What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Search results

  1. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    GG everyone. Good game, Void
  2. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    You also hit hammer, so I'm confused
  3. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Wait, why can't you yeet me? Is maj necessary?
  4. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Execute
  5. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I targeted Foxxi for circle of death on N1

    All my reads are legit. Voting me is smart, but you guys need to seriously start looking at the cult if you want to win. They have at least one person on the loose from N1 guaranteed and most likely have a second by now, or at least will be guaranteed to have one on N5. Don't just trust the claims. Converted cult members have a ready made claim, and if you're not careful, they're gonna overtake you.

    Have fun, y'all. Good target, LDG.
  6. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Psycho

    Let's run it
  7. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I believe Badger wasn't recruited before N2 so less likely to be cult, and we know at least as late as D4 he wasn't cult. Assumingly MTR found out Xan isn't cult last night, so less likely he was converted, and definitely not converted before last night. Satsu also wasn't cult and if he is would have had to have been converted last night, and I have suspicions either he or Jarrod is the reaper.

    I trust MTR isn't cult due to how he went about claiming info about Xan.

    We know CWE isn't cult.

    Morrison could be a cult king, but I still have good feels there and he wouldn't have been a recruit.

    That leaves Val, Foxxi, LDG, kareemah, Matthieu, Future, and one of Jarrod/Satsu

    I think kareemah has too much of a target on her that could backfire if recruited, so unless she was recruited N1, unlikely

    Matthieu is right that trying to convert him is a risk that I'm not sure cult would have taken before maybe last night.

    That leaves Val, Foxxi, LDG, Future, one of Jarrod/Satsu

    Val is the one that stands out as having changed tack and been more opportunistic the last couple phases. The way he jumped right to voting Xan and then immediately followed up with Badger, who was increasingly likely to have been reaped, is not a good look for me, and not the place I think town!Val would poke.

    LDG is LDG and my whole argument there has been that just because we know she's an observer doesn't clear her in this setup. Though, now that I think about it, I don't think she'd be able to track after being converted? So since she correctly tracked me, she's probably not cult right now.

    Foxxi hasn't seemed to be looking for cult at all the last couple phases which is interesting, but I'm willing to write it off and focusing on what's right in front of her and not giving her overall thoughts as much to try and stay alive for once. But it's definitely standing out that she's zeroing in on me instead of having a wider view.

    Future is probably a toss-up, as is Jarrod/Satsu (though less likely Satsu is cult due to MTR's claim)

    Hence, my vote is on Val
  8. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    If badger was silenced instead of reaped, only the reaper could have silenced him for the whole day. All the other roles that can potentially silence only do so for 12 hours, so he would be able to talk by now. If he doesn't say anything by the end of this day he either got reaped, or silenced by the reaper to frame you. And as I mentioned earlier, the reaper could only have two - maaaaybe three - souls when this day began, and spending two of them to frame you doesn't seem all that likely to me.

    The cold hard truth is this: If badger is dead tomorrow morning, your claim to be a knight that protected him last night cannot be true.
    Click to expand...
    The cold hard truth is that I targeted Badger to defend him regardless of what happened to fuck with the results.
  9. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    I think Val is Val. I haven't had any issues with him, but I do think your focus on both him and LDG - two of the arguably easiest targets to go after, is not like you as town.
    Click to expand...
    That's not really an answer. Cult is out there and while the reaper is also a threat, you seem unphased by the fact they could be growing and they have to be hiding somewhere. Why are you only zeroing in on the reaper?

    Also, LDG is whatever, but I genuinely think Val's tone changes in the last couple phase and that's problematic.

    Who do you think is cult? And if I flip and you see I'm town, who do you think is reaper? Because you should know better than anyone else alive that just because people have roles to claim doesn't mean they're still town.
  10. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Foxxi, what do you think of Val?
  11. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    I don't buy this. First, if you are a knight that targeted badger with a defend, he would not be reaped. It's possible the real reaper saw you were tracked to badger and silenced him before he could talk to try to frame you? But if badger does die to a reap, your knight claim cannot be true. Secondly - I had actually thought you were hinting at physician earlier in the game when you insisted the kills N1 had an explanation other than cult, and badger and I haven't had any private conversations since D2, so no - he didn't tell me your claim and I have no idea why you would assume that he had.
    Click to expand...
    I figured he may have targeted you again for a night chat. I also thought you guys whispered after that, but looking at it, that's not the case. It doesn't change the fact that I claimed to Badger, whether you know it or not.

