also think it would be good to look back at how people reacted around the Badger wagon with him confirmed as town now, and I think it's probably best to treat it as Caito was town based on the spreadsheet.
  61. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I have a 3-day game jam that just started today, so I'm probably not gonna be around much. But I got my spreadsheet filled out finally and Satsu is pretty much always town at this point. Lora, Xan, and morri are most likely not red since it looks like Voldemort picked his targets, and Blind can't be red either. Only way they could be is if Fred and George Weasley are one character and we're missing a red.

    Randolph is still not red.

    Purple is pretty open at the moment.

    Also, Caito is crossed off a lot of characters so far, and I'm assuming the official death with no flip confirms there was a cannibal kill

    Also, the info should be pretty obvious

    Vote: Kareemah
  62. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    DivaSmurf said:
    Also I’m sorry for not posting at all yesterday, i was terribly busy with V-day shit, and when there weren’t customers, there were online orders or I was filled with anxiety based on hype and warnings from the owner
    Click to expand...
    No worries. I think a few of us have been busy. Just try to catch up over the night phase and post what you can for the next day.
  63. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    PsychoSoldier said:
    But if we no lynch because we don't get the hammer, than then a punishment happens :\
    Click to expand...
    :shifty:
  64. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    But if we no lynch because we don't get the hammer, than a punishment happens :\
  65. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    DivaSmurf said:
    So I was doing my best to quickly skim as much as possible, so it looks like we are voting dreyski correct?
    Click to expand...
    It's either that or no lynch at this point, because I don't think 12 people are gonna come in and vote anyone else in the time we have left.
  66. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Listo95 said:
    Could also maybe be a RB? Harry lost his wand on the duel d1 and didn't act n1?
    Click to expand...
    That actually makes some sense. I could buy that if he can't share specifics.
  67. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    DivaSmurf said:
    Alright who took my wand! That’s not very nice
    Click to expand...
    Can you divulge what that did to you? My guess is it took your vote. Tread carefully and ask Void if you're not sure. We don't need any modkills.
  68. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    My guess is a lot of people are wishing to kill certain players they suspect.

    Speaking of which, we have 33 minutes left and I believe we're two short of the hammer.
  69. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    That's interesting. I need to noodle there. I was more thinking of the boost.
    Click to expand...
    My guess is it was an amplify/roleblock protection. It could maybe be a motivation, but it doesn't really read like that to me. So I think it guaranteed that Xan's action went through.

    I have no clue one what action Xan took, though, or if he was even active last night for it to matter.
  70. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    idk im more interested in sinking future he was all gung ho all its my house now and its peter'd off to nothing but shadowplay
    Click to expand...
    This is why I want to hear his thoughts about Dreyski. Ideally before he flips.
  71. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    Any thoughts on Xan with mechanics last night?
    Click to expand...
    I actually forgot him and 3pups got probably bus drove, in which case Moody is probably not a traitor, because he intended to protect 3pups which is a pretty pro-town move at that point.

    As far as what I think it means for Xanjori, if it was a traditional bus drive, I think 3pups was a top kill choice and throwing your partner right into the line of fire when you know you're not controlling the kill is a hell of a gambit.

    Though, this also makes me think that Xan is kind of an interesting person to protect on that night. And if I'm not misremembering, wasn't Argus Filch on the side of the Death Eaters in the conclusion of things? So if there is a traitor, Filch is an option and I could see him maybe protecting scum or something he thought was scum. I'm not really sold on that, though.
  72. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    3pups came in extremely confident on Badger. Claiming info, and even talking about his skill as a spreadsheeter.

    I believe I brought that up earlier, and asked 3puppies directly. The explanation he had previously given had made sufficient sense to me. It potentially even makes a little more sense now that his role is revealed. I don't fault anyone for asking questions to 3p, and trying to understand what he was saying. But as he revealed it, it was a high percentage play. He obviously made a newer player mistake.

    I understand how this set-up makes some people nervous, particularly if you've really never seen anything like it. This is going to rely on reads and associations. The scenario here is with now that we know what happened with 3 puppies, how would people react to that? It's looking at probabilities and tells at this point.
    Click to expand...
    I actually thought for a while that he was claiming Marauder's Map and didn't intend to target me, hence his explanations about Badger changing form
  73. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Also, for reasons, I think Matthieu and Satsu are  probably clean. Or at least not Death Eaters/Alliance
  74. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I don't think it's impossible that Xanjori is scum, but I don't think he's Peeves. At least, if he is, it's pure coincidence and the night actions don't reflect that, because I feel like Moody amplified his action rather than allowed him to act twice. And again, I don't think the action separated by lines was an actual night action.

