What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mafia 33 - Gym Leader Mafia

Reader mode
Unless someone else wants to dispute it, I'm gunna assume matt and cwe are clean which gives something like

Me town fox
Listo the miller
BN the psych killer
Future the not protected
CWE the neighbor
Matt the neighbor

Val the derpy prolly town
Void the neut

Pups
Claws
Grumpy
 
Coming Guinea Pig GIF by Guinea Gambino
 
But seriously - if grumpy isn't full of shit, pups is prolly the better choice. Someone had to have blocked BN, and if claws is just a goon then it's likely pups

Unvote: Claws
Vote: Pups

And if it's not then we yeet grumpy into the sun
 
Claws said:
We wiped 2% on styx last night
Click to expand...
Its a pain in the ass fight... especially if you are close and then people tunnel and ignore the mechanics. Or hit the bomblets and put dots on everyone.

We had a couple pulls on H Mug. But people were being dumb and putting the jails and big fire soak in bad places to chop the room real small, or overlapping the jails so the dudes buff each other.
 
Foxxi said:
I mean, he's basically claimed wolf at this point. But again, if Grumpy is on the level then he's not the wolf that blocked you so makes more sense to try and find that
Click to expand...
Its claws giving scummy vibes... so likely town in wolfs clothing right now.

I can see grumpy being on scum, but would also not be the person that blocked me if his info is true.

3pups gave me scum vibes from his OP. I see most scum equity there.

Also cant get away from the tinfoil on you. Scum would want you gone early, but would they give you 1 night since you havent played much? Would they take that into account? Or are you scum just trying to get into everyones good graces. This is a problem for later in the game, not D2.
 
Blind Ninja said:
Now that you've remembered that the game is in fact going... and we are now a couple hours into D2... Any thoughts? (aside from MTR was killed to frame you or claws)
Click to expand...
Hmmm, Foxxi is 100% town. I have no idea how I feel about Claws. He’s willing to defend me but he usually isn’t like this. I see no reason why VK would lie about being third party.
 
FutureHold said:
Hmmm, Foxxi is 100% town. I have no idea how I feel about Claws. He’s willing to defend me but he usually isn’t like this. I see no reason why VK would lie about being third party.
Click to expand...
Calling someone 100% town, when they havent been cleared, is dangerous. The fact that scum didnt kill her on N1 should give you enough pause that she could be scum

Foxxi said:
Why the fuck am I 100% town? O.o
Click to expand...
I know, right... I wouldnt even say that the 2 neighbors are 100% town (both) but a better possibility then you at that percentage.

Claws said:
Cuz your smart and ppl arent as logical as you
Click to expand...
But she is smart. And Logical. And knows people will come after her.

Which is why im sus of her. It might be tinfoil, but enough to keep me honest in my assessments of her.
 
Blind Ninja said:
Calling someone 100% town, when they havent been cleared, is dangerous. The fact that scum didnt kill her on N1 should give you enough pause that she could be scum


I know, right... I wouldnt even say that the 2 neighbors are 100% town (both) but a better possibility then you at that percentage.


But she is smart. And Logical. And knows people will come after her.

Which is why im sus of her. It might be tinfoil, but enough to keep me honest in my assessments of her.
Click to expand...
It gives some pause for him. I actually believed Foxxi was town just from the beginning and the fact that she was the first person to post during night chat confirmed it.

Scum hate night chat. It lets everyone continue to talk. I don't think scum foxxi brings attention to that detail and in such a casual way.

Foxxi is also a better town than scum. She is far more engaged, especially it being her first game in months? than I would expect to see if she had randed scum in a game she likely didn't fully intend to play :D

However, Future isn't one to typically notice these things so I agree it's suspicious and goes perfectly well with the assumption that he killed MTR for the lulz.
 
I should have slept in.

Flannery being a brand new gym leader with no prior public speaking or leadership experience and having a hiccup giving you your challenge was a pretty interesting bit of flavor.

I trust GrumpyCat.
 
GrumpyCat said:
Pups ofc. i pressed just the right buttons and now he will be on me forever.
Click to expand...

I didn't trust you yesterday and see no reason to trust anything from you today.

I was hoping we'd get some deets or something, because all I am seeing is clear as mud.

Listo and BN are town, as are most likely our presumed remaining neighbors CWE and Matthieu

Void being 3rd party - I see no reason they'd claim this if they weren't, because it clearly could be disputed.

Foxxi is probably her town solvy self. Not sure why she hasn't claimed, but I agree with a lot of what she has posted. I will always be wary of her because she is certainly skilled enough to be a wolf, but I think it's likely she's town. Not worth pushing yet, but I'd like her to claim. I'd like everyone to tell us their role.

