Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Search results

  1. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    thanks for hosting it was fun i got a lil mad at the wishes but i got over it just in time to win the game
    I appreciated that you at least played along and interacted with me over my Hail Mary. I knew it wasn’t going to fly but I thank you for not just ignoring the effort. LOL
  2. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    And well played, @Xanjori - I didn’t have you on my radar remotely as Filch.
  3. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    It was a fun game, @VoidKitten.
  4. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Oh for the record.

    Claws should have been modkilled for the "SHOOT HIM SHOOT HIM SHOOT HIM" talk.

    But I had realized it way after processing the kill.
    I admit. I was fussing about that. lol
  5. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Thanks for running and for reaching out to me to be a sub. I really needed things placed on a platter for me this game though. It’s tricky coming in completely blind mid game when you weren’t following around before.

    Claws took a real gamble on me there near the end.
    He really did. If only he would have given that frisbee to the other sub. Bwahahahaha!!!
  6. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I was kinda hoping Robo would come in and say something.
    In fact the fact he hasnt said a word so far makes me wonder if he has been silenced.
    It’s definitely been disappointing that he subbed in but only seemed to have one burst of posting activity.
  7. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Any reason we haven't finished this day phase yet?
    Any other time everybody wants to use the entire day phase but here you are wanting to rush.

    Vote: Randolph
  8. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    331897393_1317939968768726_3343169222456502840_n.jpg
    LOL. Does that explain why we have a Harry Potter themed game going here with no Ron?
  9. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Who do you think is dumbledor?
    This is going to sound a little crazy (maybe its the cold meds), but I've been trying to think outside the box with the way wishes keep affecting things. I think its possible that Psych is Dumbledore. I went back through the different actions and I noticed that with the exception of Xan, all of Dumbledore's hides were on players that have since flipped as Deatheaters. I can't find any red or purple actions against Psych (which seems odd given that Mazer flipped red & Blind Ninja flipped purple). Psych was yeeted on D5 and the last Dumbledore action was N5 (maybe some wish that let him do one last action?). If the Dumbledore character is as important to the end game as it appears, Psych being Dumbledore even helps explain why he didn't flip and became a "ghost" instead. There's still a chance he can win if he can get us to misyeet enough people.
  10. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I think robo or tildey are both fine options for different reasons robo basically doing nothing why bother getting subbed in.

    tildey i have said shes been my 2nd fav this game is due to trying to be solvy for a new player.
    however her iso is looking poor and im not so sure her solving helped any steered away from ppl to houses ect so either is likely a decent option.
    I wasn't trying to steer anyone away from anybody. I was feeling frustrating that I couldn't get anywhere on solving the people based on the writeups and equally frustrated that the only info I could get anywhere on didn't seem to be useful (which I even made comment about).
  11. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Yeah I feel like Tildey was asking poor questions like the Red/Purple back and forth we had. I was very clear what colors I was talking about.

    You had two posts, days apart, that were almost exactly the same except for the color. I don't think it was crazy of me to make sure it was intentional. I was also clear in follow up that the reason for being sure was because I wanted to confirm the number of traitors we needed to find. Your posts suggested two. We know, now, that Dumbledore is a traitor. Based on your information is he the only traitor or is there still another we need to uncover?
  12. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Hey guys. I’m sorry. MTR gave me his cold that he’s had all week and it hit me during the night. I’ve been trying to get caught up all day but keep falling asleep while reading. I’m about half conscious now so going to try to eat some soup and get caught up a little. I feel bad about Dreyski. I didn’t have him as Hagrid because I thought we couldn’t self target.
  13. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    While I may be frustrated at the lack of info, I’m not going to do some rogue vote and risk a no lynch so that a random player dies. That means voting either Dreyski or Future. I’m leery of those “new robes” that Future just got so I don’t want to risk any traps there.

    Vote: Dreyski
  14. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I only gave one option :ROFLMAO:
    LOL. That doesn’t even surprise me.
  15. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Problem is houses were player selected
    Well, player driven. Not everybody got their first pick because we were sorted into houses evenly. But, that’s exactly my point. The one area that I feel like I can track or identify any info and it feels useless.
  16. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Gryffindor & Slytherin are tied for the most flipped deaths at 4 each & there’s been two flipped Hufflrpuff deaths. We also know from looking at all of the granted wishes that at least one Alliance member is a Hufflepuff and since both of the flipped Alliance deaths were Slytherin that player is probably still alive.
  17. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I almost feel like I’ve gotten more info looking into houses than anything, but then I don’t know what that has to do with anything so that’s been frustrating too. We know that everyone was sorted into houses evenly - so around 6 people per house. Based on deaths that have flipped we know Ravenclaws have the most living players.
  18. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Sorry I haven’t been able to post earlier today. I’ve had a lot of meetings at work. I saw that Val asked if anyone is still spreadsheeting. I’m still trying to I but I don’t feel like it’s doing me any good. Losing our cop & our tracker has really hurt us since it would seem a lot of the remaining roles don’t seem to turn up much info in the write ups. An example is Draco who only turned up once and with an action that didn’t appear to be aimed at anyone so we got zero information on who they aren’t. Dobby has acted three times, but 2 of those 3 were on MTR.
  19. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I did say that. Now I’m telling you about purple. Asking if colors are different makes me wary of you.
    I just wanted to make sure I understood. The last game I played I got taken out by a traitor. If someone that has info says I’m looking for two instead of one I want to make sure.
  20. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    5 Purple scum but that includes a would be traitor. So probably started with 4 maybe?

