This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
In fairness, me not wanting you and claws telling each other to fuck off and having matthieu's being a dick come up.... was not about this game.
What were their roles?
Good reads. I know the results have been tough, but I feel like you've leveled up recently.
I thought you were good after day 1. I have long been on record on saying I don't like to see the frustrated, mad card on here.
No I would not vote badger. He's like my number 2 town.
They both have bad records. I just have some explanation for blind ninja. If future dies and is town, my legacy read is kill blind ninja tomorrow. If he's scum, look at tildey, and the rest of the counter train, obviously.
You did your poe.
Did you answer my badger and tildey question?
Happy almost birthday to your daughter and happy birthday to blind ninja.
In fairness, that set up could not have been fun for you.
If he's scum does that mean we misread the kills?
If he flips v, guns of navarrone at bn.
In fairness, I wasn't trying to say it was the same thing. It's more of the general change in reads. I saw earlier it seemed you were very open to my interpretation of mtr. And it did read ax him kind of focusing specifically on you vs. Claws.
Definitely not free either
Fair enough. So, you think tildey is wrong about amount?
It reads as tmi. We've played dozens of games now, and I've never seen someone read order of operations read into a watcher target.
I guess that's an interesting perspective.
I've never talked to.foxxi about it. But she and void talk. Role madness was typically assumed to be about a 30% non town ratio in our conversations.
I'd love to get from blind ninja and tildey before I give mine.
I usually don't give order as info. And I'm not 100 that it's how the write ups are working. But obviously the write ups as info.
Do we know the order of visits?
I went back through my thoughts.
Is the question what do I think out of the people claws saw?
I'm reading this as you saying the drawback on future is that tildey (who you think is scum) thinks his town tells have gotten better?
I agree that we need to be careful. We need to make a good decision.
Strongman?
Which ones? Because I just went through a lot of spelling things out.
Again, mtr did a lot of stall posts for someone who "did not have time". Which leads me to believe that there was probably a decent amount of scum chat coordination going on.
Kind of punts on the House reads here.
Another defense of Future's vote. Defends the banter.
Claws calls him out on the amount of nothing posts, and he goes to defense.
Hey look Ma....it's another House defense.
Looking back - The first 3 on him were listo, claws, and badger. So if we're right about claws and Badger, this means he was throwing shade at 3 townies.
Defends Future.
And now we're going to debate math. But still reiterates that he believes all are clean, but if not all, he feels good about two.
Town reads Xan and Insaner. AGAIN says at least one person on his train is suss, and tries to go for a push on claws again.
Goes back at Claws here again. Interesting that the focus is not just on him, still mentioning the House.
Now this is where things pivot because Listo's dees comes out.
Here's some reads from before mtr is feeling too pressured.
Delays a lot during these phases. This is an example.
Middle reads for claws (an obvious town by this point) and Tildey.
He was legitimately busy I guess, but you'd also have to wonder if this is where they are coordinating strategy.
Some back and forth with claws and CWE that happened earlier.
Lol. Guess he knew about that kill.
Defends his train place, so there might be something there. Wondering if the team decided to move together late on that vote?
I think both of these are valid considerations. And there was something I was thinking of as well. I'm going to catch up, and then possibly see if I can go find.
I don't disagree with this, but I still can't get behind the listo theory
There are things I forget.
I think the closest interpretation of calling out logic might be you thinking he was tracker.
CWE had put a decent amount out, so it's not that this was some secret. CWE had him has a possibility, but not a certainty. Say what you will about CWE, but he doesn't play with fear. I'm not sure it changes the equation dramatically.
lol. The timing on this post and the one I just did.
Mtr being the one off voter is intriguing. Honestly, I was curious if someone would feel like they would have to hammer or jump a train when I did the "I'm watching for something'. I was fishing for a nervous player. And it was interesting that we didn't see the same "energy" as we did on the Morrison train.
When I really push people have a tendency to vote themselves or get modkilled. It's counterproductive, until I'm mostly sure I'm right. But that's fine. Because, I don't expect anything until I lead a righteous kill.
None that I know of. But I don't know every theory and possibility. If you're using it to clear yourself....that's a reason?
Not an unfair point. I've known Badger a long time, and I strongly believe he is town. Frankly, I don't even like why I know, because I didn't like the day 1 interaction. Badger also knows if he pulls that ATE as a scum, like he did a much lesser version of 1 time, and for the next several games afterwards he will know no peace.
I think we've seen this in Foxxi's games a few times previously.
People can pretty much tell a story for any action. I don't think what you're saying in unreasonable, or something that I'm scum reading. Because with zero righteous kills, it's a helluva thing to want a hard clear just based on possibly letting someone die later rather than before.
No. It doesn't work then
It has 3 leans in it for me, and one neutral. Which makes me feel good.
Too soon badger......too soon.
Points for a solid copy/paste.
Like clockwork
It just hurts ti have left so little of an impression.
I don't see this one
Tildey you're pretty confident in?
I'm still catching up. And I'm freezing my ass off at a windy field.
I don't see cwe making anything up. But I feel like this just strengthens my town read on claws
Why are their votes worse than the others? Worse than future or you just townread future?
He said not that though
7 2 2 3 4 3 4 3 5
I TAKE THIS VERY PERSONAL. WHY DO YOU PUT FAMILIES ON THE STREET?
I sometimes I imagine playing Monopoly with our group. Someone would say "HOW DARE YOU TRY TO BANKRUPT ME! THIS IS A FAMILY HOTEL AND YOU JUST TAKE IT OVER LIKE IT'S NOTHING! I WOULD NEVER DO THIS TO YOU!"
This is a hint. Which character sounds the most like a harry potter character.
Man, I have to coach my fifth game this weekend soon. I'm already spent
I was just assuming you had motion dees.
Yeah....I'm not going to get that
That nobody else seems to be worried about what I'm worried about.
I do agree that what I would expect to be "leans" are being expressed as "clears".
Well that was not what I was guessing from insaners posts
I would totally use you as bait again. I just would have to do it a different way so it was more unexpected. People wouldn't buy that response from me again.