Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

[Tildey]

I still need to go back and re-read again, but first things that stand out is Hermoine’s action. N1 she was armed with knowledge about Death Eaters. N2 it’s Alliance. Does that mean she can only check for one or the other depending on Odd/Even night?

Did Peeves get two actions? Kill attempt on CWE plus taking Diva’s wand?

Speaking of CWE - how many bpv’s are there in this game?

 

[Kareemah]

LMAO DID U MAKE THIS MEME I was like he’s finding very specific badger pictures, I couldn’t post that yesterday

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Well that was an eventful night phase. It's about time I get my spreadsheet started

 

[Kareemah]

From reading this I have a strong suspicious that 3pups is town and I think maybe Xanjori

 

[PsychoSoldier]

@VoidKitten I assume there's no mistake, but still no Badger flip, right?

 

[PsychoSoldier]

We know Lucius did a rolecop on Homely Man, but he intended to target Randolph. So Randolph isn't a Death Eater.

 

[Tildey]

@VoidKitten I assume there's no mistake, but still no Badger flip, right?

I hate the lack of flips. I’m assuming it means there’s a someone with a reviver/resurrection action out there and we won’t see flips until they use their action(s).

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I still need to go back and re-read again, but first things that stand out is Hermoine’s action. N1 she was armed with knowledge about Death Eaters. N2 it’s Alliance. Does that mean she can only check for one or the other depending on Odd/Even night?

Did Peeves get two actions? Kill attempt on CWE plus taking Diva’s wand?

Speaking of CWE - how many bpv’s are there in this game?

That would make sense, and keep it from being too OP.

I think Void does what I usually do where any actions separated by a line of hyphens is technically not a night action. So my guess is it's either a twilight action, a predetermined day action, or something that was specifically triggered.

Knowing Void, there's probably a few BPVs lol

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I hate the lack of flips. I’m assuming it means there’s a someone with a reviver/resurrection action out there and we won’t see flips until they use their action(s).

Usually yes, but the flavor of Caito's death implies he was cannibalized, which means we won't get his flip until maybe the person who killed him dies.

I think Badger is someone who could be revived, but it's also not impossible there's a role that needs to die before we see flips. I don't think Void is being that cruel though.

 

[Tildey]

Usually yes, but the flavor of Caito's death implies he was cannibalized, which means we won't get his flip until maybe the person who killed him dies.

I think Badger is someone who could be revived, but it's also not impossible there's a role that needs to die before we see flips. I don't think Void is being that cruel though.

I’m unfamiliar with how the cannibal mechanic works. This would be my first time encountering it. I’ll have to look it up.

 

[Claws]

cwe

 

[Claws]

I’m unfamiliar with how the cannibal mechanic works. This would be my first time encountering it. I’ll have to look it up.

Cannibal is a sk that kills ppl but they never flip

 

[Randolph]

So Randolph isn't a Death Eater.

Clearly you haven't seen me eat at Thanksgiving.

 

[Lora]

Cannibal is a sk that kills ppl but they never flip

not always true. we've had plenty of games that once a cannibal died, the roles were revealed.

 

[Lora]

also, I'm of the mind that we don't have a cannibal and that it is something else that is hiding results of the victims, be it a role or maybe just the nature of the game itself. if you've read the writeups, we've had different characters kill different people and it still shows up as ????? so its unlikely that its cannibal bc it'd have to be multiple and thats more of a SK role vs mafia role + like i said, different characters.

 

[Claws]

not always true. we've had plenty of games that once a cannibal died, the roles were revealed.

Yes but catching them sucks ass

 

[Lora]

Yes but catching them sucks ass

 

[Mazer]

3pups, I'm not at having a go point, as I'm working on something right now. But looks like the 2 possibilities for Badger didn't work out.

Any thoughts that it didn't play out like you thought it should have?

 

[Claws]

3pups, I'm not at having a go point, as I'm working on something right now. But looks like the 2 possibilities for Badger didn't work out.

Any thoughts that it didn't play out like you thought it should have?

