Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mafia 22: <Insert Title Here>

  • Thread starter Thread starter Foxxi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Also, we should make a decision within the next 12ish or so hours. I would not be surprised if a re-rand happened again because we took too long or some shit.
 
Also, we should make a decision within the next 12ish or so hours. I would not be surprised if a re-rand happened again because we took too long or some shit.
Oh yeah I don't doubt that, that's why I'm trying to solve as fast as I can 😄
Not like I really mind the rerand, it makes things interesting, but if it frustrates people the engagement levels might go down again, and i want to avoid that.
 
But yeah basically my thought was that LDG likely was a cop, but then why werent we told about it? So then I thought, maybe she was scum and decided to lie, but the last day of the previous rand never actually ended, so she had like no premise for claiming to suddenly have a result on MTR just to bus him. But for that matter, she also shouldn't have gotten a random cop result if the day didn't end, either...
 
Did yall know about a doctor? Because if a doctor was discussed, i find it unlikely that a cop was never discussed at all. ever.
There was discussion over a doctor but from when I was there, I can’t recall cop being brought up.
 
Oh btw I ISO'd Satsu, I'm not fully convinced he's town but he also went for me like last time so honestly idk, he might just not know how to read me 🤷

I don't think he looks the scummiest today, though. Only thing I think might be a red flag is saying he'd vote me if you guys could get enough votes on me, because I can't be voted today, and neither can he so I'm pretty sure he's aware of that. But that's more like I think it mightve been a suggestion to waste votes and not so much that I think he's actually trying to get me voted out specifically today.
 
Val also said he was vanilla when asked.

LDG - Cop
Val - Vanilla
MTR - No claim, but probably scum by PoE unless both val and LDG are lying lol.
Is there like, any chance Mitch would lie?
He'd have a reason to lie if he went scum > scum, if only because I pushed him on the premise that his baseless pushing on me was very similar. If he's town now I don't think he would've had a reason to lie either way.
 
Is there like, any chance Mitch would lie?
He'd have a reason to lie if he went scum > scum, if only because I pushed him on the premise that his baseless pushing on me was very similar. If he's town now I don't think he would've had a reason to lie either way.
Satsu and Mitch corroborated they were neighbors.

So technically Mitch could be scum since its neighbors, but eh.
 
Satsu and Mitch corroborated they were neighbors.

So technically Mitch could be scum since its neighbors, but eh.
Neighbors doesn't mean anything, the only thing I care about is whether Satsu thought Mitch was towny then and if he still thinks Mitch is towny now, since he probably has more to compare with.

And I have a mild suspicion on Satsu here but I don't think his play is wildly different from in the previous rand. I'm not more sus of Satsu now than I was in the previous rand, and he flipped town there so I don't really want to go the same route and potentially repeat the mistake.
 
I think its Mitch, LDG, or MTR today.

MTR since he hasn't posted. I know he is sick, but gotta post to play.
LDG since this confusion, but risk losing a cop if she is actually currently a cop. But we won't get a ton of meaningful posts.
Mitch since his demeanor changed and at least 3 of us felt a certain way about it.
 
Neighbors doesn't mean anything, the only thing I care about is whether Satsu thought Mitch was towny then and if he still thinks Mitch is towny now, since he probably has more to compare with.

And I have a mild suspicion on Satsu here but I don't think his play is wildly different from in the previous rand. I'm not more sus of Satsu now than I was in the previous rand, and he flipped town there so I don't really want to go the same route and potentially repeat the mistake.
I think the kill choice tonight will be interesting.
 
Vote: MTR
Why did you suddenly start posting again? Did your Scum chat tell you to?

Last post pre re-rand. - Foxxi

Vote: MTR
Checked, he's sus.

I did last night


Ok so check this out, LDG's last post on MTR before reranding was accusing him of being scum, and then immediately after the rerand she claims to have copped him. She specifically says she copped him the night before (if I'm reading this correctly) because there was no night phase between the rands. Meaning LDG would've known the whole day that MTR was scum, if she actually copped him.
 
CWE is my main sus person at this point. Just doesn't seem interested in being helpful

Well you aren't posting much either so....

I wake up to three votes. What in the world.

Any particular reason for this vote? I get claws and I can see why Dreyski would go ahead and get on the train but curious why start with me

Just vote someone lmao
If we look even farther back:
MTR shades CWE, MTR gets voted by 3 people, engages specifically with Mitch about his vote, LDG just says to vote and then AFTER that she later votes MTR but never claims she has a cop result on him.

I think she's lying about being a cop in the previous rand, but I'm not sure why, other than that she doesn't want people to know she was scum previously.

Vote: LDG
 
Ftr I also still think the other two top wagons are fine, I'd move if we need it to flip a wagon. But this is where my suspicion is greatest right now.
 
@Badger Why aren't you scum

Well I only just got made aware that there was a re-rand so yeah kinda switched off a bit after being killed early and some dead chat discourse wasn’t expecting a second chance as there seemed to be a legit dead chat going on.
The closest I can remember is being placed in “limbo”. Hell I’ve run games like that so this came as a bit of a surprise.

If you know my scum play, I’d still be active trying to misdirect.

Also the small matter of being pineapple town too.

From reading through, I’m liking CWE’s play a bit better, seems more towny. I would agree that Mitch does seem a bit different too.
 
Youre Welcome Maui GIF
 
He was Satsu's neighbor pre-rand and I assume they're not neighbors again, though. That's why I poked Mitch to give a read on Satsu if he had one. Maybe I should also poke @Satsu to ask whether he thinks Mitch is playing different to the first rand.
He doesnt seem different to me and i had a town lean on him last game. His push on you last game could look unnatural because he asked me if i had thoughts about the game and i said i have scum read on you. And he was like ok lets do windward.
 
I Cant wrap my head around yall tryung to yeet the cop tho
Because she hasn't specifically claimed she is currently the cop, as far as I can tell.

That is just us inferring because we don't think there was a cop last game.

But why not just be clear and not lie?
 
Unvote:

We can give her the day. Scum will either shoot her or we will have her "cop check" and see who she picks and what she gets.
 
Would Foxxi let scum be closeish to a victory, re-rand the game, and make the same person have to be scum again and start over?

That's just evil if so :D
 
I am heading into a meeting. I wont be around for a bit so I am moving my vote as it seems like a solid way to check and not possibly lose the cop.

Vote: MTR
 
Like im not saying her whole train is for that reason

But unless Foxxi put in a Day Cop, there is no chance she has info on MTR for this re-rand.
 
Back
Top Bottom