Fingers of Suspicion
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Mafia 39 - Ghost Town
- Thread starter Foxxi
- Start date
- Tagged users None
CWE
Godfather
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
As the weekend is here, I have little time and won't likely make my min post counts.
I don't trust Mazer, but then again, I never do. I don't trust anyone but myself.
CWE is the only one I will trust completely - he won't lie. I am trying to decide if CWE has info or if he is seeking info.
We need information - and nobody wants to or has anything to share. With nobody mentioning about not getting results, I don't think the scum pulled a mass role block. Probably wouldn't make sense in a game this small.
There apparently is a traitor. Which to me means we have someone who can get information about alignment or roles.
The other way to get info is vote history and engagement.
I don't mind voting for Blind, but purely in the interest of a counter train, I will stick with
Vote: Claws
I don't trust Mazer, but then again, I never do. I don't trust anyone but myself.
CWE is the only one I will trust completely - he won't lie. I am trying to decide if CWE has info or if he is seeking info.
We need information - and nobody wants to or has anything to share. With nobody mentioning about not getting results, I don't think the scum pulled a mass role block. Probably wouldn't make sense in a game this small.
There apparently is a traitor. Which to me means we have someone who can get information about alignment or roles.
The other way to get info is vote history and engagement.
I don't mind voting for Blind, but purely in the interest of a counter train, I will stick with
Vote: Claws
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
He said "when the bandwagon follows the sharpest stick, enlightenment follows".
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
Do we know if foxxi has been using a mafia knows or doesn't know the traitor mechanic?
Val the Moofia Boss
Vigilante
Claws
All-Knowing
im not sure what marked for death could mean maybe its you get killed in a certain amount of days or maybe thats the target that dies at night idk i also have no idea if you are told your are teh marked one
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
Claws
All-Knowing
your missing GC
Claws
All-Knowing
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
or am I?
Claws
All-Knowing
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
Claws
All-Knowing
gc maybe defeatism from being brought up
psycho for saying he vibes with me but then wants every1 take on me
a spicy team would be mazer psycho but id think cwe would hone in one that shit like a fat kid eating cake
I don't read emoticons either. I am wondering if CWE was cursed, and can only speak in emoticons?
I initially read this as "Get on the bandwagon, or get slapped. Be suspicious of everyone and let's try to solve this. Shrug and Cheers" which could mean he's not sure. Then again I don't know if this was sober CWE or his drunken alter-ego. If he's close, it's worth celebrating with a couple drinks.
then we got my
Was this the direct response to the question about does CWE have info, or is this a hunch? This is what has me wondering if he's been cursed, but it could mean it's a only a guess.
@CWE, if you've been cursed, reply and ask for a couple drinks.
But, if you have info, then reply with the squint.
And if you're only on a hunch, then please reply with the shrug.
Claws, your repeating my question to CWE is not really solving, but it feels to me like you are trying to appear to be solving. Then again, your answer to Mazer's question about "marked for death" is helpful, but I don't see the relevance.
But that makes me wonder more about Mazer. This is just harder without any write-ups. You have my head spinning, in part because we recently rewatched Treasure Island, and the pirate's Black Spot is a part of the plot, the mark of death
I think I'd like to hear from Val the Moofia Boss, and/or the ghost of Matthieu, before automatically clearing Val
As for Grumpy, I guess I could go either way, depending on CWE's potential response.
Not sure I get a chance to reply again before EOD Sunday evening.
I initially read this as "Get on the bandwagon, or get slapped. Be suspicious of everyone and let's try to solve this. Shrug and Cheers" which could mean he's not sure. Then again I don't know if this was sober CWE or his drunken alter-ego. If he's close, it's worth celebrating with a couple drinks.
then we got my
and
followed by
Was this the direct response to the question about does CWE have info, or is this a hunch? This is what has me wondering if he's been cursed, but it could mean it's a only a guess.
@CWE, if you've been cursed, reply and ask for a couple drinks.
But, if you have info, then reply with the squint.
And if you're only on a hunch, then please reply with the shrug.
Claws, your repeating my question to CWE is not really solving, but it feels to me like you are trying to appear to be solving. Then again, your answer to Mazer's question about "marked for death" is helpful, but I don't see the relevance.
But that makes me wonder more about Mazer. This is just harder without any write-ups. You have my head spinning, in part because we recently rewatched Treasure Island, and the pirate's Black Spot is a part of the plot, the mark of death
I think I'd like to hear from Val the Moofia Boss, and/or the ghost of Matthieu, before automatically clearing Val
As for Grumpy, I guess I could go either way, depending on CWE's potential response.
Not sure I get a chance to reply again before EOD Sunday evening.
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
Grumpy is the main person I'm interested in flipping today. You were the first one to call him out. So I want everyone in the game to have a take on you that way in any event where one of you flip, we get a bit more to potentially dig into later
Why haven't you voted Grumpy despite being the first one to sus him?
CWE
Godfather
Claws
All-Knowing
I typically dont vote ppl i sus early when ppl jump on to not hit majority by accident
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
Because of votes or other reasons?
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
Yeah. Psych. Explain anything else if you want.
GrumpyCat
Mastermind
Psychos vote on me seems opportininstic sure, but its more like a vibe check. I expect this kind of game would me more up his alley but I dont see it. He is just there sitting on a sheep vote.
Claws is behaving in a way I would expect towny Claws to act. He can trick me at times so no guarantees.
Claws is behaving in a way I would expect towny Claws to act. He can trick me at times so no guarantees.
Mazer
Spirit Breaker
There was one thing claws said recently that I did not love.
No sir, I did not.