    And I don't buy CWE's generic reasoning, especially when I think Xan's posts about Future were justified.

    Speaking of Future, he seems a bit more quiet this game, but I also know that he was camping last weekend, and apparently he had strep. But also the private chat thing is  interesting because if an outside player made that chat, I don't know why specifically Future was paired with 3pups. If somehow 3pups initiated the chat like Future postulated, it would make sense.

    I'd like to hear his response to me about the Dreyski wagon if nothing else.
  75. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    Honestly a lot of people. Still really early in the game and we are still gathering info. Just looking back at things I am not as convinced as others on Dreyski. I can go that way because we need the lynch though. Just hate taking out fellow town especially when it looks like we have two teams and a neutral to worry about.
    Click to expand...
    7bbenn.jpg
  76. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I may actually back off Claws just because I think as scum whenever I sus him, he's usually more quick to sus me back? Him taking a strong stance on me being town and just kinda being disappointed at my sus on him rings more towny to me.
  77. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    VoidKitten said:
    Day 3 Vote Count:

    9 - Dreyski (Psycho #965, Jarrod #969, Xanjori #1112, Lora #1144, Kareemah #1157, Randolph #1159, THM #1160, Matthieu #1162, Future #1171)
    2 - Jarrod (Dreyski #962, Claws #1007)
    2 - Xanjori (CWE #1132, Tildey #1161)
    1 - Claws (Val #1073)

    Not Voting: Diva, MTR, Satsu, Morrison, Listo, Peter Griffin, Lettuce

    With 21 players alive, majority is 12 votes on a single player.
    Click to expand...
    Oh jesus, I was looking at Discord earlier. I didn't realize how many were on the Dreyski wagon now lol.

    So, valid move, Lora
  78. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Lora said:
    Unvote:

    ill unvote just to prevent early lynching. but the RNG says dreyski must die today.
    Click to expand...
    Remember there's only 3 hours left in the phase.
  79. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    I am not sure I am sold on this Dresky train but at the same time we need to reach a majority.
    Click to expand...
    Who are the people you're curious about if not Dreyski?
  80. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    FutureHold said:
    Vote: Dreyski
    Click to expand...
    Any particular reason for joining this train?
  81. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    I’ve played plenty of games with Psycho and I’ve never seen this kind of snark. Very out of character for him. See also his response to Claws soon after.
    Click to expand...
    :lol:

    Maybe I'm not as snarky on Rajah as I am other places, but I regularly make posts like this and constantly worry someone's gonna take it more serious than it was intended
  82. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    How do I defend myself when people aren’t even giving a reason and are just sheeping each other?

    I wasn’t a fan of Psycho’s interaction yesterday - Jarrod’s a good player who can speak for himself, why was Psycho covering for him?
    Click to expand...
    Because I read Jarrod as innocent and the way you went about trying to jab at him felt more manipulative than earnest
  83. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    The one thing that stands out to me from the write up in regards to Xan is him getting that boost from Mad Eye and then Peeves appearing to act twice. But I think somebody else said that the way the second Peeves action is separated in the write up that it may be flavor and not mechanics?
    Click to expand...
    Yeah that was me, and I still stand by it
  84. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    Xanjori
    Future
    Mazer
    Psycho
    Diva

    My top 5.

    3 and 4 are kinda there because...I'm mean...they're alive? And they have both triggered red flags that I promised town I would point out next time I saw it.

    And someone tried to kill me. :squint:
    Click to expand...
    Care to expand on Diva at all? Since you're being tight-lipped about Future.
  85. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    I'm not on the future anymore so I'll use my new train...

    Classic tell me why we can lynch you tomorrow...

    fishing...

    Hops on the latest train.

    3 generic scum tells.

    :sherlock:
    Click to expand...
    I don't buy this at all tbh. I think Xanjori had every right to question you like he did since people were voting Future with no actual basis or reasoning shared in the thread.
  86. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    Garlic dip? I want some dip.

