Search results

If you're bleeding, then there's not much to lose by claiming - in fact, it'd increase your chances of being saved if you're a valuable role and add further wifom at night when it comes to actions.

I don't get results as to what killed Val until the day phase ends. I'll dump it in my logbook so it can be shared in the event someone tries to kill me tonight. I haven't decided what to do about Jack.

Blind Ninja said:

Then give me reasons to think you are town, or at least not a threat to town.

Click to expand...

Alright, how about a claim? I'm the physician and hoped to lay somewhat low as I often do when assigned an important TPR role. Happy? Going to back off now?

Want me to prove it by inoculating Foxxi or someone else? You know, the sort of ploy I had in mind like during the last game to prove myself innocent and trustworthy?

Er

Vote: Blind Ninja

It's your own bias.

Wasn't Listo the fool last time this game was run? I'd laugh if it were the same this time around.

JackSparrow said:

Im not a fool

Click to expand...

I believe you.

If Jack is lying about a post restriction and/or being made to bleed then that only really makes sense if we believe he's the fool and trying to get yeeted in which case we don't want that to happen as we lose a charge to every ability and can't eliminate anyone the following day phase.

Alternatively a fool could just fake information to try and get someone yeeted with the intention of being yeeted themselves when it proves false.

D1 is generally always hit or miss. We're a blended community and one half generally prefers to take the D1 = sleep approach and the other half leans more towards taking out a perceived inactive or just making a blind shot in the dark and hoping for the best.

Blind Ninja said:

You know this just reads as "Im too lazy to read the game rules"

Click to expand...

You know full well that I always read the rules, though. Especially in a game where I can pull off plays.

Blind Ninja said:

Maybe you could read the OP and see what the rules say about claiming

Click to expand...

I wanted to see who was actually paying attention and willing to be helpful.

rock meets hard place said:

Sure man, whatever you need to tell yourself. This game seems a little complex so I'm not sure how reliable night actions will be. Also, think void kitten said that write-ups aren't going to have much information so when you say "im going to let this game be dictated by na's and write ups" all I hear is "let's put less emphasis on scumhunting/day phase."

Click to expand...

It's almost like I was placing emphasis upon the former element rather than the latter. Which, in turn, ties into my earlier question posed regarding whether claiming is allowed or not.

I don't think my post actually did 'ping' you so much as you're just letting BN's post saying the exact same thing dictate your judgement of me. Which is strange, since nothing I've said this day phase is remotely controversial and you seem to be ignoring that at least one player spoke up in my favour. Namely Xanjori. Nightingale voted for me, yes, though has since removed that vote.

If you have specific questions, ask them. It's too early for me to make any real judgement and I'd rather let night actions and write-ups dictate the direction of the game.

Incidentally, are we allowed to claim in this game or was that something limited to the previous iteration of this game?

rock meets hard place said:

or rather Matthieyu and Morrison are decent votes.

but I thought that was funny

Click to expand...

I don't believe that we've ever played together before, so how would you know if I'm a decent vote or not unless you're just following the crowd? I'm genuinely struggling to see what I have said this day phase that is even remotely controversial.

Unvote
Vote: Sleep

I'm going back to this. I don't see much point in randomly taking someone out under the guise of 'getting information' when it would be much more reliable to let those who can bring something to the table in terms of solid info unfettered.

Unvote
Vote: Nightingale

Going with my gut on this, but after seeing how well I played during the last version of this game I genuinely believe that a scum aligned Foxxi would try to get rid of me early given how much frustration I caused with my role the last time around.

Blind Ninja said:

What about the discussion of potentially 2 restrictions?

Where do you stand on that? If 1 were faking it, who do you think is the fake?

Click to expand...

I'm going to assume it's legit, since restrictions can and have targeted multiple players.

Between the two, though, I think if either of them were to fake it then it'd likely be Claws. If only because Foxxi posted first.

Though like I said, I think it's legit. An annoyance for them both (and anyone who can't understand French) but at least it's happening on D1 and not at a more critical point.

On a more serious note, there was...ten (?) or so posts made by the time I decided to check in. Barring me commenting on each and every one for the sake of seeming busy, I dunno what BN expects. If I see something that piques my interest, I'll bring it up.

So far, the 'haha lets kill the king' was the most pressing thing to me.

Pourquoi ne pas tous taper en français pour frustrer Voidkitten et lui faire tout traduire ?

Blind Ninja said:

Your opening post just pings me...

Click to expand...

Why?

Vote: Sleep

Let's at least give Robozerim some time to prove whether he's a benevolent monarch or not.

D1 being what it is I would prefer not to go after anyone at all unless we end up with a no show.