Recent content by Dude Love

Merlin said:

Where have you been?

Click to expand...

Mania weekend I was checked out, came back and we voted Glinda out, next day phase ended early and I just hadn't shown up yet, and this current phase I think I've been active enough.

Dr Strange said:

Mick and Rhea

Click to expand...

That's what I thought.

Dr Strange said:

I've given my thoughts on all the votes up to the most recent and looked at the patterns.

Right now, I feel like we can resolve this between our top two.


I'm also not against the idea of Cody as the SK. Particularly with the Spellman kill-if I'm right in my theory about Spellman (although last game like this I was worse than I think I should be about sussing out actual identities).

@Cody Rhodes Any good town argument?

Click to expand...

Who do you have as our top 2?

Dr Strange said:

I'm going to be honest, that wording looks very similar to how busdrive has been written in the past. I guess it can't be 100 proven, but that was how I read it as well.

Click to expand...

I read it as a busdrive, too.

Mick Foley said:

VoidKitten did what he did best and ran his hands over the dials of his master control unit, while sitting on his throne with a Pepsi in hand. VoidKitten didn’t really like Cactus Jack nor Mick Foley and fired a red laser beam at both of his target, confusing the two of them.

are you actually this fucking dumb?

Click to expand...

You do know that continually not just fucking explaining your point makes you look absolutely badgering and aggressive in a non-helpful way, right?

With all that said, I'd have Strange, Dresden, Merlin and Sirius as my townies.

1. Cactus Jack - Voted for TFB who we know is town and also pushed against Jafar, who was town, for being a bad wish granter. They also had this post, #1252, which I tagged as odd upon first reading it:

I know I haven’t been active. But why am I poisoned?

Wait scum did it? Why?

Click to expand...

Came off as very performative. CWE seemed to cure him before night phase, so we didn't see what might have happened, if anything.

2. Cody Rhodes - Voted Jarfar day 2 in a joke vote, but also never moved off him. Shot at Gargamel and missed during Russian Roulette and chalked it up to RNG, says they missed them outing Sabrina as scum. Very convenient. They did vote Glinda, but that was after the comeback and once Glinda was well outed.

3. Dr Strange - His shot and kill on Rhea is looking better each phase. Strange claims silence, yet it was Rhea who comes back defensive and deflecting. Strange came right in and started giving reads, trying to connect dots and engaging with people, and not just to defend himself. Since coming back from the silence, he's been the one most dedicated to sussing shit out.

5. Harry Dresden - Argued for not voting The Final Boss as the yeet on Day 2 based on good deduction once we realized Paul Heyman was killed night 1 when we thought there wasn't a death. He also asks Jade why she voted for Gargamel, which is something I also noticed while doing some ISO'ing and didn't sit right with me. Also second to vote sleep during day 2 in an attempt to have no misyeets, but that backfired since Sleep is not a person. I doubt scum knew enough about how Void would classify that to set that all up.

6. Jade Cargill - Random vote on Gargamel when Gargamel hadn't been very active. No explanation given. Voted for Pug, and when pressed on why, said it was random. Voted for Jafar while admitting to not keeping track of things going on in the game. When pushed to elaborate by Harry Potter, said they couldn't without infringing on game rules, which I assume means something around claiming. I don't buy that.

7. Mankind - Doesn't want to push TFB as a lynch, and says Jafar's personality is probably distracting from their alignment. But then they throw a rando vote onto Palpantine, putting him at 3 votes to TFB's 4 and setting him up as the second highest wagon. But then Sleep rushes in and takes the lead with 4 votes, with Jafar hopping off TFB and voting Sleep. This puts Palp and TFB at 3 votes each, but Palp is situated above TFB, despite the first three votes for TFB coming before Palp got his third vote. So with modified majority, shouldn't TFB have been above Palp? Could there have been a hidden extra vote on Palp? He also points out the possibility that Strange had been silenced before Strange shows back up, but doesn't commit to it because Strange had posted in the phase already. His breakdown of living players is fine.