But I haven't played in more than a year, so its possible there was a change.
Some of this is weekend volume making for more limited reads.
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
What was the thing Claws said that you didn't like?
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
Is it this post?
Claws
All-Knowing
What i do old man
Claws
All-Knowing
Thats about to change if grandpa doesnt explain
Val the Moofia Boss
Vigilante
Foxxi
Administrator
Matthieu
Vigilante
Sure.
I'm a humble VT. So although I was killed, it isn't a devastating loss as I wasn't a cop, doctor or anything like that.
Hopefully N2 is more productive and town walks away with solid information to work with.
I can't figure this out without writeups or any info. We know there is a traitor - which Foxxi says will always appear as town, so there has to be someone with investigative role. But nobody shared D2 about info on N1 - which I guess I can understand because sharing will make them a target.
We lost two last night. Grumpy and Val. Grumpy was the leading train and he flipped town. Val is also gone, and he flipped green as well. I am thinking that one was a mafia kill while the other was Foxxi's mark of death. But I can't help but notice that Grumpy was warning us about Psycho, and Val also voted for Psycho. So I am thinking that maybe one of them had the investigator role and may have found scum, but didn't want to out their role. If so, we are probably screwed.
Grumpy's death does tell me that CWE is probably not the investigator, or at least he hadn't found a bad guy. I don't think CWE would post the shrugs emoji so much if he knew for sure. But at least when CWE is town, he understands we need information. I am getting mostly positive vibes from him.
This pings me that you have info you're not sharing. Isn't it possible that ANY of Matt, Val, or Grumpy could have been the traitor? Why are you focused on gc only? And why are you still alive? You voted for GC as well, but so did Psycho and Claws.
@MTR - where are you? You've been pretty quiet, and sitting in the background, not solving makes it hard to figure you out. On the one hand, if you were scum you easily could have voted to take Grumpy out, as only one more vote was needed and you didn't vote. But like Claws said, were you just content to wait for the mark of death?
I am not going to vote early, as even though I am leaning Psycho, if there is a scum killer and a traitor left, I don't want to give them the chance to pile on quickly if I am wrong.
We lost two last night. Grumpy and Val. Grumpy was the leading train and he flipped town. Val is also gone, and he flipped green as well. I am thinking that one was a mafia kill while the other was Foxxi's mark of death. But I can't help but notice that Grumpy was warning us about Psycho, and Val also voted for Psycho. So I am thinking that maybe one of them had the investigator role and may have found scum, but didn't want to out their role. If so, we are probably screwed.
Grumpy's death does tell me that CWE is probably not the investigator, or at least he hadn't found a bad guy. I don't think CWE would post the shrugs emoji so much if he knew for sure. But at least when CWE is town, he understands we need information. I am getting mostly positive vibes from him.
This pings me that you have info you're not sharing. Isn't it possible that ANY of Matt, Val, or Grumpy could have been the traitor? Why are you focused on gc only? And why are you still alive? You voted for GC as well, but so did Psycho and Claws.
@MTR - where are you? You've been pretty quiet, and sitting in the background, not solving makes it hard to figure you out. On the one hand, if you were scum you easily could have voted to take Grumpy out, as only one more vote was needed and you didn't vote. But like Claws said, were you just content to wait for the mark of death?
I am not going to vote early, as even though I am leaning Psycho, if there is a scum killer and a traitor left, I don't want to give them the chance to pile on quickly if I am wrong.
CWE
Godfather
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
This does make me wonder if Grumpy's death was intended to frame me, but also like I've been a limp noodle so far this game and my only push flipped town. Why would they kill me lol
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
I want to say that 3pups is just town this time, even if it kind of rubs me the wrong way that he's trying to use role conjecture as a reason to vote me, but I also think scum 3pups probably wouldn't hesitate with just voting right away
Mazer has been inquisitive but unimpactful. Which isn't particularly scummy for him. If anything I kind of expect him to have more leading questions and try to set up shade on more people, but it comes off a bit more like he's trying to gauge everyone.
CWE could be scum pretending to have a posting restriction, but not sure that's really his style. I'm more prone to believe he just had a misguided hunch on Grumpy and is kinda annoyed he can't talk more.
If I'm at all right in this, MTR and Claws become the two most concerning, though MTR is a coin flip and I'm still kind of mixed on whether Claws is posting in a towny way or trying to manipulate the thread while having little accountability himself
It's actually kind of weird Claws has been so reserved with votes now that I think about it
Mazer has been inquisitive but unimpactful. Which isn't particularly scummy for him. If anything I kind of expect him to have more leading questions and try to set up shade on more people, but it comes off a bit more like he's trying to gauge everyone.
CWE could be scum pretending to have a posting restriction, but not sure that's really his style. I'm more prone to believe he just had a misguided hunch on Grumpy and is kinda annoyed he can't talk more.
If I'm at all right in this, MTR and Claws become the two most concerning, though MTR is a coin flip and I'm still kind of mixed on whether Claws is posting in a towny way or trying to manipulate the thread while having little accountability himself
It's actually kind of weird Claws has been so reserved with votes now that I think about it
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
MTR
Mastermind
Or he is just being goofy. I mean pretty basic game so not sure if would see any kind of restrictions in play.
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
PsychoSoldier
Administrator
Claws
All-Knowing
Could he have been marked for death or val it was a double kill i cant see foxxi giving the scum team a double kill with this many players
Claws
All-Knowing
How does this shake the tree other then last day you were all with me and now you want to vote me you change your mind like i change my cat litter
Claws
All-Knowing
I explained why i reserve with votes earlyier to not get a pile in and end early by accident