Im actually confused on his play its not like 3pup to pull weird shit

 

[Mazer]

Im actually confused on his play its not like 3pup to pull weird shit

I keep thinking that as well.

 

[Mazer]

Badger is certainly a resurrection Candidate.


I would also Blind Ninja should get strong consideration.

 

[Foxxi]

My wonderful students, so many of you slacked in your studies yesterday- I hope you'll be more diligent going forward. Preparing for what will happen is pivotal- and to prepare you must first see!

 

[ForgottenHold]

Caito is dead, and it could be anyone

 

[Tildey]

Cannibal is a sk that kills ppl but they never flip

I don't like the sounds of that. :(

 

[ForgottenHold]

I don't like the sounds of that. :(

yeah it's rude

 

[3puppies]

3pups, I'm not at having a go point, as I'm working on something right now. But looks like the 2 possibilities for Badger didn't work out.

Any thoughts that it didn't play out like you thought it should have?

I think I misinterpreted because I now believe that I was blocked on N1. I didn't get a note that my action failed so I thought it had been successful, and I was excited to post info. Different mods handle things differently.

 

[Matthieu]

I'll be honest, I find games with a lack of reveals to be very difficult on the basis that I tend to be a very reactionary player and deal with stuff as it comes to light. So admittedly I don't have much to say for now that wouldn't just be repeating what others have already observed from the writeup.

 

[Kareemah]

also, I'm of the mind that we don't have a cannibal and that it is something else that is hiding results of the victims, be it a role or maybe just the nature of the game itself. if you've read the writeups, we've had different characters kill different people and it still shows up as ????? so its unlikely that its cannibal bc it'd have to be multiple and thats more of a SK role vs mafia role + like i said, different characters.

Hm I’m not familiar enough with the game to really comment on any of this

 

[Matthieu]

Hm I’m not familiar enough with the game to really comment on any of this

Don't worry, I've been playing these games for...at least five years now, if not longer than that and I still get confused often.

 

[CWE]

cwe

CWE was minding his own business and someone tried to kill me. Don't you stink eye me for that.

 

[CWE]

Ebwop

to ever killed Caito

 

[Mazer]

I think I misinterpreted because I now believe that I was blocked on N1. I didn't get a note that my action failed so I thought it had been successful, and I was excited to post info. Different mods handle things differently.

That's different than what I was thinking

 

[CWE]

Knowing Void, there's probably a few BPVs lol

If I lost a BPV (that I didn't even know I had) to a neutral instead of scum, I'm going to be pissed.

 

[ForgottenHold]

was CWE crippled then?

 

[Mazer]

If I lost a BPV (that I didn't even know I had) to a neutral instead of scum, I'm going to be pissed.

Don't you have a rule about that?

 

[Mazer]

Right now, I think BN was likely town (at least odds are). And it looks Badger has a base chance at least.

 

[CWE]

Don't you have a rule about that?

Yup. The neutral just made this games (s)hit list.

 

[Mazer]

 

[Mazer]

I need to spreadsheet now, but I've got some holes

 

[CWE]

I do wear a mean scarf.

 

[Kareemah]

Well I have no clue what to do now I wish the roles would be revealed

 

[Kareemah]

I do wear a mean scarf.

U don’t lie

 

[Kareemah]

Don't worry, I've been playing these games for...at least five years now, if not longer than that and I still get confused often.

Oh jeez that’sa really long time lol

 

[Kareemah]

Right now, I think BN was likely town (at least odds are). And it looks Badger has a base chance at least.

If I were to pick between the two I would pick ninja bc I’m tired of trying to decipher his messages but they are cute animals say least

 

[Kareemah]

Ebwop

to ever killed Caito

Was he scum?

 

[CWE]

was CWE crippled then?

11 Cars and 2 guns havent been able to stop me. You think 1 statue can?

 

[CWE]

Was he scum?

When isn't he?

 

[Kareemah]

11 Cars and 2 guns havent been able to stop me. You think 1 statue can?

Great, a cripple and a dead man

 

[Kareemah]

It’s so hard to talk without claiming, please please please don’t kill me Void Overlord

 

[CWE]

Great, a cripple and a dead man

You can't kill an immortal.