    The silence on Badger is a maybe, and would be the most likely scenario to explain how today's gone down. Though honestly, not sure how quickly the reaper would have been able to get to it. Unless cult can somehow silence and wanted to frame me.

    Again, I don't understand the full mechanics of this setup but I targeted Badger for defense last night. That's a fact.
  12. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Which is funny because I had it down to Jarrod or Satsu as the most likely to be neutral based on claims and crumbs so far
  13. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Satsu said:
    Thats what I am assuming. There arent that many roles with night attacks.
    Click to expand...
    I mean...if that's the case, it's not a great look for you from my perspective
  14. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    For the record, I feel like Val has been over aggressive in the last couple phases, and in my experience, that usually comes from scum Val. I don't think he was cult early due to his vote on Claws, but I'm thinking he was converted after N2. The fact he jumps to vote Badger despite a lot of signs pointing to him being either silenced or killed is a terrible look and comes off more opportunistic than actually trying to drum something up to help town.

    So I think Val is cult, but not the one who would have been converted on N1.
  15. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Satsu said:
    I protected myself from an attack last night. it couldnt have been a reaper because reap is unhealable, and cult attacks 2 targets so where are deaths?
    It leaves alechemist and knight. CWE said he didnt do anything so that leaves a kinght. Psycho targeted Badger so he isnt a knight.
    Unless I miss a role.
    Click to expand...
    I don't see how this adds up at all. I assume you think you were attacked by a knight?
  16. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    I called psycho evil on day 1.
    😎

    Even a broken clock is right from time to time.
    Click to expand...
    It's too bad it's wrong this time
  17. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    The longer he is silent, the more obvious it is badger was reaped. So I'm just going to come out and say it - Badger is the mystic. We spoke N1 and he expressed suspicion about psycho then. We had whispers later where he still told me wasn't sure about psycho. I think badger reached out to talk to psycho, and psycho being the clever person he is knew that even if he fooled badger right then, badger may go on to talk to other people who would not be fooled. So he reaped him. Psycho was seen visiting Badger by LDG; and when asked why he was there, he said he was defending badger. A knight defending badger would have prevented a reap - which clearly does not seem to have happened.
    Click to expand...

    Foxxi's telling the truth about Badger. He targeted me for a N2 chat and it was kinda obvious who he was to me, but when he made the comment about why I used the scum posting gimmick again, that confirmed it for me(as that was a part of our conversation).

    I don't know what could have happened that Badger died even though I defended him, but that's what happened. I'm pretty sure he also told you about my knight claim so you know it's legit.
  18. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Xanjori said:
    I still dont trust Psycho

    Vote: Psycho

    He just doesnt seem overly involved or solvy this game.
    Click to expand...
    I've been pretty occupied IRL. Not really a great reason
  19. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    In the meantime, if the claims and crumbs that are about
    Val the Moofia Boss said:
    Ball needs to get rolling but I'll pose an alternative lynch, just to see how people position themselves.

    Vote: Badger
    Click to expand...
    This is an icky vote

    Vote: Val
  20. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    There's still a cult about, but not Xan

    Might need to look back through Claws ISO
  21. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Unvote: Xanjori
  22. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    MTR, why did you choose to check Xan by the by?
  23. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    MTR said:
    Going back through role cards and only way Xan is not cult is if the Apostle targeted me to cause a framed result. So I guess there is that possibility which will leave some doubt but I am sticking with my vote at this time.
    Click to expand...
    Actually, this isn't impossible considering your role should have been obvious to those paying attention
  24. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    LemonDemonGirl said:
    Psycho, what were you and Badger doing last night? You visited him.
    Click to expand...
    I'm honestly not sure I trust telling you tbh

    But I defended him
  25. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Xanjori

    Starting this off. Been obvious who MTR was since the last phase(I think it was?) where he was claiming people as not cult

