Mafia 32- Traitors

[Val the Moofia Boss]

I went to random.org and Listo's name was at the top of the list.

Vote: Listo

Better luck next time buddy.

 

[FutureHold]

Hi, I'm VK. I play based on my feelings about a post at any particular place in time.

I am neutral on this post. I hated it, but I also like it.

That doesn’t sound like you

 

[FutureHold]

Unless all the times you hounded me for not spreadsheeting or following logic is just an emotional gameplay

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I'm bored so here's both games I've ever been scum in (technically there was a third but dont like that one bit cause i wasnt there 90% of the time)

back to basics mafia (a newbie friendly game) [GAME END SCUM INDEP WIN]

Hi players! Welcome to Back to Basics Mafia! This is a game with simple roles and rules to introduce newer players into the game, experienced players are welcome to join and help coach newer players. Moderator: @Calvinッ 1. @ExLight - Town Vanilla - Killed Night 3 2. @Jade The Necromancer...

bulbagarden.net

Crossover Mafia [day 4 - Potentially Bastard]

A bunch of characters from different franchises have been teleported to one town. But who is a good guy and who is a bad guy? Not everyone is how they seem. Everyone has reasons to be bad and reasons to be good, and there is no way to tell who is who. my MoD for this game is @JamieIsBored

bulbagarden.net

maybe cause i prefer people to explain why for why they dont like a post or why they find something scummy or towny or flimsy but the 'stop making posts I hate' is pretty vauge and doesn't say why you dont like posts but also that could be cause people dont wanna give too much to the mafia so they dont make 'likeable posts'
ejfifoewfkeogk hate i cant really put my thought process super great into wordsView attachment 328 I'm prob just tired

Would you vote VK based on that, or do you just not like it as reasoning?

Do you have any feels on anyone yet?

 

[VoidKitten]

Unless all the times you hounded me for not spreadsheeting or following logic is just an emotional gameplay

*sighs* You making an illogical post would be me disliking a post you made in real time as the post is illogical.

Use logic.

 

[Handium]

Would you vote VK based on that, or do you just not like it as reasoning?

Do you have any feels on anyone yet?

I don't like it as reasoning, it's still D1 so Im not expecting the greatest reasons yet; if this kind of poor reasoning happens later in the game I might vote

Not yet
the interaction between Void and Matthieu doesn't feel w/w but not fully sure on it being t/t so maybe t/w there

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I don't like it as reasoning, it's still D1 so Im not expecting the greatest reasons yet; if this kind of poor reasoning happens later in the game I might vote

Not yet
the interaction between Void and Matthieu doesn't feel w/w but not fully sure on it being t/t so maybe t/w there

If you had to vote between the two, which do you think is the wolf between them?

 

[MTR]

As far as I'm aware, if I'm dead I don't win so are we really teammates?

If you are going to be that way I didn't want to be your teammate anyway.

Who I am kidding. I always want to be your teammate.

 

[Handium]

Scum feels like they would need to make up a reason for why someone is scummy since they know most if not everyone is town (unless indep there) so less willing to give reason outside of 'i dont like this' and 'this is a good post' rather than town needing to find scum so its more natural reasons

 

[MTR]

Sup

Hard traitor claim

 

[Handium]

If you had to vote between the two, which do you think is the wolf between them?

Matt doesn't seem too scummy but wolfs can play quite towny and get into town core so not ruling em out yet so probably void due to my previous reasons
still D1 tho so bound to change

 

[MTR]

I would banish both Claws and Matthieu today.

Psycho is fun. I wanna see more. I am curious if we are meshing on the same wavelength on certain aspects.

Handium seems normal thus far based on the one game they played.

MTR I need to see more.

 

[MTR]

All I know of this theme so far is Bob The Drag Queen was playing terrible and was also robbed at the same time.

He was not robbed. He just FAFO when it comes to playing with Boston Rob.

 

[MitchRapp]

He was not robbed. He just FAFO when it comes to playing with Boston Rob.

Did you watch the most recent episode yet?

 

[MTR]

Did you watch the most recent episode yet?

No. Maybe tonight before we crash. Behind on a few things since I was gone for the Rumble

 

[FutureHold]

*sighs* You making an illogical post would be me disliking a post you made in real time as the post is illogical.