    Hopefully FutureHold's new robes isn't Future switching from town to scum.
    Before you said there was 5 red (I thought). Is this purple count new Dees or did I misunderstand the color of the prior Dees?
  21. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Some quick thoughts so far….
    -That’s two kills now for Filch. Interesting. But both are written as accidents.
    -I’m curious about Future’s new clothes. Was it a recruitment of some kind? Or maybe he has a bpv now (there seem to be a ton this game).
    -I hope Stump Pysch turns out to be as much fun as Stump Mazer was in Ghostbusters.
  22. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Not frustrated. I actually think I was as clear as I could be without crossing the line.



    I will say that I feel like I run games better than play them.

    Also I feel like since my split I have really been quite horrible. I don't scrutinize as much as I used to and my problem solving has been lackluster. Depression can take the speed off your fast ball I guess.

    I have been trying this game though and bringing legit information that I can gather to everyone. I even pretty much said you can put things together on me character-wise, that's no lie.

    You've seen the last couple scum games I've played. My play feels different when scum. I have definitely been part of the discussion even if you say I'm not.

    Also since I started playing these games if I say I'm town I'm generally town.
    For what it’s worth, I was honestly asking and not accusing. I’ve had trouble getting a read. Probably for the reasons you’ve shared & the fact that this is only the 3rd game I’ve played.
  23. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Still reading, obviously, but hard not to notice that Psycho is a clear favourite for lynch based on both start of day and very recent posts. Something like never getting targeted and that's suspicious? Mister Homely seems to be a pusher (as of the posts I've reached) of him, though it was at least in part as a counter to being called out himself. Psycho pointed out that Homely hadn't been targeted by somebody I think except when a bus driver was in effect on him? Always a headache, and certainly suspicious. A lot of other people with less overt reasoning than Homely at around the same time. I hear multi ball or w/e the terminology is now is in effect (and the day's write up indicates it too), so I honestly could see them both being scum on opposing teams. Kill em both and things probably go well or at least not terrible. Of course, this is just the currently clueless guy putting in his 2 cents.

    Questions...the first post seems to not be updated past day 3 for deaths and such, is there a good place to see a full list of the dead and their roles/alignments? It'd be nice to get an idea of how the game is going overall.

    Secondly, is this Homely person somebody I've seen before with like a name change or something? I don't recognize the name at all, but he seems the persuasive sort that probably has experience.
    If you click "Reader Mode" at the bottom or top of the page you can go through all of the Threadmarks to read the write ups and final vote counts. The only one not threadmarked is Day 3 end.
  24. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    jarrod has never done well in the spotlight in my opinion
    Which is a reason I would think a town person would help him if they could help clear him as town.
  25. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I'm pretty sure I know who you are

    Are you able to offer more info on this? Jarrod has seemed frustrated that he isn't able to offer clearly info to support his town status. It sounds like you may be able to help him?
  26. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Oh, yeah, if you want some kind of automated vote count for any point in the thread, we're still a ways off from that unfortunately.
    I figured as much. I like the threadmarking feature, though. And I could be wrong - but I thought that's what he was looking for (automated vote counting).
  27. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Is there some way to check vote counts quickly on here?
    Not until an update is posted. I've tried Reader mode and I can follow the Threadmarks that are out there but there doesn't seem to be an easy way to see where the counts stand (without going back through posts and counting) until the mod posts an update.
  28. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I’m trying to get caught up after a rough end of week work wise. Last day phase ended in mid kills before I could vote. I don’t want to jump on a train when I’m behind on reading but I also don’t want to killed for missing two vote.

    Vote: Future as a placeholder vote, not because I’m implying anything. Once I’m caught up, I expect to change votes.
  29. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    As it stands according to the writeups - three different characters visited Kareemah on N3. Including Fred, who hid behind Kareemah. Yet in N1's writeup Fred was shown using a different ability on Listo.

