What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mafia 7: Everyone Loves Listo. Except the Devil.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mazer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Reader mode
If we wanted to look at the future train:

future (9)- vk, Jay,gc, val, night, psych

From positioning, GC could go either way depending on how you look at it, but I tend to lean it town. He voted right after Jay did. Sure, it could be a bus attempt, but there was no reason to think Sleep wouldn't inevitably win out.

Val could be a bus with now a 6th vote. I'm not putting it heavily either way right now. Val does Val.

Nightingale and Psycho could also be busses, but Nightingale has made posts yesterday and today that feel like town. She typically sits and focuses on mechanical discussions especially if things are in the air, but I did like the fact she brought up the no cred for me as it was specifically something I was looking for.

Psycho, I can see the thoughts. I don't see scum Psycho throwing that vote out there at the end to bring questions on him. It wouldn't provide cred.

Overall, I don't hate most of the the future train at all. Val would be who I'd pick if we had to choose someone from the train.
 
rock meets hard place said:
What are your non future wagon game thoughts?
Click to expand...
We have a lot more people not here than I'd like.

Still like Dreyski with the way he was posting and asking questions.

No issues with Claws atm, which by Claws law means he's probably scum covered, but I am not currently bothered by anything to pursue it.

Anyone specifically?
 
Oh. I am not yeeting Kryllian. That is a big ol hell no from me. Dude could claim to be scum today and I'd want to look elsehwere.
 
Whelp. Looks like future is either a stump or not actually rez'd. I'm guessing the latter since the ability to stump someone we have seen the alignment of is kinda eh. Especially when choosing scum because no one is going to pay any attention to anything he'd say. If it were a town role stumping a town player sure, but this makes no sense as a stump.

Void, talk to me about Grumpy. You think he could go either way - why? I didn't like him voting CWE, saying he would vote MTR and just not even mentioning future, and his vote on future right after jay doesn't mean much to me since as you yourself have mentioned, there was no reason at that point not to think sleep would eventually get piled on like it usually does so if they are partners it could still be thought a safe gamble. I can kinda see the offer to vote someone else if they reached 7 votes as twtbaw, but it still bothers me - and his reaction today saying that everyone else in that group is clear because the scum was found pings me.
 
I think whatever we're dealing with in regards to Future is probably tied to his role. He flipped as a 'deceiver' so it could very well be the case that there's trickery afoot. He might not even be dead for all we know or he is and we're just being baited into wasting time going after him.

I'm not sure what to make of Void's strong reaction to the idea of Kryllian being someone to look at. It seems a little extreme.
 
Nightingale said:
Void, talk to me about Grumpy. You think he could go either way - why? I didn't like him voting CWE, saying he would vote MTR and just not even mentioning future, and his vote on future right after jay doesn't mean much to me since as you yourself have mentioned, there was no reason at that point not to think sleep would eventually get piled on like it usually does so if they are partners it could still be thought a safe gamble. I can kinda see the offer to vote someone else if they reached 7 votes as twtbaw, but it still bothers me - and his reaction today saying that everyone else in that group is clear because the scum was found pings me.
Click to expand...
The vote on CWE would be the only thing that looks overly suspect to me and even that I want to feel was a random choice. Yeah, I get the concern because I picked Future over CWE. I did it because its more fun to vote Future, but mainly because CWE becomes obvious later on typically. I can see GC possibly not thinking about who to vote for. I can also see it done as a "welp we have a chance to get rid of cwe so lets try it."

Especially if scum were planning on killing him anyway I'm unsure why they'd want to push. Again, likely didn't expect Sleep to actually happen since it almost never does.

And this folks, is why I say D1 should never be a foregone conclusion of sleep or not.
 
Listo is saddened by all the death that occurred in the night. Listo will try to get caught up after work.

Listo was there at Pompeii and helped the survivors get out and restart their lives.

The voice of Listo also forgot Listo’s deed last post.

Listo has kept all those close encounters with meteors away not letting any of them hit Earth.
 
VoidKitten said:
I can see GC possibly not thinking about who to vote for
Click to expand...
No I didn't. It stops being a silly probability theory if you start to influence it by thinking. I didn't care whitch one of MTR-FH-CWE it would be in the end. First one that sticks, turned to be FH.