    Also doesn't really seem like a worthy gambit if he's actually cult trying to cut people off
  26. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Execute

    I think we've got about everything we're gonna get out of this day. Let's finish it.
  27. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    morrison said:
    i've dealt with a migraine all of today and am about to go pass back out and sleep until i gotta wake up for work in eight hours. no clue what has gone down outside of listo being on trial, cause i've only read from foxxi's tagging of me and checking void's post to see who was nominated. won't be catching up until the morning, if work volume permits. if satsu is making a claim or implication that they know me to be cult, they were either tampered with or outright lying.
    Click to expand...
    Any thoughts on the Listo chop before he goes over?
  28. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    What 2 roles can I be?
    Click to expand...
    Alchemist or Physician
  29. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Also, I feel like Jarrod's posts today have had more of that town!Jarrod fire I've come to expect from him.
  30. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Matthieu said:
    If we're concerned that the cult still exists, then it's possible that anybody has been converted. Though to convert me to the cult, there's a greater degree of WIFOM involved given that any potential cult members surviving would have to gamble that hit me on a night phase when I'm not defending myself against killing and conversion. Which, assuming that a hypothetical cult member still exists seems rather risky to me. Better to go with a safer recruitment option in that case, no?
    Click to expand...
    I believe Mazer recruited on N1, and if that's the case, it's impossible for him to have failed due to the bad luck protection, and we have to be dealing with at least one other cult member. But yeah, I forgot about the Hunter protection, so it's probably less likely that you would have been the conversion.

    CWE is maybe convertible depending on which of the two roles he is, but there's still LDG who we have no real confirmation on and didn't get much other than her role after she was on trial.

    So, if there's any cult smoke to that fire, I'd be looking at LDG again.
  31. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    As for Listo himself, the claim seems alright, but pulled off in a very similar manner to Claws' claim(at the very last second before the wagon could be hammered). Plus, I think Val probably isn't lying about whatever he has that leads him to believe Listo targeted Future instead of me, so he's in the least caught in a mechanical contradiction. I've also just not liked his participation all game and have said as much. Like Foxxi already said, he's being helpful with roles and being active while not really contributing to reading people. Not a great look, especially when we consider how quick he was to try and say a reaper is unlikely back on D2.

    I'd like to see if morrison will come and say anything and not rush the execute, but that's where my vote will end up.
  32. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    VoidKitten said:
    8 - Listo (Foxxi #960, Kareemah #993, Xanjori #996, Badger #997, MTR #1004, Future #1009, Val #1011, Satsu #1028)
    Click to expand...
    Also, as soon as Foxxi picked Listo, a lot of people followed suit again. Barring any recent conversions, I trust Badger still, and I think MTR's reaction to the possibility of CWE having info was really towny. I feel like Val has been a little extra aggressive this phase which I feel like I see more often from scum!Val. Kareemah just following along isn't a great look either, but she does get the new player buffer.

    I think Foxxi has it right with Xan that pulling this off as scum has a lot of opportunity to blow up in his face, and came out too quickly to feel like something really thought out like he would probably do as scum. I also feel like the restriction is legit and came from someone trying to make him look worse.
  33. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    Why do you and Psycho both poke snakes instead of shooting it?

    Vote: Satsu
    Click to expand...

    Matthieu said:
    Vote: Satsu

    For pressure, then.
    Click to expand...

    LemonDemonGirl said:
    Uhm ahctually, I don't have a letter name 🤓

    Vote:
    Vote: Satsu
    Click to expand...
    Knowing that they all unvoted the moment Foxxi clarified she was accusing Satsu of being a fool, I don't feel great about this pile on and feel like we'd find cult or neutral in here