    Which suggests to me that Fred isn't specifically a hider.
    I’m thinking either JOAT or maybe masons with George and a shared list of 1x abilities.
  30. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Either that or Voldemort correct
    In the write up Grindenwald is who killed Caito.
  31. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Mazer is the one who killed Caito, Hermione never showed up on the write up so I figured it was related based on my spreadsheet, Caito has voted Mazer immediately after checking on him, there’s good evidence against him but I wanted to confirm, no one else seemed to notice and I’ve been waiting bc I didn’t want to call him out and look like scum but fuck it, I’m very positive I am right about this and anyone is free to double check if they don’t want to lose another townsmember
    Vote: The homely man
    So you think Mazer is Grindenwald?
  32. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I’ve got back to-back meetings all afternoon so I want to go ahead and enter a vote (just in case). Based on the concerns I have with the write up and the Peeves possibility, I’m going with Xan for now. I am open to changing later, if needed, to reach majority and avoid a random kill.

    Vote: Xanjori
  33. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Do you see any potential mechanic reasons for suspicion last night related to Xan?

    I am leaning to dreyski. Right now, I'm more confident in my list of people I don't want to kill than those I want to. There's some interaction with Jarrod. Re: jarrod - I have never really seen him put himself out there much as scum until he's forced to. So, I think his activity strikes me true. And I felt like I didn't like some of the explanation and process around 3pups. And obviously it seems that 3p making a mistake was the right interpretation.

    Because of the correlations, my main interest is dreyski.

    I'm also thinking the need to hammer is going to get in the way of some of my ability to read the momentum and late pushes. VK frustrating me rn.
    The one thing that stands out to me from the write up in regards to Xan is him getting that boost from Mad Eye and then Peeves appearing to act twice. But I think somebody else said that the way the second Peeves action is separated in the write up that it may be flavor and not mechanics?
  34. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    3pups and I were placed in a private thread last night. We were talking about the game and what to do
    Last night? As in last night phase?
    Can you share how/why you came to be placed in a chat together?
  35. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Probably mentioned it in scum chat...

    :squint:
    But 3pups flipped town?
  36. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    @FutureHold - I am hoping you're feeling better. Glad the strep test was negative. Any thoughts on Snape's potion, or listening to private chat?
    I remembered something this morning that I had forgotten to follow up on yesterday.
    @FutureHold - how did 3pups know you had been tested for Strep? I did a thread search and I don’t see any posts from you mentioning being sick or getting checked.
  37. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Was he scum?
    It doesn’t matter to CWE. He & Caito have a long-standing mafia feud. lol
  38. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Cannibal is a sk that kills ppl but they never flip
    I don't like the sounds of that. :(
  39. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Usually yes, but the flavor of Caito's death implies he was cannibalized, which means we won't get his flip until maybe the person who killed him dies.

    I think Badger is someone who could be revived, but it's also not impossible there's a role that needs to die before we see flips. I don't think Void is being that cruel though.
    I’m unfamiliar with how the cannibal mechanic works. This would be my first time encountering it. I’ll have to look it up.
  40. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    @VoidKitten I assume there's no mistake, but still no Badger flip, right?
    I hate the lack of flips. I’m assuming it means there’s a someone with a reviver/resurrection action out there and we won’t see flips until they use their action(s).
  41. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I still need to go back and re-read again, but first things that stand out is Hermoine’s action. N1 she was armed with knowledge about Death Eaters. N2 it’s Alliance. Does that mean she can only check for one or the other depending on Odd/Even night?

    Did Peeves get two actions? Kill attempt on CWE plus taking Diva’s wand?

    Speaking of CWE - how many bpv’s are there in this game?
  42. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Has our wonderful proff trelawny chimrd in yet
    The write up said she would not be posting this phase but that she would get wishes.
  43. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    hasn't actually indicated any reads like he normally does.
    Good point. And it helps me reconcile my concerns.
    Vote: Badger
  44. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The only thing that worries me is that the guy with the 3 puppies Is exposing himself pretty early to late night shenanigans. I hope this pays off at least
    I think this is what has me so conflicted. In my limited experience, 3pups seems to be a pretty cautious player and only claims something when he’s sure. But Badger’s posts are reading town to me. I just wish I could figure out from the write up whatever info it is that 3pups feels so confident about.
  45. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    A likely story...
    Fridays are when we have our department meetings at work. Because we’re a call center that isn’t allowed to shut down we split the staff into small groups and proceed to present the same info to the different groups of staff all day. By end of day, my brain is complete mush between being in every meeting and repeating the same info over and over.
  46. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    So basically, if it's not coincidence(like someone was randomly chosen or Claws died because of a different rule), someone dies if we don't hammer, and the last person to vote on the biggest wagon dies as punishment.
    If this turns out to be the mechanic, then I guess it’s good you got those emotes fixed. This one is going to get a lot of use…:bandwagon:
  47. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I noticed this as well, and wondered if the Alliance (purple) only has an EN kill, while the Death Eaters (red) has an odd kill ?
    Ooh! That’s an interesting theory. And I’m an idiot for not thinking of it. *facepalm*
  48. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Well shit, people really wanted Blind Ninja dead
    I was thinking that, too.
  49. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Interesting. The Alliance appears to be missing from last night’s activities.
  50. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I spent far too much time on that today.
    Well done! Here’s hoping we’re in the same house. lol
  51. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For 3rd sentence, I am thinking it starts with "Whoever houses"
    How about..."Whoever wishes"
  52. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The last word could be Fair to rhyme with Snare..."Whoever houses _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ phrases fair"
    Nope. Fair doesn't work. Doesn't leave enough vowels to form the other two words I don't think.
  53. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    For 3rd sentence, I am thinking it starts with "Whoever houses"
    The last word could be Fair to rhyme with Snare..."Whoever houses _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ phrases fair"
  54. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    @3puppies Your answer for the first phrase makes sense to me. I had figured out "Do not fear the" but was struggling on the rest. Had come up with "rivals needs" but it didn't make sense. Yours is better.

