What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mafia 38 - Trouble Brewing

  • Thread starter Thread starter Foxxi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Reader mode
Honestly its a pretty chill job.

And I thought you said if we get it wrong here we lose? How is that not enough time to make a better nom lol
 
It was clear to me that Xan was the undertaker from his prior hint about not getting information yet. Based on the other claimed roles, it was the only remaining role that got information that could be shared.

From my own info, Xan might also be the drunk.
 
Listo95 said:
So crazy idea. Foxxi almost rarely will give someone a specific role. Has she done it before yes. But with this being 1st time in this section I highly doubt it.
Click to expand...

And I think otherwise., or at least, instead of giving someone a specific role, but I think she may have run several randomized draws to settle on one she liked.
 
3puppies said:
Now, I don't see how town has a chance of learning anything.
Click to expand...
If slayer kills a demon and game doesnt end then scarlet lady is not next to them. Otherwise ldg can be confirmed as virgin by town dying on nomination. Otherwise no idea. I think we already have as much info as there is.
 
GrumpyCat said:
If slayer kills a demon and game doesnt end then scarlet lady is not next to them. Otherwise ldg can be confirmed as virgin by town dying on nomination. Otherwise no idea. I think we already have as much info as there is.
Click to expand...
Considering I have a 1/7 chance of hitting the demon I’m more likely to have nothing happen when I shoot.
 
If we keep xan alive, he will surely be killed by the demon as he would be the only remaining way to get meaningful information. But that's only if we execute someone, and xan then survives another night, and xan actually is who he has claimed, and not the drunk or evil.

If we execute him, it brings the end of this game sooner. Theoretically, I suppose he could be the demon or even formerly the scarlet lady. And if so, that might even end the game now, but we won't even know, because if the game doesn't end it could mean he was the demon and someone else is the lady who will step in.. I don't really trust Claws, so I doubt any of that.

The question is, does keeping xan alive give town a better chance, toward the end of the game? Who do we want to see in the final three, knowing that three have lied to us?

I suppose
Vote: YES

I feel completely defeated by this game.

The weekend approaches. I do not expect to be around that much.
 
Now that I know CWE's role just narrows down who is and isn't Demon, I'm kind of back to just Occam's Razor and that CWE's role is legit, which would mean there's a demon between Xan/Blind unless we have a Scarlet Lady

That said, Xan being a demon basically requires 3pups to be a minion or CWE happening to get the right information beside being drunk.

I guess it also requires Grumpy to be scum or for 3pups to be a spy

I dunno, this game is making my head hurt

Let's just make something happen

Vote: Yes
 
Xanjori has reached 5 votes and will be eliminated at the end of day unless another nominated player receives six or more votes. Voting remains open until 2:30am est, and then nominations may continue.

Day ends tomorrow at 8am est.
 
Looks like there just a few hours left. you could nominate NQM is she is a virging you could die and thats info. You die anyway so what can go wrong. Otherwise make one on someone who you think is scummier and see how it goes?
 
i think the only 2 ppl alive i havent talked ot are mattieu and nqm so ill have a chat with either of them if they want to it is thanksgiving here in canada today so i will be on an off
 
I feel like enough time has been given for this person to start to participate...

While I dont think they are the demon... has not done anything town and can likely be a minion.

Nominate: NQM
 
Matthieu said:
Vote: Yes

I'm much more suspicious of NQM than BN for whatever that is worth.
Click to expand...
Claws had info of no pairs...

So who do you find to be more scummy, Psycho or BN? Why?

Why are you town and listo scum?

Or do you think we already have dead scum?

(this is assuming all dead are town and NQM is one of the minions.)
 
3puppies said:
But if you are demon or minion, you would not die by nominating the virgin.

Only town dies by nominating the virgin.
Click to expand...
I understand that. But can promise you, 100%, I am not the demon. I am not a minion. I am exactly what I claimed on Day 1, the washerwoman.

I assume ive been left alive, since I dont bring any new information on a day to day basis. And for the potential mislynch in the late game.
 
Nightmare Queen Miko will be eliminated at the end of the day phase. Voting remains open until 6:40am, and then nominations will be open once more.
 
@Nightmare Queen Miko , I don't believe you are the demon, and I think it is wrong of town to yeet you.

But you have reached the number of votes needed for elimination, so if you are town, town can still win, and you can very much help the rest of town as follows -

First, you need to claim your role.

Second, you need to nominate someone else, and if they get more votes than you, you will stay alive.
 
Blind Ninja said:
I understand that. But can promise you, 100%, I am not the demon. I am not a minion. I am exactly what I claimed on Day 1, the washerwoman.

I assume ive been left alive, since I dont bring any new information on a day to day basis. And for the potential mislynch in the late game.
Click to expand...