    I am not sure what to think about this chat that took place. Who would put two random people in a chat?
    Click to expand...
    Badger had a similar role last game, and I did the same with Jean Grey in my X-Men game

    Future/3pups is kind of an interesting combo, though.
  87. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    That's not how bone smells work?

    Unvote: future
    Vote: Xanjori
    :squint:
    Click to expand...
    How do you feel about Dreyski? Off memory I don't think you've talked about it even though he's one of the main topics of discussion this phase.
  88. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Xanjori said:
    Vote: Dreyski

    Badger had self-voted by this point, if he was on a team they'd have the go ahead to just finish him off. We also need to have a majority to avoid breaking rules. I honestly dont know what the best way to play this game is with no flips, town win using info from deaths, we dont have that info.
    Click to expand...
    I assume the info will eventually come, but with multiple threats about, we can't really afford to just sit on our hands until they come.
  89. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Xanjori said:
    But can they know if there are 3 teams? I think for any scum team literally anyone going from any other team is to their benefit. People defending him would more likely be on his team imo.
    Click to expand...
    From their perspective, the odds are greater that Badger is town. And even if he was on the other team, 3pupe vague explanation gives enough room for 3pups to be wrong that they could be trying to get on the right side of history since most of us were buying 3pups' info.

    Either way, I don't think defending Badger yesterday looks great, especially how wishy-washy people like Dreyski were about it.

    On that same token, some scum would likely take the golden ticket of claimed info if they're not teamed with Badger, so I don't think there's zero scum on that wagon - especially if he's town. I am just more wary of the people who thought twice about it.
  90. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Just a heads up that I won't be around much tonight due to Valentine's Day
  91. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Also not a fan of Claws' go at Jarrod
  92. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    100%…could include (I mentioned Snape as a potential traitor a while back)

    Contradiction much?
    Click to expand...
    This is not the gotcha you think it is

    Reaching much?
  93. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    Unvote: jarrod
    For now.

    :sherlock:
    Click to expand...
    Who else are you curious about, mr. Invincible?
  94. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Jarrod1983 said:
    Also anyone voting me right now is a dam fool.

    I seemed to be Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation.

    Also, 100% fact there are 5 red scums out there but this could include traitor characters. I have zero Harry Potter knowledge so not sure if a traitor character has been mentioned in write ups.

    Suck it scum.

    :panic:
    Click to expand...
    Mad Eye Moody immediately came to mind as a potential traitor

    Also Snape
  95. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Still no word from morrison, too
  96. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    Also
    Vote: Jarrod1983
    His being aggressive this early off the bat is triggering all types of non-town alarms. Plus, if one of us is accused of OMGUS, I’d rather it was him. :cool:
    Click to expand...
    I think Jarrod's energy was in the right place and the fact he bothered trying to solve Badger's posts as if he was scum is something I think is more likely to come from town.

    This reaction, however...

    Vote: Dreyski
  97. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I also still think the way he was reacting to the votes was more in line with scum Badger than town Badger
  98. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Regardless of his alignment, I'm still wary of those who were quick to defend Badger or give him wiggle room. If Badger was town, there would likely be scum knowing he was innocent and trying to look helpful.
  99. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    I hate the lack of flips. I’m assuming it means there’s a someone with a reviver/resurrection action out there and we won’t see flips until they use their action(s).
    Click to expand...
    Usually yes, but the flavor of Caito's death implies he was cannibalized, which means we won't get his flip until maybe the person who killed him dies.

    I think Badger is someone who could be revived, but it's also not impossible there's a role that needs to die before we see flips. I don't think Void is being that cruel though.
  100. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    I still need to go back and re-read again, but first things that stand out is Hermoine’s action. N1 she was armed with knowledge about Death Eaters. N2 it’s Alliance. Does that mean she can only check for one or the other depending on Odd/Even night?

    Did Peeves get two actions? Kill attempt on CWE plus taking Diva’s wand?

    Speaking of CWE - how many bpv’s are there in this game?
    Click to expand...
    That would make sense, and keep it from being too OP.

    I think Void does what I usually do where any actions separated by a line of hyphens is technically not a night action. So my guess is it's either a twilight action, a predetermined day action, or something that was specifically triggered.

    Knowing Void, there's probably a few BPVs lol
Top Bottom