    I know Matthieu has claimed, but it's possible he could have been converted by now
  34. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Sorry guys, was with my partner after work all day yesterday and wasn't paying attention to my phone. I'll catch up and give some thoughts later.
  35. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    morrison said:
    yeah, i kinda want to think on this a bit. we know she is claiming an action on foxxi n2 and it failed. what would make one of the observer's night actions fail? obvs a direct rb on her would do that, but would ldg be a target for a rb going into n2? what else leads to failure of a watch/track?
    Click to expand...
    This is actually a really good point
  36. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    Am mildly sus of BN and Xan - the first for seeming to establish himself fairly well in the last phase, and then feeling like he ghosted this one. The second because I would expect a lot more from him as town. But that's just based off the top of my head on gut feel.
    Click to expand...
    Xan could be a neutral, but I highly doubt is cult. Same with BN, and honestly, while I see your point, I feel like BN was too talkative the first two phases to be a lone threat.
  37. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Does LDG's claim preclude then from being a cult or are we just going on "That was the only reason Foxxi suspected them"?
  38. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I just want to get any thoughts from her because if she's innocent it would help her odds.

    I'm not against a pardon. I just wish she would focus less on the frustration of the position and work with us, and I'll try to work with her in return
  39. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    LemonDemonGirl said:
    Oh my fucking god
    Click to expand...
    I know this position is frustrating. But can you please share if you have any suspects? Just one or two.
  40. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    Unvote: Kareemah
    Vote: LDG
    Click to expand...
    I see I'm late, but I'm still curious about the answers
  41. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    As for LDG... I feel like she a schrodingers box of mafia. She's a super easy target to fall on, but also someone likely to be ignored. I don't have anything to sus her on other than poe and I don't like it
    Click to expand...
    Ok, so why feel so strongly about kareemah?

    Also, let's not forget that any people converted have a pretty clean claim and that doesn't really mean much in the long run, so I'm not quick to give thaf pass to Future when he hasn't really been contributing to discussion past self-defense.
  42. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Also, I figured you were the butler when you hinted at being able to poison the king.

    Fwiw, I think Morrison is probably fine.
  43. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Kareemah said:
    What do you mean? And guys I’m Butler, not pulling a claws but genuinely the Butler. That’s why no one has been able to do actions on me and why I’m pushing so hard to see if Morrison is good or not
    Click to expand...
    What do I mean as in my reason for considering you as cult? It's that you voted Xanjori at a time when Claws was starting to get legit heat. Ergo, scum/cult/non-town team members generally vote for people other than their partners in an attempt to save them.

    That said, I think if Claws was your partner, he probably wouldn't have claimed you as his N1 target. So I'm thinking it's less likely.
  44. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Again, my hesitance with kareemah is how on the nose it would be with Claws' claim
  45. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    And I don't think future is the way to go today. We should look elsewhere
    Click to expand...
    Why not future? And thoughts on LDG?
  46. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FutureHold said:
    as for the others. Kareemah is very new and LDG is LDG, good targets but i doubt they are cult
    Click to expand...
    Ok, so where are your thoughts as far as people you don't trust? Don't think you've shared that beyond voting Jarrod
  47. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    In fact, why were you more concerned with defending yourself rather than discussing the other names I proposed? Especially since I didn't even vote you.
  48. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FutureHold said:
    Vote: Jarrod
    Click to expand...
    Why Jarrod? Why note LDG or Kareemah?
  49. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    @PsychoSoldier - what is it that makes you feel grae isn't cult? I have light tinfoil that even though he probably wouldn't be Mazer's first choice, if Mazer tried to recruit someone he couldn't then Grae could have ended up as the bad luck choice. Hunter as a claim is exceptionally safe in that scenario too if that's what he began as... you know no one is going to counter you, and since the cult can still cause bleeds, if you need to "prove" it, it's feasible.
    Click to expand...
    It's all about Claws' approach to Grae in the last phase. It seemed like he was genuinely trying to drum up suspicion there. Don't think they're aligned.
  50. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Future, Kareemah, or LDG. I think those are the votes we look at if we're trying to find a cult member

    Vote: LemonDemonGirl

    Misyeet ahoy!

    wolf GIF
  51. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Foxxi's coming to a lot of the same conclusions I was as I was looking back over the last phase. Claws honestly spews a lot of people as non-cult. I do think the votes/push on Jarrod is the weakest out of the bunch, but overall the timing makes me think they aren't aligned.

    Not Cult: Xan, Jarrod, MTR, Badger, Foxxi, Blind, Grae, Diva, Val

    Some of those(Foxxi and Badger primarily, Probably Blind, Xan, Grae) I think are town regardless.

