Mafia 23 - The Town of Rings

[Listo95]

She does respond to some people, just not me. The lack of effort for it, even 1 post mentioning her directly...

Main reason I didn't try is because I could still win even with her dead as long as I survive. Yes that relies on everyone else to actually keep me alive. But meh.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

What do you guys feel about MTR claiming at this point?

Safe or unsafe? I guess Doomsayer is still a possibility.

I think it's relatively safe. If he claims and it clears him for us, then Caito is very likely the other(maybe last?) Apoc. He could get doomed but at this stage it seems like a worthy tradeoff

 

[MTR]

If it will help town out then I will claim. We are down to the end

 

[MTR]

I am also a cleric.

I barried Matthieu night one just picking randomly.

N2 Psycho
N3 CWE but we still lost him anyway.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Unvote: Listo

Vote: Caito

I think Caito was probably telling the truth about not killing CWE because the Arsonist or some other killing role was responsible for it. I am leaning on believing Listo, and in the least he's not Apoc.

MTR is up in the air, and unless Claws claimed something other than TP that I missed, he could be a neutral killing maybe but not Apoc. BN could also maybe be neutral killing but his claim lines up, and I think him debating with me about the kills using the logic that CWE targeted Grumpy comes from someone who actually had that info, not someone playing to the fake claim.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I am also a cleric.

I barried Matthieu night one just picking randomly.

N2 Psycho
N3 CWE but we still lost him anyway.

This actually perfectly lines up with him saying he didn't buy Matthieu's claim, so yeah, I trust MTR

We kill Caito, and then maybe look for the arsonist

 

[MTR]

Vote: Caito

 

[MTR]

This actually perfectly lines up with him saying he didn't buy Matthieu's claim, so yeah, I trust MTR

We kill Caito, and then maybe look for the arsonist

Yeah I knew that we could have more than one of a role which we do but I was not buying Matthieu being a cleric

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Actually, thinking, CWE wouldn't be protected if Grumpy was the one killed and they died as lovers, right?

Is there any other way CWE could still die despite his targeting other than being blocked?

Either way, I think the claim is legit. Not sure why you would fake claim protecting a person died the same night lol

 

[MitchRapp]

Vote: Caito

 

[Blind Ninja]

Vote: Caito

 

[VoidKitten]

Day 4 Final Vote Count:

Caito - 6 (Apocaclaws #971, Psycho #1105, MTR #1107, Mitch #1110)

Not Voting: Blind Ninja, Caito, Listo

—------------------

As the day progressed, there was a sudden flurry of action as the group came together to put someone up for elimination. As arguments went back and forth, the group decided on a single name. Caito was the next person suspected of being an evildoer. Caito was not given the chance to defend himself before the group slit his throat in an offering to Cthulu and the Valar.

Caito, playing as Treebeard, the Coven Hex Master, has been eliminated.

—------------------

It is now Night 4. Night 4 will end at 8:00pm ET on Sept 25th or when all actions are submitted.

 

[VoidKitten]

The night seemed to speed by and dawn was starting to approach. Shelob decided to leave her cave as she was hungry and there were definitely some tasty morsels that she could find. Shelob stalked out of her cave with her mind on a single focus.

—------------------

PsychoSoldier, playing as Boromir, the Town Spy, has been killed.

—------------------

Living Players:

1. Apocaclaws
2. Blind Ninja
3. Listo
4. MitchRapp
5. MTR

Dead Players:

1. Val the Moofia Boss, playing as Gandalf, the Soul Collector was eliminated. (Day 2)
2. LDG, playing as the Ringwraiths, the Town Socialite, was modkilled. (Day 2)
3. Matthieu, playing as Smaug, the Plaguebearer, was eliminated. (Day 3)
4. Llettuce, playing as Bilbo Baggins, the Town Cleric, has been killed. (Night 3)
5. CWE, playing as Boromir, the Town Trickster, has been killed. (Night 3)
6. Grumpycat, playing as The Eagles, the Town Admirer, has been killed. (Night 3)
7. Caito, playing as Treebeard, the Coven Hex Master, has been eliminated. (Day 4)
8. PsychoSoldier, playing as Boromir, the Town Spy, has been killed. (Night 4)

—------------------

It is now Day 5. Day 5 will end at 8:00pm ET on Sept 27th or when majority is reached. With 5 players alive, majority is 3 votes on single player. If majority is not reached by the end of the day, there will be no elimination.

 

[MTR]

Okay. Down to the end. So at this point who do we not believe?