    For the second phrase I've got "Clear your mind and calm down."

    I'm still coming up blank on phrase three. And so far on phrase four I've got "Voidkitten is the best moderator ___ __ ________ ______"
  55. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    A majority is not going to be reached. I think you are safe for now unless one of those two are scum and then well I wish you the best.
    Not scum. And I like the game too much to persist voting him when it could actually cause a misyeet. So he's safe from me unless he gets all sus and/or outs himself.
    I'm watching, though. :squint::sherlock:
  56. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    it's the House of FutureHold

    Someone is getting too big for their britches

    No, I killed the namesake of the house, is it not mine then?

    We are named after a wrestling faction. This is not game of thrones.

    So what I got is that you are Edge and I'm kicking you out of your own faction

    Again someone is getting too big for their britches.

    Future: I'm the head of the table now. Acknowledge me.:wiggle:

    MTR: The fuck you are. Get off my lawn. :irked::grumpy::beer::slap:
    Me: :popcorn:
  57. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?

    I think scum teams of 3-4 is pretty typical. With there appearing to be two scum teams I can't imagine there being more than 4 each. So maybe two more, at most?
  58. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Fuck that. Go with what I feel my house would be if this was real.
    That was my approach, too. I didn’t get my first choice, but I’m satisfied with my second.
  59. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Do we think Lora had the cloak as an ability, or do we think VK did it to ensure Lora had a chance to play the game. Lora died N1 last game and I dont think he's done any Rajah games.
    This was definitely my thought when I saw it.
  60. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Good job bonus kid.
    To be fair, I think it’s more that I have beef with Caito than the other way round. But he knows what he did so he just ignores my ranting. LOL
  61. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Vote: Caito u and tildey seem to have beef so I’m siding with tildely 🫡
    Good job bonus kid.
  62. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Have a base template with you in the 1st spot and around 20 ish openings after. Then just modify anytime you need on a game by game basis. It will save a lot of time in the long run.
    I’ve got a standard base template that I use. It’s more that if I don’t keep up (at least the minimum) I won’t go backward to catch up.
  63. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I haven't even thought about procrastinating while delaying making my spreadsheet.

    AKA...ask me on day 4 if I'm alive.
    I never know what fresh hell is going to come up at work so if I don’t draft it early there’s a good chance it won’t happen.
  64. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Oh, and has anyone done a character/player tally based on current info? I’m technology-limited at the moment.
    Wonder if Snape is a traitor character for OOP?
    I’ve gotten the bones of my spreadsheet started. We’re still 6-7 characters short of the number of players (depending on if you count the Marauder’s Map as a character).
  65. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Order of the Phoenix is town.

    Something I found interesting is that Marauder’s Map is in blue. So is the map somehow a character in its own right? A mousekatool perhaps?
  66. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    What’s ewop again
    A typo. LOL
    It should have been EBWOP (Edit By Way Of Post) since we aren’t allowed to edit our posts in game threads.
  67. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    EWOP *had started
  68. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Oh god, I didn’t realize we started and missed so much 😭 but I’m ready 😼 how do we find cult if we can’t call out our roles
    Your roomie didn’t even let you know things he started. Just let you suffer through your double shift with no entertainment?
  69. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Anyone else upset that this got changed to alphabetical order instead of number you signed up for?
    On the contrary. It puts Void in the running for my favorite mod. ❤️
  70. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    did you kill your entire family or portions of it 2 games in a row?
    He hasn’t killed me. Caito did - two games in a row.
  71. Tildey

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    It's an absolute win win.
    Agreed.
    Vote: Caito
Top Bottom