    That leaves: morri, LDG, Kareemah, CWE, Future, Listo

    I think morri is probably clean, but I think mechanically he could have been Mazer's partner and Claws was the recruit, so it's worth considering.

    CWE just today voting me has me second guessing, but I also don't exactly think he's playing like he was recruited N1. I have suspicions about him being neutral though.

    Future had a couple posts and vote timings that made me hmmmm, and the only thing holding me back is the pardon would probably be too blatant.

    Listo seems more likely to be a neutral trying to be helpful to stay alive without drawing too much nightkill attention by suspecting people.

    Kareemah is interesting because I think Claws saying that was his paladin target may be too on the nose? But then kareemah's vote on Xan was interesting timing, especially since it came as some pressure was building on Claws. I'm really torn there.

    LDG is a complete neutral and as many have said would be a smart conversion pick.
  52. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    VoidKitten said:
    Vote Count:

    6 - Claws (DivaSmurf #408, Psycho #457, Badger #421, Foxxi #475, Jarrod #512, Blind Ninja #521)
    4 - Jarrod (Claws #385, LDG #401, Matthieu #413, Future #483)
    3 - Xanjori (CWE #317, Val #331, Kareemah #462)

    With 17 players alive, majority for nomination is 9 votes on a single player.
    Click to expand...
  53. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Claws said:
    I still wonder about mtr.
    i think i have listo figured
    grae claimed.
    Pretty sure i know what you are
    maybe diva xans pretty Weak too
    Future im unsure about
    Click to expand...
  54. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    VoidKitten said:
    Vote Count:

    4 - Xanjori (CWE #317, Val #331, Kareemah #462, Jarrod #465)
    4 - Claws (DivaSmurf #408, Psycho #457, Badger #421, Foxxi #475)
    3 - Jarrod (Claws #385, LDG #401, Matthieu #413)
    1 - DivaSmurf (FutureHold #382)

    With 17 players alive, majority for nomination is 9 votes on a single player.
    Click to expand...
  55. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Claws said:
    i still think mtr is a good target in the case that sum1 made him talk backwards theres no saying hes not bad.

    Another is morri still no response on how he would vote and hes king that bothers me.

    psycho being gimmicky is usually town but nothing saying he cant do it as a wolf aswell specially the same gimmick back to back.. (BORING)

    and then basically any1 that is quiet in the background that usually would be a lil chatty during day is sus af
    Click to expand...
    And I think this is a good look for MTR
  56. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Claws said:
    ok psychos not there

    Unvote: psycho

    Vote: badger

    gun to your head impress me
    Click to expand...
    Decent look for Badger methinks
  57. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Listo95 said:
    And like I said cult wouldn't vote pardon unless they thought it could go that way. In no universe at that point was it likely he would be pardoned. Cult would be a non-voter or someone on his execute list.
    Click to expand...
    On this note, I think it's more likely we find a prime misyeet in people that would have voted to put someone else on trial. Because yeah, by the time Claws was on trial, he was pretty much already cooked.

    And now understanding the mechanics more, I can't help but feel that the two kills on N1 came from somewhere other than the cult, because I really dont think Mazer would have opted to kill instead of recruit. I don't know what that means mechanically exactly.
  58. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    If he tried to recruit N1 it had to have been successful- this game has a mechanic that the first recruit attempt had bad luck protection - if the cult had tried to recruit someone they couldn't for whatever reason, they would have gotten a random person they could recruit. And I originally thought he would have chosen to recruit too, especially since Lora seems like a strange kill target for him, but I don't think it's impossible he would have thought to wait a night and let people behave normally/ gauge who might be a good pick - after all, what are the odds he and Claws would both bite it back to back?
    Click to expand...
    I might have misunderstood, but I didn't think the bad luck protection, meant it was a guaranteed recruit. Just that the odds were higher.
  59. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FutureHold said:
    Claws mentioned Kareemah, do you think he was pulling a name out of a hat or a potential conversion?
    Click to expand...
    This was something I was ruminating on over the night phase
  60. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Gonna be busy for most of today so I won't be able to howl up the thread for a while. Trying to parse whether Mazer recruited successfully on N1, because it's not impossible we're looking at a dead cult at this point. But if so, that means we're definitely dealing with at least one of the neutral killers.