Use logic.

What the fuck does this mean?

 

[MTR]

What the fuck does this mean?

Made sense to me and I am the only non-gifted person in this household.

 

[VoidKitten]

Welp, I am now in your underwear pocket

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Made sense to me and I am the only non-gifted person in this household.

To be fair, it is worded a bit awkwardly

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Future feels aight to me

 

[VoidKitten]

To be fair, it is worded a bit awkwardly

Almost like that was intentionally obtuse.

 

[VoidKitten]

Future feels aight to me

Was it the "What the fuck does that mean"

I liked that.

 

[MitchRapp]

***GAME ANNOUNCEMENT***

A shield has been won and been given out via direct message. It is up to those in the running if they wish to reveal if they won it or not.

 

[Handium]

so either psycho or mtr has shield mk

 

[Claws]

Claws, how do you feel about Matthieu, MTR, and Handium so far?

I've got absolutely no read on Handi ATM. Also realizing this is my first time playing with them

I could toss any 3 of those traitors

 

[CWE]

San Antonio

Texas

duh...

 

[Listo95]

He was not robbed. He just FAFO when it comes to playing with Boston Rob.

Sorry Bob The Drag Queen can do no wrong. She is just wonderful and perfect.

 

[FutureHold]

so either psycho or mtr has shield mk

I’m fine with voting either of them, although MTR knows this format, so it might be worth it to keep him if he’s not a traitor but if he is a traitor

 

[Matthieu]

Vote: Conjure Meteor: VoidKitten

/s

do u like this post m8?

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Was it the "What the fuck does that mean"

I liked that.

That was mostly it, yeah

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I’m fine with voting either of them, although MTR knows this format, so it might be worth it to keep him if he’s not a traitor but if he is a traitor

Wait, why would you vote us for having a shield? Do you actually think we could be scummy, or something else?

 

[Handium]

I'm tired

 

[MitchRapp]

Vote Count:
2- VK (Claws, Matthieu)
1- Matthieu (VK)
1- Claws (Psycho)
1- Listo (Val)

Reminder, the person with the most votes at the end of the round will be banished.

 

[VoidKitten]

Vote: Conjure Meteor: VoidKitten

/s

do u like this post m8?

It has style, but falls flat with it showing vote and conjure meteor.

6/10 points.

 

[FutureHold]

Wait, why would you vote us for having a shield? Do you actually think we could be scummy, or something else?

Possibly, just vibes

 

[GrumpyCat]

Anything interesting going on here? Found any traitors yet?

 

[CWE]

Vote: Psycho[/VOTE

 

[CWE]

Vote: Psycho

 

[GrumpyCat]

I didn't read the game yet, but I think so too.

Vote: Psycho

 

[Handium]

welp were tied rn



wanting voting out one of the shields feels really suspicious yk?
Vote: PsychoSoldier
vk's reasoning is likely a more of a 'me' thing rather than actually being scummy so psycho feels a bit more scummy that way
it could also be 'Too Wofly to be a Wolf"

 

[MTR]

I’m fine with voting either of them, although MTR knows this format, so it might be worth it to keep him if he’s not a traitor but if he is a traitor

Kind of rude to vote one of us out just because one of us has a shield. Maybe you want to take one of us out since you can't murder one of us and you don't want to try to guess which person has the shield.

 

[MTR]

Not buying Psycho is a traitor at this point. Feels off to push him

 

[GrumpyCat]

wanting voting out one of the shields feels really suspicious yk?

Why? i would rather go into the night with someone that doesnt have a shield rather than someone with shield ;p

is it sussy? yes. Does it push my win-con? yes ;>

 

[CWE]

Unvote: Psycho

 

[CWE]

Psycho should know why I voted him...

 

[CWE]

Vote: GrumpyCat

 

[Apocaclaws]

cuz hes a sussy baka?

 

[Claws]

^ ignore that
cuz hes a sussy baka?

 

[GrumpyCat]

I am not a sussycat. thats the obvious vote ;D

 

[Claws]

your a grumpy cat

 

[GrumpyCat]

Someones getting yeeted and if you die you lose. No idea how to go with this but this game sems tailored to grumpy style XD

 

[Claws]

JUst yeet til your the last non traitor standing

 

[MTR]

If you die you lose for sure but if you are at the end and there is still a traitor alive you also lose.