 

[Listo95]

You can't kill an immortal.

There is always a way to kill an immortal.

 

[CWE]

There is always a way to kill an immortal.

We're they REALLY immortal then?

 

[CWE]

Ebwop

Were not we're you stupid fucking phone.

 

[CWE]

Did Peeves get two actions? Kill attempt on CWE plus taking Diva’s wand?

If anyone had a action that makes someone get double role use, please share with the class who you targetted. I want Peeves hanging by the end of the day.

Please?

 

[Lora]

We're they REALLY immortal then?

immortal =/= undying

 

[Lora]

I need to spreadsheet now, but I've got some holes

we do love some nice holes

 

[CWE]

Vote: Jarrod

Top of my Peeves list as of now.

 

[Dreyski]

FWIW, Potter challenged me to Rock Paper Scissors, but we drew loads of times and then I fell asleep.

 

[CWE]

Git good scrub.

 

[Tildey]

Was he scum?

It doesn’t matter to CWE. He & Caito have a long-standing mafia feud. lol

 

[Dreyski]

Git good scrub.

 

[Dreyski]

Also
Vote: Jarrod1983
His being aggressive this early off the bat is triggering all types of non-town alarms. Plus, if one of us is accused of OMGUS, I’d rather it was him.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Regardless of his alignment, I'm still wary of those who were quick to defend Badger or give him wiggle room. If Badger was town, there would likely be scum knowing he was innocent and trying to look helpful.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

I also still think the way he was reacting to the votes was more in line with scum Badger than town Badger

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Also
Vote: Jarrod1983
His being aggressive this early off the bat is triggering all types of non-town alarms. Plus, if one of us is accused of OMGUS, I’d rather it was him.

I think Jarrod's energy was in the right place and the fact he bothered trying to solve Badger's posts as if he was scum is something I think is more likely to come from town.

This reaction, however...

Vote: Dreyski

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Still no word from morrison, too

 

[Mazer]

Morrison being inactive is not NAI. But absolutely should hear more from him.

I couldn't overread Badger. It was memes. But the self-vote near the end, vs. The beginning or middle was something I've seen from him as scum, and didn't exactly make me feel worse.

 

[Claws]

Maybe cwe is a ghost

 

[Jarrod1983]

Also
Vote: Jarrod1983
His being aggressive this early off the bat is triggering all types of non-town alarms. Plus, if one of us is accused of OMGUS, I’d rather it was him.

So basically you knew I'd be coming for you and you'd like to paint the picture of me doing OMGUS to you.

Have at it.

Vote: Dreyski.

 

[Randolph]

If there isn't much info, I will fall back to my usual tried and true method. Which is to vote on inactive to try to force them to be a little more active.

Vote: morrison

I am not married to this vote though.

 

[Jarrod1983]

Also anyone voting me right now is a dam fool.

I seemed to be Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation.

Also, 100% fact there are 5 red scums out there but this could include traitor characters. I have zero Harry Potter knowledge so not sure if a traitor character has been mentioned in write ups.

Suck it scum.

 

[CWE]

Also anyone voting me right now is a dam fool.

I seemed to be Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation.

Also, 100% fact there are 5 red scums out there but this could include traitor characters. I have zero Harry Potter knowledge so not sure if a traitor character has been mentioned in write ups.

Suck it scum.

Unvote: jarrod
For now.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Also anyone voting me right now is a dam fool.

I seemed to be Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation.

Also, 100% fact there are 5 red scums out there but this could include traitor characters. I have zero Harry Potter knowledge so not sure if a traitor character has been mentioned in write ups.

Suck it scum.

Mad Eye Moody immediately came to mind as a potential traitor

Also Snape

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Unvote: jarrod
For now.

Who else are you curious about, mr. Invincible?

 

[Jarrod1983]

Between Badger's glowing town lean of CWE and CWE coming out firing at me I don't feel great about CWE at all.