    Honestly, I doubt Mazer would opt to kill instead of recruit on N1, so I think the two deaths on N1 have to be explained by something else anyway. But trying to put the role puzzle is dizzying.
  61. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Execute
  62. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Claws said:
    Didnt need to kareems not been in trouble why put in a spotlight
    Click to expand...
    But you ultimately know kareemah is blue dragon (assuming that's what you're implying with this claim), so why wouldn't you have her in your townreads?
  63. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    @Claws Why did you target kareemah? If you give a satisfactory answer, I  might not execute you
  64. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    morrison said:
    what's with the quotation marks?
    Click to expand...
    morrison isn't buying the gimmick I guess I better explain to him.

    Meh, I'll keep him guessing for now
  65. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    Potentially. What is your take or thoughts on what you think he might do in this scenario?
    Click to expand...
    Honestly, I feel a lot of his decision would come down to who he would like to plot with. Which means he'd probably pick people he thinks can wolf well, but would also probably try to find someone he hasn't been scum with. Or at least has less experience being scum with.

    If he wanted to play it safe on N1, he'd probably pick someone low-key but effective like Val. But if he did the above, I'm not sure the first person I'd think he'd gravitate to, as I'd have to cross reference who he's scammed with how often and allat.
  66. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Val feels like a prime target if he were to go that route
  67. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Foxxi, out of curiosity, if someone was converted last night, who do you think it was?
  68. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    What happened to psycho? I thought you were sus of his gimmick earlier?
    Click to expand...
    This too
  69. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Claws said:
    I still wonder about mtr.
    i think i have listo figured
    grae claimed.
    Pretty sure i know what you are
    maybe diva xans pretty Weak too
    Future im unsure about
    Click to expand...
    This reads like such a thrown together list that it's practically begging to be mischopped.
  70. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I mean

    Pbs Nature Wolf GIF by Nature on PBS
  71. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I'm gonna be honest, I haven't hated Grae's posts, but I have trouble buying his breadcrumb at face value considering his record.

    I'm not a big fan of Xanjori's wagon either more for the nature of how it came about. Xan seems fine so far, but it feels kind of like a throwaway wagon that some people are hitching their cart to. If Jarrod, Claws, or Diva end up being a cult member, we could potentially find one or two(?) of them in those voting there.

    I'm torn between CWE having a bit more vote gusto than usual as scum, but feeling less purposeful than usual as town.
  72. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    @DivaSmurf

    Could you give us some thoughts on who you would consider mislynching and who you wouldn't like to right now? Obviously you're voting Claws, but is there more than that?
  73. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Claws

    "This or Listo, I think. Foxxi has hinted at leaving Jarrod be, and I don't feel great about chopping Diva due to recent games and the fact she's actually participating right now.

    I'm open to other options, but nothing else really stands out as not right to me."
  74. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    wolf GIF

    Vote: CWE
  75. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Blind Ninja said:
    who do you want me to vote for and why?
    Click to expand...
    "Whomever you suspect. My eye is primarily on Listo right now because I think he's throwing posts into the thread for the sake of looking active rather than actually caring about solving and eliminating threats."

    If we can get Blind to help push this, all the better. Let's see how this post does to convince him.
  76. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Y'all suck at voting
  77. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    Though you could actually be cult and that's why you weren't aware of the possibility that it could have been an unseen game, so meh. Nevermind
    Click to expand...
    You should never derp clear scum anyway
  78. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Foxxi's getting too powerful to misyeet. I'll probably have to abort that, but maybe I can play some tinfoil if we leave her alive.

    Jarrod is lacking and didn't have a great EOD, so we could probably get traction there, but I get the feeling he's just been busy, so I'd like to give him a chance to at least play.