 

[MitchRapp]

Okay. Down to the end. So at this point who do we not believe?

 

[Blind Ninja]

Im wondering if this was a 2 apoc, 2 coven, 3p killer setup

Shelob sounds like WW for sure

 

[Blind Ninja]

Do we think we would have 2 clerics and a GA as protection roles?

 

[Listo95]

Do we think we would have 2 clerics and a GA as protection roles?

GA isn't technically a protection role. Yes it protects my 1 target but that is all it will ever do.

 

[Blind Ninja]

GA isn't technically a protection role. Yes it protects my 1 target but that is all it will ever do.

Fair

 

[Blind Ninja]

@MitchRapp I know you are a man of action, but your lone vote will end the day.

 

[Listo95]

BN did you see anything last night?

 

[Blind Ninja]

My 2 likely votes are MTR and listo. In that order.

If I want to get super tinfoil, I'd toss Claws... but i dont feel thats the right play.

 

[Blind Ninja]

BN did you see anything last night?

Unfortunately I did not

 

[Blind Ninja]

If I had, Id be leaning there, not on my list from yesterday

 

[Blind Ninja]

@Apocaclaws Did you claim at all?

 

[Listo95]

Unfortunately I did not

Yeah I was hoping you saw someone cause if you saw that person we know they can't be what is likely the WW.

 

[MTR]

I don't think claws has claimed and starting to wonder about him.

 

[MTR]

Not going to lie. I did self protect last night just in case. So leaving myself open by saying this.

 

[Apocaclaws]

I feel like mtr or bn imo

 

[Apocaclaws]

I don't think claws has claimed and starting to wonder about him.

I have claimed a tp thats all you need to know

 

[Apocaclaws]

I more lean mtr then bn its magical all of a sudden hes comming out with theories

 

[Apocaclaws]

More then*

 

[Apocaclaws]

@Apocaclaws Did you claim at all?

I did yes

 

[Apocaclaws]

Who did you watch bn

 

[Blind Ninja]

Who did you watch bn

you, because I was in tinfoil mode

 

[MTR]

I have claimed a tp thats all you need to know

At this point everyone has actually said what they are and their targets. We just need to lay the cards on the table to figure out who is not telling the truth. If you are not willing to share more than that then makes me sus. I mean I hate claiming as well and avoid it but I claimed to help out town.

 

[Blind Ninja]

I have claimed a tp thats all you need to know

I think at this point, it may be worth more of a claim

 

[Apocaclaws]

you, because I was in tinfoil mode

I didnt act plus psycho looked at me twice and i stated im done acting why the blazes choose me

 

[Apocaclaws]

I think at this point, it may be worth more of a claim

Hahah no.

 

[Apocaclaws]

Im a TP

 

[Apocaclaws]

Its really between mtr and bn for last scum then idk for 3p moght have to just yeet listo with the nuet claim but id prefer to let that slide today

 

[Apocaclaws]

Vote: mtr

 

[Blind Ninja]

Its really between mtr and bn for last scum then idk for 3p moght have to just yeet listo with the nuet claim but id prefer to let that slide today

Im kinda in the same boat as you with MTR and listo, but if game doesnt end there, i think its you

 

[Blind Ninja]

Vote: MTR

 

[Apocaclaws]

Im kinda in the same boat as you with MTR and listo, but if game doesnt end there, i think its you

DOnt worry if mtr flips not scum ill be voting you next?

 

[MTR]

Barking up the wrong tree here.

Vote: claws

 

[Apocaclaws]

Barking up the wrong tree here.

Vote: claws

I doubt this

 

[MTR]

I doubt this

I am going to flip cleric if you guys hammer me. I am not convinced at all that you are town at this point.

 

[Apocaclaws]

Ive fully claimed since like game started i believe yall just to stupid to look past my memes of bread im not famine

 

[Apocaclaws]

Unvote:

 

[Apocaclaws]

I am going to flip cleric if you guys hammer me. I am not convinced at all that you are town at this point.

Who have you protected

 

[Apocaclaws]

Enlighten me

 

[Apocaclaws]

Why didnt you counter grae

 

[Apocaclaws]

So mamy fucking questions

 

[Blind Ninja]

Why didnt you counter grae

not to mention Llettuce also flipped Cleric

 

[Apocaclaws]

not to mention Llettuce also flipped Cleric

Its possible but i need to know who he "protected"

 

[MTR]

Who have you protected

I listed who I protected already.

