What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Day 3 Timer

9 Players Alive/3 Dead
Day 3 has come to and end.

Recent content by Gargamel

  1. Gargamel

    Mafia 16-House of MTR Episode 1 - The Not-so Civil War

    And will NOT be playing under the Gargamel user lol
  2. Gargamel

    Mafia 16-House of MTR Episode 1 - The Not-so Civil War

    1. Val
    2. llettuce
    3. VoidKitten
    4.
    5. CWE
    69. Blind Ninja
    7. Tildey
    8. MTR
    9. Future
    10.
    11. CLAWS
    12.
    13. morrison
    14. PsychoSoldier
    15. MitchRapp
    16. LemonDemonGirl
    17. Robozerim

    I'll probably be mostly a flop this game
  3. Gargamel

    Mafia 16-House of MTR Episode 1 - The Not-so Civil War

    Blind Ninja said:
    Per the laws of Mafia Statistics, if I signup and play, ill be killed D1/N1
    Click to expand...
    And you'll come back 2 times after
  4. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    You still broke my heart, @Sabrina Spellman
  5. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Rhea Ripley said:
    I don't have a lot of time nor brain power, and I don't know if I will make it back before the end of day, so

    Vote: Strange

    I hope this is not just OMGUS for shooting me / killing me without explanation, then disappearing. It's just that right now, I trust Gargamel more than anyone and he's voting here.

    I think it is quite likely that we have multiple scum trains at the moment, because according to my scribbles there are a probably baddies left.

    The lack of flips makes this difficult, and we don't know a lot, but I'd like to get opinions on everyone's top 2 trusts (for me, it's Gargamel, then probably Sirius), and bottom 2 aka threats (Strange, then I can't decide whether maybe Pug over Glinda).
    Click to expand...
    I think everyone who hasn't already should answer this question
  6. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Jafar said:
    IM having trouble deciding wether scum or town i shot at him dismorning but im thinkin the more day goes on we could figure him out maybe he doesnt tell lies
    Click to expand...
    It was the bandwagon emoji, wasn't it?
  7. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Jafar said:
    Myself
    Garg
    Sb
    Likely alot of dead players


    Then cody is top of my nuetral list as i think ive figured the actual player its not future
    Pug needs more lhf maybe idk

    Scum pile
    Glinda
    Strange for the weird shot has he even came back?
    Possibly merlin cactus and jade

    Any1 else isnt really signifcant enough to place
    Click to expand...
    No, Strange has not come back. They made the shot in private, and despite being online, they have not made any post since.

    Why do you have Cactus as possible scum?
  8. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Gargamel said:
    Have we literally had half the player lost not post or only post once this phase?
    Click to expand...
    EBWOP player list
  9. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Have we literally had half the player lost not post or only post once this phase?
  10. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Jafar, who would you say are the people you trust and the people you suspect
  11. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Rhea Ripley said:
    I don't have a lot of time nor brain power, and I don't know if I will make it back before the end of day, so

    Vote: Strange

    I hope this is not just OMGUS for shooting me / killing me without explanation, then disappearing. It's just that right now, I trust Gargamel more than anyone and he's voting here.

    I think it is quite likely that we have multiple scum trains at the moment, because according to my scribbles there are a probably baddies left.

    The lack of flips makes this difficult, and we don't know a lot, but I'd like to get opinions on everyone's top 2 trusts (for me, it's Gargamel, then probably Sirius), and bottom 2 aka threats (Strange, then I can't decide whether maybe Pug over Glinda).
    Click to expand...
    To answer this, my top two trusts are probably Sirius Black and maybe Cactus after I read their ISO. Just wish they were more present today. Also if Strange is scum you're ultra clear to me.

    Top 2 suspects are Strange and Glinda
  12. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    I don't think Merlin's explanation is scummy. It just means the deets aren't as concrete as we initially thought.

    Don't think they'd even put theirselves in that position if they were a Smurf in most cases
  13. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    I'll say for Strange that I don't really get why as scum they would shoot silently and not bother to check in or explain theirselves or anything, knowing that it would probably bring them a lot of attention. It's not like they were cornered.

    But I also just think the simple fact they didn't engage with the shot or the reactions at all just isn't towny.
  14. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    Merlin said:
    There is always room for error in these games. If we want to get rid of Glinda now and circle back to Pug then I am comfortable with it. However him not even addressing it in his multiple posts makes me even more confident in my beliefs.
    Click to expand...
    My surprise came from the fact that they've been posting and sort of solving along at all. I figured they'd maybe make one or two posts and then realize they were outed, or just not have posted at all, so I'm less sure it's a hit. But I get that it just as easily could be scum trying to seem like they don't care.

    I guess my question is you didn't receive like "Pug is not town" or something and learned something about their role that's very damning on the surface? So I wanted to make sure just in case they suddenly start being so towny that I get paranoid.

    I'm fine resolving there, but I think Glinda and Strange will also kill at least one smurf.
  15. Gargamel

    Mafia 15 - VoidKitten's Revenge

    I want to say we have at least two smurfs in these wagons, if not 3
See more
Back
Top Bottom