 

[GrumpyCat]

If it was impossible for psycho to be a traitor i wouldnt vote there. but the way i see it he could be a traitor

 

[Claws]

If you die you lose for sure but if you are at the end and there is still a traitor alive you also lose.

Yes dad thank for for reading the rules

 

[MitchRapp]

Vote Count:
2- VK (Claws, Matthieu)
2- Psycho (Grumpy, Handium)
1- Matthieu (VK)
1- Claws (Psycho)
1- Listo (Val)
1- Grumpy Cat (CWE)

 

[Handium]

wonder how having no shields would count towards a win con? also didnt one of the people who actually know the source material say there's not really a indep or something like that

it feels off yk

 

[PsychoSoldier]

welp were tied rn



wanting voting out one of the shields feels really suspicious yk?
Vote: PsychoSoldier
vk's reasoning is likely a more of a 'me' thing rather than actually being scummy so psycho feels a bit more scummy that way
it could also be 'Too Wofly to be a Wolf"

If voting out one of the shields is suspicious, then why are you currently doing that?

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Vote: Psycho

I didn't read the game yet, but I think so too.

Vote: Psycho

welp were tied rn



wanting voting out one of the shields feels really suspicious yk?
Vote: PsychoSoldier
vk's reasoning is likely a more of a 'me' thing rather than actually being scummy so psycho feels a bit more scummy that way
it could also be 'Too Wofly to be a Wolf"

Gonna say there's a guarantees traitor in this train, especially from the tagalongs

 

[MTR]

Yes dad thank for for reading the rules

You know half the people here don't read the rules.

Plus people seem hung up on if they die the lose and not caring as much to hunt the traitors as much as to live to the end.

 

[Claws]

i dont get the shield mechanics so its whatever

 

[GrumpyCat]

Psycho cant be nightkilled so if he is alive tonight than everyone elses odds of getting killed rise up ;p Thats why i am voting there no changing.

 

[Handium]

Unvote: Psycho


Vote: ForgottenHold

went back and realized i voted the wrong person oop
thats why you should double check before sending a vote lmao

 

[MTR]

Psycho cant be nightkilled so if he is alive tonight than everyone elses odds of getting killed rise up ;p Thats why i am voting there no changing.

Again though yeah your odds at being killed tonight go up but if you don't bother to hunt the traitors during the day doesn't matter if you make it to the end or not. Now if people legit thought Psycho was a traitor yeah sure but I don't see it at this point.

Voting for people with shields just because they have a shield is just terrible strategy in my view.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

If it was impossible for psycho to be a traitor i wouldnt vote there. but the way i see it he could be a traitor

There's no one who currently can NOT be a traitor

 

[FutureHold]

The votes on psycho were sus as hell

 

[FutureHold]

My vibes on psycho are gone

 

[FutureHold]

I believe Handium for wanting to vote me.

So that leaves GC and CWE

I’m not going to go after CWE yet so

Vote: Grumpy Cat

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Trying to determine if Grumpy is playing super logical in a towny way or whether I should look at the selfish self-preservation as scummy, but I'm gonna fuck around and find out

Vote: GrumpyCat

 

[GrumpyCat]

There's no one who currently can NOT be a traitor

I dont think there is ever a point in this game when someone can be confirmed as not traitor.

 

[GrumpyCat]

Well maybe if CWE says he isnt

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I believe Handium for wanting to vote me.

So that leaves GC and CWE

I’m not going to go after CWE yet so

Vote: Grumpy Cat

Yeah, I kind of had a feeling they maybe voted the wrong person, which their follow-up does make me feel a bit better about them

 

[GrumpyCat]

Trying to determine if Grumpy is playing super logical in a towny way or whether I should look at the selfish self-preservation as scummy, but I'm gonna fuck around and find out

Vote: GrumpyCat

Havent decided on how to play this yet.

What do you think. if scum are down to 1 they will recruit someone very townt or scummy?

 

[FutureHold]

Havent decided on how to play this yet.

What do you think. if scum are down to 1 they will recruit someone very townt or scummy?