 

[Lora]

Mad Eye Moody immediately came to mind as a potential traitor

Also Snape

he wasnt really a traitor tho. just misunderstood. but they absolutely do kinda relate to traitors. + wormtail.

 

[CWE]

Between Badger's glowing town lean of CWE and CWE coming out firing at me I don't feel great about CWE at all.

Pepto-Bismol might help?

 

[CWE]

Who else are you curious about, mr. Invincible?

Vote: future


And I have no idea how I lived. Maybe 1. But it's dumb. Reallly dumb.

 

[3puppies]

It’s so hard to talk without claiming, please please please don’t kill me Void Overlord

If you have information that will help town, you can share it, but you don't have to claim your role to do that. Void is the boss moderator of my internet parade. You can try running by Void what you want to post here, and he'll tell you if it comes too close to roleclaiming. But he won't tell you if you're off base in your interpretation.

As for the rest of last night's actions -


George Weasley seemed to have a commuter role?

Lucius Malfoy's investigating The Homely Man's stuff made me wonder what result came through, especially since it appears Newt Scamander bus drove The Homely Man and Randolph, causing them to scatter in opposite directions. So was Lucious investigating The Homely Man, or Randolph?


Harry Potter and Dreyski's rock paper scissors game only tells us that Dreyski is not HP. But does it clear Dreyski from other roles, other than George Weasley? If Dreyski was preoccupied, does that also mean he couldn't be Peeves?

Not sure about Albus Dumbledore , but I wondered if he had a hider role as he "found The Homely Man and decided to spend time behind him, ?

Lord Voldemort 's spell that would make it so those members of that house were more likely to sleep soundly tonight probably means some folks can't act tonight - I wonder if those players were notified that they will be roleblocked? I wonder if they won't be able to revive one of the dead but not revealed?

Severus Snape's potion about "hidden voices" intrigues me. I am suspecting that he is setting up private chats?

Peter Pettigrew seemed like a bus drive to me as well. Xanjori and me are not Scabbers's alter ego.

Dobby doc protected MTR ?

Hermione Granger has a variation of a cop role?

Hagrid jailed Jarrod.

Argus Filch doc protected yours truly.

Mad-Eye Moody charm on Xanjori’s back that would give Xanjori a bit of a boost this night.

The Marauder’s Map watched Jarrod, so does that mean someone knows who Hagrid is?

Grindelwald taking out Caito by the Imperius and Incendio curse at makes me believe Caito was not purple. I also think red and purple are alternating kill nights.

Peeves having two actions makes me wonder if he had a wish granted, or maybe won a prize solving an anagram puzzle?

 

[Mazer]

Mad Eye Moody immediately came to mind as a potential traitor

Also Snape

I like the moody theory. that would fit.

If there's a role that's the equivalent of Ross from friends, that should be Snape/

 

[Matthieu]

Vote: Dreyski

 

[Mazer]

If you have information that will help town, you can share it, but you don't have to claim your role to do that. Void is the boss moderator of my internet parade. You can try running by Void what you want to post here, and he'll tell you if it comes too close to roleclaiming. But he won't tell you if you're off base in your interpretation.

As for the rest of last night's actions -


George Weasley seemed to have a commuter role?

Lucius Malfoy's investigating The Homely Man's stuff made me wonder what result came through, especially since it appears Newt Scamander bus drove The Homely Man and Randolph, causing them to scatter in opposite directions. So was Lucious investigating The Homely Man, or Randolph?


Harry Potter and Dreyski's rock paper scissors game only tells us that Dreyski is not HP. But does it clear Dreyski from other roles, other than George Weasley? If Dreyski was preoccupied, does that also mean he couldn't be Peeves?

Not sure about Albus Dumbledore , but I wondered if he had a hider role as he "found The Homely Man and decided to spend time behind him, ?

Lord Voldemort 's spell that would make it so those members of that house were more likely to sleep soundly tonight probably means some folks can't act tonight - I wonder if those players were notified that they will be roleblocked? I wonder if they won't be able to revive one of the dead but not revealed?

Severus Snape's potion about "hidden voices" intrigues me. I am suspecting that he is setting up private chats?