If this is true, why do you think I was targetted? I think its because I was clearly on to something by pointing out that the scum team communication on Day 1 had to include Claws.
 
3puppies said:
@Nightmare Queen Miko , I don't believe you are the demon, and I think it is wrong of town to yeet you.

But you have reached the number of votes needed for elimination, so if you are town, town can still win, and you can very much help the rest of town as follows -

First, you need to claim your role.

Second, you need to nominate someone else, and if they get more votes than you, you will stay alive.
Click to expand...
Fine, I'm the Chef. No clue who to nominate, I think I'll just let myself die.
My blood is about ready to boil outside of my fucking skin.
 
Nightmare Queen Miko said:
Fine, I'm the Chef. No clue who to nominate, I think I'll just let myself die.
My blood is about ready to boil outside of my fucking skin.
Click to expand...

Thank you. But hasn't Claws also claimed to be the chef? And hasn't the washerwoman claimed that the chef was either you or Claws?

The chef got information about how many pairs there are. Can you please share that for us? It will help determine who we should suggest you nominate.
 
First, I was clearly wrong about your role, as I thought you were the virgin.

Second, this makes Claws evil for sure, and someone working with Claws.

@BN, did you mention to Claws that I shared with you that Grumpy was the empath, and had cleared me and Claws? If so, that would have let Claws know he would have to keep poisoning Grumpy until Grumpy's death.

NQM did not have private chats with anyone. She would not have known she needed to kill Grumpy to keep Claws alive.
 
3puppies said:
First, I was clearly wrong about your role, as I thought you were the virgin.

Second, this makes Claws evil for sure, and someone working with Claws.

@BN, did you mention to Claws that I shared with you that Grumpy was the empath, and had cleared me and Claws? If so, that would have let Claws know he would have to keep poisoning Grumpy until Grumpy's death.

NQM did not have private chats with anyone. She would not have known she needed to kill Grumpy to keep Claws alive.
Click to expand...
How does it make me evil i claimed ages ago
 
If NQM was evil, then she presumably would have claimed to be the virgin, or more likely, she would not have claimed. There is no reason at all for her to have claimed to be the chef.
 
3puppies said:
If NQM was evil, then she presumably would have claimed to be the virgin, or more likely, she would not have claimed. There is no reason at all for her to have claimed to be the chef.
Click to expand...
Why shes def hasnt read the whole game she likely just didnt see my claim
 
GrumpyCat said:
And if Claws is evil then the pair is BN/Psycho or Listo/Matt, right?

Well if Xan was a hit it could have been Xan/Listo too.
Click to expand...
How do you even think there was a world where I was a hit? Like can we at least try and play this properly

And I believe NQMs claim here tbh.

And no 3puppies I didnt actually get the info, I was memeing cos we finally executed someone
 
In a world you aren't demon and don't have safe claims.

Also it makes BN look better because he guessed Chef within 2 players, And would also give you a better claim ;>
And if BN is town it makes Psycho town because it would be a pair.
 
So we are left with Listo/Matt. Unless it was Xan then ist Listo. I liked Xans claim tbh but I won't be convinced that he cant make a good claim.
And in a rare world where MTR self killed on mayor Psycho it has to be Matt.
 
GrumpyCat said:
And if Claws is evil then the pair is BN/Psycho or Listo/Matt, right?

Well if Xan was a hit it could have been Xan/Listo too.
Click to expand...

Which would mean if Listo is telling the truth about being the slayer, he would have a 50% chance of winning the game for us by killing one of BN or Psycho.

But Claws also talked with Psycho and Listo on Day 1. If BN was evil, he might know the washerwoman was safe, but before he claimed the info he had, he would want to know the other safe roles. Would BN have picked that the chef was out there, and that it was between one of Claws or NQM. I think this makes BN look more towny. Which means the pair should be Listo/Matt, or Listo/Xan.

Another possibility, that I will discount, is that if NQM is the demon after all, her blood is boiling because she's been caught, and that she hadn't communicated at all to the others. Too much tinfoil for me.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

VoidKitten
Mafia 37 - Town of Unlimited Pasta-bilities
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
541
Views
7K
Linguine
Linguine
VoidKitten
Mafia 36 - Cursed Souls
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
1K
Views
11K
VoidKitten
VoidKitten
VoidKitten
Mafia 34 - The Prized Traitor
2 3 4 5
Replies
469
Views
10K
Val the Moofia Boss
Val the Moofia Boss
VoidKitten
Mafia 35 - Another Day, Another Town
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
669
Views
14K
3puppies
3
MitchRapp
Mafia 32- Traitors
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
781
Views
24K
MTR
MTR
Back
Top Bottom