BN claims to have an important town role, and to have been roleblocked. Not so, as he was jailed, by yours truly. BN claimed to have an important town role so I thought he made himself a target, and that scum would want revenge for him taking out psycho. So I protected him, figuring his role will be needed later

Future claims to have been framed for MTR's death. Isn't adding much else. That 100% town comment on Foxxi made me wonder a bit as well.

Claws is always sus, and true to form brings nothing to help.

I was going to say Val also hasn't done much to help. Val seems to like to lay low at the beginning of games. Then Val comes in to say Grumpy is trustworthy.

Grumpy claims to be a hider, then backed off, but the comment about pushing my buttons because I voted there yesterday just rubs me the wrong way.

Vote:
Grumpy


Val, can you give more of an explanation as to why you trust Grumpy?
 
How are you gonna bury your claim in a wall of text and make me read the entire thing to find it. I was about to jump all over you for demanding other people claim but you didn't claim yourself.
 
Mmmmmmmmm...... why would you prevent the useful town role from acting? Keeping them alive is all well and good, but their role isn't useful if they can't, ya know... use it? So seems kinda counter-productive. "Keep them alive so they can use the useful role I'm stopping them from using!"

This claim isn't implausible... but I think it's perfect cover for a scum role block - and I think BN after his claim is the most plausible target *for* scum to choose to block since they'd prolly be worried about a doc protect on him too.
 
Foxxi said:
Mmmmmmmmm...... why would you prevent the useful town role from acting? Keeping them alive is all well and good, but their role isn't useful if they can't, ya know... use it? So seems kinda counter-productive. "Keep them alive so they can use the useful role I'm stopping them from using!"

This claim isn't implausible... but I think it's perfect cover for a scum role block - and I think BN after his claim is the most plausible target *for* scum to choose to block since they'd prolly be worried about a doc protect on him too.
Click to expand...

Because I didn't/don't know what roles we have. I trust BN because of his voting to take out psycho. I don't know what his role actually is, but he's clearly town. With no other info out there, I couldn't think of who else to protect. And I think of the jailor as protector more than as preventing someone from using their role, at least early on.

I also debated in my mind protecting you, since as a very strong player you're usually an early target. I went with BN since I was more convinced he's town.
 
Blind Ninja said:
So I was told my action did not go through... so I was likely blocked
Click to expand...

3puppies said:
I didn't trust you yesterday and see no reason to trust anything from you today.

I was hoping we'd get some deets or something, because all I am seeing is clear as mud.

Listo and BN are town, as are most likely our presumed remaining neighbors CWE and Matthieu

Void being 3rd party - I see no reason they'd claim this if they weren't, because it clearly could be disputed.

Foxxi is probably her town solvy self. Not sure why she hasn't claimed, but I agree with a lot of what she has posted. I will always be wary of her because she is certainly skilled enough to be a wolf, but I think it's likely she's town. Not worth pushing yet, but I'd like her to claim. I'd like everyone to tell us their role.

BN claims to have an important town role, and to have been roleblocked. Not so, as he was jailed, by yours truly. BN claimed to have an important town role so I thought he made himself a target, and that scum would want revenge for him taking out psycho. So I protected him, figuring his role will be needed later

Future claims to have been framed for MTR's death. Isn't adding much else. That 100% town comment on Foxxi made me wonder a bit as well.

Claws is always sus, and true to form brings nothing to help.

I was going to say Val also hasn't done much to help. Val seems to like to lay low at the beginning of games. Then Val comes in to say Grumpy is trustworthy.

Grumpy claims to be a hider, then backed off, but the comment about pushing my buttons because I voted there yesterday just rubs me the wrong way.

Vote:
Grumpy


Val, can you give more of an explanation as to why you trust Grumpy?
Click to expand...
I stated that my action did not go through and presumed i was blocked. I didnt say roleblocked, since multiple roles have a way to stop actions.

Also feel the same as Foxxi. how does preventing me from using an action help town if i said I had a useful town role?

Vote: 3pup
 
3puppies said:
Because I didn't/don't know what roles we have. I trust BN because of his voting to take out psycho. I don't know what his role actually is, but he's clearly town. With no other info out there, I couldn't think of who else to protect. And I think of the jailor as protector more than as preventing someone from using their role, at least early on.

I also debated in my mind protecting you, since as a very strong player you're usually an early target. I went with BN since I was more convinced he's town.
Click to expand...
I would 100% vote a teammate out for early town cred.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Handium
Mafia 33 - Gym Leader Mafia
Replies
57
Views
777
VoidKitten
VoidKitten
PsychoSoldier
Mafia Universe Championship Season 12
Replies
29
Views
424
Handium
Handium
Foxxi
Mafia 29: The Killing Itch
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
652
Views
5K
3puppies
3
VoidKitten
Mafia 25 - The Town of Warcraft
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
1K
Views
21K
Val the Moofia Boss
Val the Moofia Boss
Foxxi
Mafia 26 - The Monster Mash
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
583
Views
6K
Tildey
Tildey
Back
Top Bottom