Peter Pettigrew seemed like a bus drive to me as well. Xanjori and me are not Scabbers's alter ego.

Dobby doc protected MTR ?

Hermione Granger has a variation of a cop role?

Hagrid jailed Jarrod.

Argus Filch doc protected yours truly.

Mad-Eye Moody charm on Xanjori’s back that would give Xanjori a bit of a boost this night.

The Marauder’s Map watched Jarrod, so does that mean someone knows who Hagrid is?

Grindelwald taking out Caito by the Imperius and Incendio curse at makes me believe Caito was not purple. I also think red and purple are alternating kill nights.

Peeves having two actions makes me wonder if he had a wish granted, or maybe won a prize solving an anagram puzzle?

I believe the puzzle wins are a house bonus.

 

[Mazer]

Between Badger's glowing town lean of CWE and CWE coming out firing at me I don't feel great about CWE at all.

Where do you stand on Badger right now? Lean town that was killed or scum that was killed?

 

[Mazer]

Vote: future


And I have no idea how I lived. Maybe 1. But it's dumb. Reallly dumb.

Intriguing

 

[Mazer]

Between Badger's glowing town lean of CWE and CWE coming out firing at me I don't feel great about CWE at all.

I'm leaning ok with you and CWE right now. I also like Psych ok. which always worries me. lol

 

[Jarrod1983]

If you have information that will help town, you can share it, but you don't have to claim your role to do that. Void is the boss moderator of my internet parade. You can try running by Void what you want to post here, and he'll tell you if it comes too close to roleclaiming. But he won't tell you if you're off base in your interpretation.

As for the rest of last night's actions -


George Weasley seemed to have a commuter role?

Lucius Malfoy's investigating The Homely Man's stuff made me wonder what result came through, especially since it appears Newt Scamander bus drove The Homely Man and Randolph, causing them to scatter in opposite directions. So was Lucious investigating The Homely Man, or Randolph?


Harry Potter and Dreyski's rock paper scissors game only tells us that Dreyski is not HP. But does it clear Dreyski from other roles, other than George Weasley? If Dreyski was preoccupied, does that also mean he couldn't be Peeves?

Not sure about Albus Dumbledore , but I wondered if he had a hider role as he "found The Homely Man and decided to spend time behind him, ?

Lord Voldemort 's spell that would make it so those members of that house were more likely to sleep soundly tonight probably means some folks can't act tonight - I wonder if those players were notified that they will be roleblocked? I wonder if they won't be able to revive one of the dead but not revealed?

Severus Snape's potion about "hidden voices" intrigues me. I am suspecting that he is setting up private chats?

Peter Pettigrew seemed like a bus drive to me as well. Xanjori and me are not Scabbers's alter ego.

Dobby doc protected MTR ?

Hermione Granger has a variation of a cop role?

Hagrid jailed Jarrod.

Argus Filch doc protected yours truly.

Mad-Eye Moody charm on Xanjori’s back that would give Xanjori a bit of a boost this night.

The Marauder’s Map watched Jarrod, so does that mean someone knows who Hagrid is?

Grindelwald taking out Caito by the Imperius and Incendio curse at makes me believe Caito was not purple. I also think red and purple are alternating kill nights.

Peeves having two actions makes me wonder if he had a wish granted, or maybe won a prize solving an anagram puzzle?

100% WAS NOT jailed. I've already informed exactly what all 3 actions on me were last night.

 

[3puppies]

I believe the puzzle wins are a house bonus.

Right, thanks. What do you think about Lucious investigating you - was it directed to you or toward Randolph?

And do you have any thoughts about red and purple alternating kill days?

 

[Jarrod1983]

Where do you stand on Badger right now? Lean town that was killed or scum that was killed?

I thought his posting of gifs was more trolling the thread. At one point he posted the same one like 3 or 4 times in a row I think. Maybe 3pups misinterpreted things but it still seemed like Badger was itching a lot.

 

[Mazer]

Right, thanks. What do you think about Lucious investigating you - was it directed to you or toward Randolph?