If Scum recruits then we need to look into VK and Psycho

 

[FutureHold]

They seem like the likely recruits

 

[GrumpyCat]

Do you want to keep psycho alive to yeet him just when he is recruited?

 

[FutureHold]

Logically I don’t think we should be cutting off our best players because they might be recruited in the future

 

[FutureHold]

That is not the play

 

[GrumpyCat]

Come on all . out of sight out of mind.

 

[CWE]

Well maybe if CWE says he isnt

 

[GrumpyCat]

same same

 

[Claws]

im a broke kitty now

 

[Claws]

so im thinkin if psycho flips a traitor ill likely sink future and probably mtr tomorrow

 

[Claws]

if grumpy is a traitor then ill re-evaluate

 

[MitchRapp]

Vote Count:
3- Grumpy Cat (CWE, FH, Psycho)
2- VK (Claws, Matthieu)
1- Psycho (Grumpy)
1- Matthieu (VK)
1- Claws (Psycho)
1- Listo (Val)
1- Forgotten Hold (Handium)

 

[GrumpyCat]

so im thinkin if psycho flips a traitor ill likely sink future and probably mtr tomorrow

Are there flips in this setup? how doest it work exactly?

 

[Claws]

im still not a fan of gc his logic makes sense to me where its d1 and shield ppl could be scum why shorten the player pool for kills if we dont win if we are dead

 

[Claws]

Are there flips in this setup? how doest it work exactly?

no idea but if i cant win while dead id rather just yeet whoever the fuck i want

 

[GrumpyCat]

if grumpy is a traitor then ill re-evaluate

Not a traitor. Maybe one day but hope not. it is what it is.

 

[Claws]

Unvote:
Vote: psycho

 

[Val the Moofia Boss]

I might not be active much this game day. Last night I ate a large taco salad and poured a lot of hot sauce into. Then I couldn't keep to sleep and started feeling ill and like I was going to vomit (I didn't). Got a little amount of rest and my stomach feels bad, shuffling around slowly trying to sip water, and my back hurts.

 

[Claws]

I might not be active much this game day. Last night I ate a large taco salad and poured a lot of hot sauce into. Then I couldn't keep to sleep and started feeling ill and like I was going to vomit (I didn't). Got a little amount of rest and my stomach feels bad, shuffling around slowly trying to sip water, and my back hurts.

feel better champ

 

[Handium]

is it sussy? yes. Does it push my win-con? yes ;>

i took this as 'indep win con' but maybe its just wanting to win idfk it feels scummy

---

I might not be active much this game day. Last night I ate a large taco salad and poured a lot of hot sauce into. Then I couldn't keep to sleep and started feeling ill and like I was going to vomit (I didn't). Got a little amount of rest and my stomach feels bad, shuffling around slowly trying to sip water, and my back hurts.

Hope you get better!

 

[MTR]

so im thinkin if psycho flips a traitor ill likely sink future and probably mtr tomorrow

Don't lie. You always go after us. It doesn't matter if Psycho is traitor or not.

 

[MTR]

I might not be active much this game day. Last night I ate a large taco salad and poured a lot of hot sauce into. Then I couldn't keep to sleep and started feeling ill and like I was going to vomit (I didn't). Got a little amount of rest and my stomach feels bad, shuffling around slowly trying to sip water, and my back hurts.

Feel better soon

 

[GrumpyCat]

i took this as 'indep win con' but maybe its just wanting to win idfk it feels scummy

I never played somthing like this I dont know the meta or anyting, just going wild for funs. If you think it is scummy i agree. Just want to see what gives.

 

[Claws]

Don't lie. You always go after us. It doesn't matter if Psycho is traitor or not.

not nessarily but i gotta say i did enjoy yeeting town future in hp so i could figure the game out as a town but i actually think you typically side with psycho just cuz you dont like to think for yourself so yes i am gunna push the sheep as scum

 

[MTR]

not nessarily but i gotta say i did enjoy yeeting town future in hp so i could figure the game out as a town but i actually think you typically side with psycho just cuz you dont like to think for yourself so yes i am gunna push the sheep as scum

I am not sheeping anyone. Come on now.

 

[Handium]

 

[Claws]

I am not sheeping anyone. Come on now.

sheeping sleeping same shit psycho is the shepard and you are the follower every game