    I'm wondering how long I can extend this pissfight with CWE and see if maybe we can twist that into a misyeet.
  79. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Only the second line there is meant to be in a quote
  80. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    No we didn't? Where did he say it was a cult? It's always random, either unseen or cult and you don't know immediately. Now the unseen can recruit too - so they kinda still function as a cult, but they aren't actually the cult class
    Click to expand...
    From the sign-up:

    This is a cult style game. I repeat. This is a cult style game.[/b]

    Looking at the opening post breakdown, I guess it said it could be unseen or cult, so yeah he didn't outright tell us. But when he said it's a cult-style game, I immediately assumed there would be a cult.
    Click to expand...
  81. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    Because voting you for the newbie's mistake feels wrong.
    Click to expand...
    That sounds like prime misyeet material of you ask me, pardner
  82. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Listo95 said:
    Was more in response to all the people voting you.
    Click to expand...
    Oh this is gold. I'm gonna push Listo for a misyeet. How's this post look:

    "Barely anyone was voting Morrison and we were already on execute/pardon for MTR

    This doesn't really make sense and makes me wonder how much you actually cared about who got eliminated last phase

    Vote: Listo"
  83. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    Vote: Badger
    Click to expand...
    I'm not sold on this being Mazer's first recruit choice. Especially with how obvious it would be.
  84. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    CWE said:
    Awww.

    Now I can't vote Mazer.
    Click to expand...
    Why don't you nut up and vote the open wolf that you supposedly have suspicions on?
  85. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    FoxxiMcLeod said:
    Well Lora was 3p - who he wanted dead doesn't actually mean anything for those people since Lora wouldn't have known anything about them one way or the other. But Mazer's comments do lead in the direction that they may not be aligned. And knowing now that we have a cult, it is entirely possible we have an apostle and Mazer may have been responsible for the restriction on MTR. Or well, whoever Mazer's buddy is since Mazer was the cult leader.
    Click to expand...
    But we already knew there was a cult? Void said so in the opening post.
  86. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    I have a bunch of thoughts and bookmarks I've already laid out, but I'm gonna reserve that info until later. Kinda dripfeed it in over the days to let me sink under the radar while looking active. Should keep me from getting chopped too soon without drawing too much attention with "towny" Psycho.

    I'll probably post something similar to this in the thread. You know, except cutting out the dripfeed and sinking under the radar stuff.
  87. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Evil comes in cute packages

    puella magi madoka magica GIF
  88. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Kareemah said:
    If someone were to be town, how does one let other town people know that they are town, likewise for scum, Hypothetically speaking
    Click to expand...
    The default is that everyone should be assumed to be town essentially. The only way you can let someone else know you're town is...to be towny. And that's such a nebulous thing that's different for different people that there's no clearcut way.

    But usually the best you can do is just post and say what you're thinking, even if you think it's dumb or not right or you're not too confident. If you're town, your general energy will show it.

    Scum have to be more tactical in letting each other know and usually involves either subtext or letting your votes show who's side you're on. Which of course can get you caught. Though most of the time, the games we play have all of scum knowing who each other is so it's more about looking towny.

    In which case, you just post a bunch and hope you look invested enough to not get chopped.

    Like I'm doing right now with this late flood of posts. I'll get cred for being active and those less likely to scrutinize me are gonna write me off as town, even though I'm clearly scum.

    Just look at me howl


    dog howl GIF
  89. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Kareemah said:
    Vote: execute u guys said that mtr is ruthless, and I’m unsure if he is cult or not but I would feel more comfortable if I didn’t have to worry about a mass murderer in the streets
    Click to expand...
    I like your gusto. You can stay in my pocket for like 10 games.
  90. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Mazer said:
    Why you answering his question for him?
    Click to expand...
    Oh, this is good. This plants a strong seed for a Foxxi misyeet later. Nice work. I'll see if I can't keep building that pressure.
  91. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    But for real

    Vote: Pardon

    MTR and I have a longform distancing agenda that gets completely ruined if he's outed today. So nah.

    Y'all should have been looking at juicy misyeet Foxxi
  92. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    DivaSmurf said:
    Vote: MTR

    I have no basis to kill the king, I just have the impulsive urge to go French and be like off with his head. But that’s not very nice. So I think im going to go for my dad instead.
    Click to expand...
  93. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    Vote: Foxxi

    wolf dancing GIF
  94. PsychoSoldier

    Mafia 1 - Throne of Suspicion

    howling wolf GIF
Top Bottom