And do you have any thoughts about red and purple alternating kill days?

I have some concerns that actions have tomfoolery or not hitting normal order. Normally you would assume it would have been directed at Rando. Based on the write-up order being atypical, I don't think we can make that a 100 assumption though.

 

[Mazer]

And Red and purple alternating kills would be pretty standard in these set-ups. I never assume baseline is every night, but I think it's an appropriate prioritization.

 

[Mazer]

I thought his posting of gifs was more trolling the thread. At one point he posted the same one like 3 or 4 times in a row I think. Maybe 3pups misinterpreted things but it still seemed like Badger was itching a lot.

I can see that. Gun to my head, I think 3pups just got something wrong. I've got a few theories on what that could have been, but nothing I feel great about. Badger being frustated in that scenario is NAI for me. But probability wise, BN is probably the most safe assumption for a kill that hurt us.

 

[Dreyski]

Hermione Granger has a variation of a cop role?

The Marauder’s Map watched Jarrod, so does that mean someone knows who Hagrid is?

If your theory is correct (and why not?) then the map should know the identity of two town characters.

 

[Dreyski]

EBWOP that should have been a reply to 3pups. Playing on a phone is starting to test my patience.

 

[Dreyski]

Also, 100% fact there are 5 red scums out there but this could include traitor characters. I have zero Harry Potter knowledge so not sure if a traitor character has been mentioned in write ups.

Suck it scum.

100%…could include (I mentioned Snape as a potential traitor a while back)

Contradiction much?

 

[3puppies]

100% WAS NOT jailed. I've already informed exactly what all 3 actions on me were last night.

Sorry. The Marauders Map watched you. Hagrid sent the spiders after you, who wrapped you in webs. Hermione Granger cop-aligned you. Your post said you were
"Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation."

So Hagid is a vote thief? Not sure I saw that from the write up. But I guess it means that, unless you are a godfather, Hermione can confirm that you're blue. But does it means that the Marauder's map knows who Hermione Granger is?



As for Badger's action with the GIF post restriction, I didn't feel great, especially with his multiple "Come at me" posts. And I didn't understand how the post restriction went through if there was a mass role block.

 

[Claws]

Sorry. The Marauders Map watched you. Hagrid sent the spiders after you, who wrapped you in webs. Hermione Granger cop-aligned you. Your post said you were
"Mr. Popularity last night phase. I was targeted with a watch action, a vote thief action aaand a alignment cop action. Those are 100% fact and not up for interpretation."

So Hagid is a vote thief? Not sure I saw that from the write up. But I guess it means that, unless you are a godfather, Hermione can confirm that you're blue. But does it means that the Marauder's map knows who Hermione Granger is?



As for Badger's action with the GIF post restriction, I didn't feel great, especially with his multiple "Come at me" posts. And I didn't understand how the post restriction went through if there was a mass role block.

Im not understanding where you read mass rb ?

 

[Claws]

Can you point it out copy paste it idc

 

[llettuce]

Severus Snape's potion about "hidden voices" intrigues me. I am suspecting that he is setting up private chats?

Perhaps snape can see chats

 

[Dreyski]

So Hagid is a vote thief? Not sure I saw that from the write up. But I guess it means that, unless you are a godfather, Hermione can confirm that you're blue. But does it means that the Marauder's map knows who Hermione Granger is?

Check Tildey’s post #901 for more info about Hermoine’s night action. She will know if Jarrod is in the alliance, not whether he’s a Death Eater.

As for Badger's action with the GIF post restriction, I didn't feel great, especially with his multiple "Come at me" posts. And I didn't understand how the post restriction went through if there was a mass role block

As stated earlier, it may have been a block targeted at one faction, or one house. We don’t have the particulars yet.

 

[Claws]

Check Tildey’s post #901 for more info about Hermoine’s night action. She will know if Jarrod is in the alliance, not whether he’s a Death Eater.


As stated earlier, it may have been a block targeted at one faction, or one house. We don’t have the particulars yet.

Im thinking so as i was not blocked so you have me confused