8. Merlin - Was on TFB early, but seemingly got deets on Pug and stuck to them thereafter. Was fine leaving Pug for Glinda as a yeet, but never voted for her. He didn't really need to, though.

9. Mick Foley - Dropped a double vote for TFB during day 1 in a single post. Followed that up voting Palp the next day, cause of the weird late day vote movement. Voted Gargamel but unvoted when somebody pointed out they were seemingly rolecopped by scum. Voted Dr. Strange before Strange came back explaining the silence. Has focused lately on the d1 votes for immunity as far as scrutiny goes, which feels like trying to get sus on people that means very little. Acknowledges Merlin's deets on Pug but doesn't vote for him and then says he doesn't know why he didn't once Pug flips scum.

10. Rhea Ripley - Post #1316 just rubbed me the wrong way, and I think the discourse surrounding them since coming back has made a compelling enough argument for them being scum.

11. Seth Rollins - Asked Palp for his thoughts after Palp was already killed. I don't think this is a mistake that scum makes nor do I think scum set this up as a smokescreen post.

12. Sirius Black - Is the one who sniffed out Glinda when others, including myself, had her as town. He was really pushing Jafar as scum and was the second vote on them, which turned out to be the final vote on them as the day ended early and Jafar got the wack. They say they were going to unvote Jafar, which is a convenient out but the early end of the phase at least lends itself to an outcome like that. A lot of their back and forth with Mick Foley feels town to me.

Merlin called deets on Pug, yes? But Strange and Glinda are the trains. Pug on Strange makes me lean voting Glinda. Glinda gets to 5 votes, Pug comes in 3 posts later to vote Strange and get him to 4 votes, and Mick comes in 7 posts after him to boost Strange into a tie with Glinda.

Hmm.

Vote: Glinda

Dude Love said:

Glinda is back, and I got town reads from her based on day 1, and I don't think that has changed.

Click to expand...

Sirius Black said:

To put the above post more succinctly

We know Glinda was killed by Rajah visiting Tribal Chief.

We know mafia actions were hidden last night.

We saw no townies visit Tribal Chief.

So it looks like Glinda is outed as mafia here.

Click to expand...

Alrighty, my obligations are over and I'm back to moving and grooving. I caught up on everything, but wouldn't say I've actually absorbed everything, if that makes sense.

Sirius and Gargamel feeling very towny. Glinda is back, and I got town reads from her based on day 1, and I don't think that has changed. I've liked Rhea's posts, for the most part.

I'll probably do better if some people ask me for reads instead of me trying to put the last couple days together in my own head.

I know Rhea hadn't seen much of the Tribal Chat, so @Glinda, if you care to say, was any of the stasis players' alignment revealed in the chat?

Sirius Black said:

Glinda, how do you feel about me pointing out this post from Palpatine?

Click to expand...

Why is 'pointing out this post' worth considering at all? The fact they refer to Glinda as a 'fellow witch?'

Jade Cargill said:

Why? The writeup suggests he couldn't have done anything last night.

Click to expand...

If he was roleblocked, and there was no scum kill, it could point to him being the scum who was supposed to do the kill.

Glinda said:

Time to decipher the writeup

Mazer character was recruitable and picked a side.

Rock activated a weapon. This a kill?
Caito protected TFB, I think.
LDG did something. Put an X through so a section??
Shiro made Paul unable to talk
Marack looking through Garmgamel's pack, could be an investigate.
Insaner listening devices. Can he check into other chats?

Click to expand...

Considering everyone is still alive, I don't think the weapon Rock used was for a kill, unless it's delayed like a poison or something. The way it 'chilled' people made me think some kind of mass roleblock, though obviously some actions went through. Could have been a percentage roleblock or something.

I read the action on Caito as a jail.

We'll have to see if Paul is able to post during this day phase or if his vocabulary is limited in some way, otherwise I think this might just be a standard roleblock.

Relatively quiet night. Not sure much info will come out.

These wishes will be interesting, though.

Vote: Glinda

Something feels off to me...