Living Players:
Claws
CWE
Dreyski
LemonDemonGirl
MitchRapp
MTR
Satsu
Val
WindwardAway
--
Copied from OP
Claws - I have some suspicion on claws but less than on satsu. And I would factor in Matt's read there but nobody answered me on how good he is at reading claws. Would vote, but seems unlikely for today. A few others have expressed scumreads on him, only satsu has expressed a read that wasn't scum, and it wasn't a townread, it was just "I will defend him from you because you're a wolf" which I'm not, so that is not a valid read.
CWE - has reads, refuses to give reads, would say that's towny for some players and not others. Would vote and give it a 50/50 chance of flipping scum tbh
Drey - they're maintaining a thread presence and making game-related posts without actually accomplishing much at all. Voted satsu after I did, saying that they wouldn't vote themselves and thought I was decent enough. Made no effort to come up with any scumreads of their own or give unique input. If they're scum, they're the type of player who keeps afloat by putting in just enough effort to not be accused of lurking scum, but also not so much as to agenda push in this state, which would directly imply that the gamestate is favorable for them and satsu is town (or at least, not scum). Felt kind of like they were whiteknighting me but I'm not sure because they didn't give any reasoning on why I'm towny other than that I'm posting.
LDG - more or less self-resolving, supposedly. Complained that everyone always scumreads her, when nobody was in fact scumreading her. Null to slightly towny because it just seems like an unnecessary post to make as scum when under no pressure, since it implies she didn't read anything at all in the thread, and if she were scum worried about getting flipped, she probably would've read at least the vote count??
MitchRapp - In light of the Satsu/Drey suspicions I have, I'm cooling off on Mitch. He might just have the sort of play style I naturally scumread regardless of alignment. I do feel like his posts have improved since earlier. I still don't townread him, but I don't really want to vote him for today because I think maybe he is actually doing some solving.
MTR - idk, I put a light townlean on him earlier for... existing and posting? But I don't find his posts particularly memorable, other than the one where he said he voted Claws on D1 because Future isn't in the game and he and Claws sometimes vote each other. It didn't really mean much, but because that was the most memorable thing about MTR aside from voting Satsu and saying he was doing it temporarily because he didn't have scumreads yet, it's also a bit worrying, particularly if Satsu is town.
Satsu - you've heard it from me a million times now, I think he's scummy, I think the fact that his case is predicted on "you are pushing me because you thought I would eventually push you" when I have no clue how he plays is absolute bullshit, and his only scumreads seemingly being on his 3 voters is also bullshit. But sadly, I don't even think Drey and MTR are out of potential scum range, so it does feel unfair to judge Satsu on that. I don't believe that he believes his read on me, though, and if he's town I would probably take him up on the Drey yeet suggestion.
Val - i think he's town. Unfortunately for him, he wasn't around when Matthieu kind of imploded under the thread pressure for... reasons. But I think, of the few posts he made today, Val seems the towniest of anyone so far, at least to me.
Ok I'm off to sleep now.