Search results

Nightingale said:

Again for the millionth time though. If you don't think either are sus - why is it such a bizarre idea to test someone else's sus

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

I do not understand why this seems to be rocket science.

We have two choices and one of them has done actually sus things.

Click to expand...

Jarrod1983 said:

Well some of those are probably right.

I would have liked your actual feelings if you were coming out of D2 alive Claws.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

The only person who's actively argued for claws is me, so I seriously doubt it's a case of "scum want claws gone" or I think there'd be a lot more people being like "oh well I have no opinion so I guess this argument is good enough" with the added bonus of making me look bad -- which is another reason I think claws is probably scum here. The amount of pushing I've had to do just does not feel like scum are fine with this.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

How about you spend some time with those gifs trying to give thoughts other than "pick the other guy"? This is really starting to feel exactly like ToL when you were begging to be saved.

Click to expand...

Jarrod1983 said:

Isn't it sort of sheeping Foxxi if you just put the minimum vote in and then unvote it? If you really didn't want to sheep you'd put a vote on Drey and let it stand so who she's pushed overly hard this phase doesn't get eliminated.

Click to expand...

Dreyski said:

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Okay, but if you think they are both town and we have to yeet one anyway, can we yeet the one who is actually sus. Even if I'm wrong we have to remove one, why not the sus one? >.>

Click to expand...

Badger said:

Click to expand...

Mazer said:

Claws may be taking Badger's gif crown.

He's possibly heading to a reward in my Christmas game

Click to expand...

Mazer said:

This phase hasn't changed my day 1 interests very much

Except I think there's a genuine chance that some people may have overtrusted foxxi. Who I can't yet see why someone goes all the way there yet.

Although I have one specific read that gives me a lean on foxxi.

A claws reveal gains a little more info.

Click to expand...

Mazer said:

Absolutely. You're a wonderful analyst. Claws is more predictable in getting reactions from and to in each day phase.

I typically assume if he is scum it will more likely come our before endgame.

Click to expand...

Dreyski said:

Click to expand...

Mazer said:

I still am not confident in my reason you, but I do want to see Badger vetted.

There's not enough for me to get crazy, but pings

Click to expand...

Dreyski said:

volume is not equivalent to content (acknowleging Claws is hamstrung) and you should know my posting style better than some on here.

Click to expand...

CWE said:

Without KNOWING Void did this, it's just 50/50. Becuase I refuse to believe scum would put one of their own in this. And the only people who KNOW if Void did this is, Void (dead), Psycho (probably not going to tell us right now. Call it a hunch), and scum.

Unless someone has a reason to KNOW 1 is scum, just keep it close and see if scum swing it.

So the question is @Dreyski anything you can say for your talent this game? @Claws anything you can...meme? to tell us for your contribution.

Click to expand...

LemonDemonGirl said:

Vote: Nightingale
You're oddly active this game.
That bothers me.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Maybe this is a lack of knowing thing since you didn't play the game - but in just a couple of games back there was a player here from MU who cited a rule that said the first wagon to three votes usually contains a scum. We yeeted one of those people and it turned out to be accurate. This is the rule Drey is referring to. You cannot seriously think that claws was "passionate" about Void without ever giving a reason other than "I was right before and no one listened to me so we should just yeet him now to be safe" -- whereas Drey saw that rule work and from what I know of him as a player he would absolutely be like "okay, maybe that's a thing we should look at again" -- but NOT if he HIMSELF was actually going to get caught by it

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Lol no clue why it quoted claws' gif there XD

Click to expand...

FutureHold said:

These past 2 days of worked suck. Anyways getting caught up now. If Claws can explain to me why I shouldn’t vote him using the highest quality gifs that would be appreciated.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

C'mon people. Just sheep me, either I'm wrong and everyone can laugh at how stupid I am or I'm right and we yeet scum. It's a win-win.

Click to expand...

Jarrod1983 said:

Incredibly wrong. 100% not scum.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

It's possible you're both town. But I have to pick one - I'm going to pick the one that I scum read. I'm not sure why that's such a difficult concept to understand. Your argument basically boils down to "why can't we both be town? So you should vote the other person you think is town instead of me."

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

What even is this question... why would I want to yeet you both if I feel Drey is town? Besides, ties are random'd so the only way to do that would be spending another day yeeting whoever isn't yeeted today.

And if you are town there is no reason you should want both of you to be yeeted unless you *actually* think Drey is sus - which you gave no indication of when I asked who you'd want to yeet if you weren't in this thunderdome.

This reeks.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Yes... maybe I am tunneled, it wouldn't be the first time. But the fact is -- our only options today are you or Drey. I feel Drey is town, and I see reasons you could be scum... so I'm going to argue my scum-read should be the choice today.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Also drey... your read is kinda backwards. D1 is the day I would expect scum claws to push something like that because - as shown by the fact I seem to be the only one who's taking any issue with how he handled Void - most folks aren't going to condemn someone for being wrong D1. And if I thought Claws had a genuine scum read on Void I'd probably be in the same camp Insaner is right now because, yup... being wrong as town happens.

The issue I have is I don't believe Claws actually thought Void was suspicious. I think he wanted to try to force a yeet on him D1 because that was literally the only time a town Void *might* have gotten yeeted. And whileI kinda think a town Claws would still do that for the lulz of seeing Void be yeeted D1 - I *don't* think a town claws would have pussy footed around with his vote for it.

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

You can't seriously expect the dude to vote himself instead... *eyeroll*

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

I think you mean scum claws, not scum you? XD

Click to expand...

Dreyski said:

Well, that's a thing. I know I'm town, and I suspect Claws is as well, if only because scum Dreyski wouldn't push so hard on D1 becuase of the backlash. But then claws is claws.
Regardless of who goes, I'd be looking towards Insaner and Future as the other names on the Void train, especially when I flip/if Claws flips green.
Cast the die and lets see where we are at day end. And I am going to do what I can to stay in.

Vote: Claws

Click to expand...

GrumpyCat said:

MTR?

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

claws, who would you vote today if you weren't in this thunderdome?

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

Oh I get what you're saying. I just think you're wrong. I think Claws said he really likes warhammer 3 and then regurgitated some reasons why from some online reviews he'd read, but he's got no clue what the game is actually like.

Click to expand...

Peter Griffin said:

Vote: Claws

Click to expand...

Nightingale said:

But it does make me feel better about Insaner

Click to expand...

Jarrod1983 said:

I know most of us think that scum would put up 1 town and 1 scum to battle.

Scum are smart enough to know this and might have just thrown 2 towns out here for everyone to choose between.

Click to expand...

Insaner said:

How are you so good at gifs

People should really give you this restriction more often

Click to expand...