N1 Matthieu
N2 Psycho
N3 CWE
N4 me

 

[MTR]

not to mention Llettuce also flipped Cleric

we can have more than one of the same role.

 

[Blind Ninja]

Its possible but i need to know who he "protected"

Since you've claimed a TP, and say you've hinted at your role...

Who have you targeted each night? And nights you didnt do anything, why?

 

[Apocaclaws]

I didnt target n1 n3 and n4

 

[Blind Ninja]

I listed who I protected already.

N1 Matthieu
N2 Psycho
N3 CWE
N4 me

I can see CWE dying if he was in fact a lover... If he wasnt, what roles could have killed through the cleric protect?

 

[Blind Ninja]

I didnt target n1 n3 and n4

why?

 

[Apocaclaws]

Why because i let it ride

 

[Apocaclaws]

I fuction that way

 

[Blind Ninja]

Im full tinfoil that if MTR isnt scum, and listo is GA turned surv....

Claws is the right way

 

[MTR]

I can see CWE dying if he was in fact a lover... If he wasnt, what roles could have killed through the cleric protect?

Not sure. He died probably because he was a lover.

 

[Blind Ninja]

Still feel MTR is the way to go

 

[Apocaclaws]

Im full tinfoil that if MTR isnt scum, and listo is GA turned surv....

Claws is the right way

And your lookout list?

 

[Apocaclaws]

Pls

 

[Apocaclaws]

Trying to figure wjos more plaisebles

 

[Apocaclaws]

Im useing my little grey cells

 

[Blind Ninja]

And your lookout list?

You want everyone to claim, but dont outright say what you are... Making me lean more towards you

I have an idea what you hinted at, but I still dont get why you would only act 1 night

 

[Apocaclaws]

You want everyone to claim, but dont outright say what you are... Making me lean more towards you

I have an idea what you hinted at, but I still dont get why you would only act 1 night

No i know your claim i want your actions

 

[Blind Ninja]

No i know your claim i want your actions

Ive stated my actions. I want your claim. To see if I should stay on MTR or potentially move it for not being willing to share at this point in the game.

 

[Apocaclaws]

You can read my will if i flip its very very well written

 

[Apocaclaws]

Its so odd that no1 has protected mitch

 

[MTR]

Its so odd that no1 has protected mitch

because he is a revealed mayor so I can't protect him.

 

[Blind Ninja]

Also find it odd that none of the scum have decided to kill Mitch.

 

[Apocaclaws]

I cant find your action list

 

[Apocaclaws]

Since Im being pegged as 3p or scum, ill claim.

Im the lookout

N1: Claws had no visitors
N2: Claws was visited by Psycho
N3: Grumpy was visited by CWE

Found it why look at me twice

 

[Apocaclaws]

3 times

 

[Apocaclaws]

What dafuck

 

[Apocaclaws]

Why not watch mitch that would of been the sensible thing

 

[Blind Ninja]

3 times

Twice... N1/2

and I said in a following post after that one, since you werent visited N1, I figured someone would visit you N2

 

[Apocaclaws]

N1 n2 and n4

 

[Blind Ninja]

Why not watch mitch that would of been the sensible thing

You talk about others doing sensible things, yet claimed to have done nothing n1/3/4... how is that sensible?

 

[Blind Ninja]

N1 n2 and n4

I didnt claim a N4 actions, just that I didnt see anything

 

[Apocaclaws]

Whats your n4 then

 

[Apocaclaws]

Cuz all im seeing is im the sensible one

 

[Blind Ninja]

Whats your n4 then

NVM... forgot that I did claim you.

 

[Blind Ninja]

Cuz all im seeing is im the sensible one

You not claiming at this point doesnt look good in my eyes

 

[Blind Ninja]

And again, I dont really trust you, so wanted to see if anyone was going to visit you

 

[Blind Ninja]

Im full tinfoil

 

[Apocaclaws]

Why 3x thats absurd what a waste of a lookout

 

[Blind Ninja]

Your unwillingness to claim, while everyone else in game has, is shifting my view of you

 

[Apocaclaws]

Btw remember listo 3p is scum siding if he gets a chance but i still think hes less of a threat

 

[Blind Ninja]

not acting on 3x at night is an absurd waste of a role

 

[Apocaclaws]

Your unwillingness to claim, while everyone else in game has, is shifting my view of you

Thats fine im tempted to vote you for watching me 3x

 

[Blind Ninja]

Unvote:

 

[Apocaclaws]

Oh noes here comes his vote lol