Maybe I subconsiously picked CWE because voting him was as stupid as whole premise.
 
rock meets hard place said:
I think the big question is if it was a roleblock.
Click to expand...
Well yes, the writeup is intentionally imprecise, but he wasn't killed, nor was he jailed (admittedly I'm only getting that from flavour) and I'm struggling to think of any other roles that would fit. Silencer maybe, but is that usually town?

@Kryllian are you able to confirm how you were acted against last night?

I'm also wondering what Future is doing - hasn't posted since being rezzed, can't be harmed, can be voted against. I wonder if its a weird stumpesque scenario.
The CWE and Badger kills aso strike me as the work of someone who knows them.
 
Imo fh is just a decoy that can be ignored. We know his name and if he is alive he will show in writeup.

Question is if that is his passive as deciever scum superspell or 3rd party.
 
Vote: psycho666

The night summary has their name in red. It also has Listo in Green. Not sure if they are indeed themselves and alignment indicated or if someone got a rolecard with their name...
 
Kryllian said:
Vote: psycho666

The night summary has their name in red. It also has Listo in Green. Not sure if they are indeed themselves and alignment indicated or if someone got a rolecard with their name...
Click to expand...
It’s that last one (I suppose someone could rand themselves).
Did you get any notification about what happened to you n1?
 
grumpy (1) -nighty
vk (2) - jarrod, bn
mtr (1)- vk
robo (1)- rock
psych (2) - val, kryll


Hammer is at 9
 
Last edited:
grumpy (1) -nighty
vk (3) - jarrod, bn, rock
mtr (1)- vk
robo (1)- claws
psych (2) - val, kryl
kryll (1)-matt

Hammer is at 9
 
Dreyski said:
It’s that last one (I suppose someone could rand themselves).
Did you get any notification about what happened to you n1?
Click to expand...
Wouldn't you like to know....I haven't been gone so long that I'm just going to drop information that may be useful to scum without having a reason to share for Town's betterment.
 
Ya no idea maybe a rolecop idk what else it potencially could be with a write up like that maybe just a plain rb idk
 
FML I completely missed this game started, I am very sorry. Off to bed right now but will be back tomorrow and uh, read the entire thread I guess
 
Listo95 said:
Listo is saddened by all the death that occurred in the night. Listo will try to get caught up after work.

Listo was there at Pompeii and helped the survivors get out and restart their lives.

The voice of Listo also forgot Listo’s deed last post.

Listo has kept all those close encounters with meteors away not letting any of them hit Earth.
Click to expand...
I don't remember Listo talking in 3rd person from past games.
 
Matthieu said:
I think whatever we're dealing with in regards to Future is probably tied to his role. He flipped as a 'deceiver' so it could very well be the case that there's trickery afoot. He might not even be dead for all we know or he is and we're just being baited into wasting time going after him.

I'm not sure what to make of Void's strong reaction to the idea of Kryllian being someone to look at. It seems a little extreme.
Click to expand...
It points towards Void/Kryllian as not sharing a common scum chat. Wouldn't the scum have told Kryllian in no uncertain terms not to even utter a word about Future not being truly resurrected? Someone give me a sanity check on this.
 
Who was it who asked why I'm town? Dreyski unless I'm mistaken.
To answer that mention. If Future and I were scum together, it makes zero sense for me to paint a target on their back when I pointed out the tell on MTR train reaching 3 votes having 1 scum.
 
Dreyski said:
@CRichardFoL
@Kryllian
@rock meets hard place

Nice to meet you (I don't believe we've met). Why should I not vote to yeet you?
Click to expand...
I answered this earlier with the quoted post below.
CRichardFoL said:
Who was it who asked why I'm town? Dreyski unless I'm mistaken.
To answer that mention. If Future and I were scum together, it makes zero sense for me to paint a target on their back when I pointed out the tell on MTR train reaching 3 votes having 1 scum.
Click to expand...
 
the only thing i think void has going for him is the fact hes randed scum like 4? games in a row (that he has played) do i really think hes randed again i doubt it but then again hes a bastard so who knows
 
llettuce said:
Idk future is always voting his dad; nai imo
Click to expand...
I don't see myself voting MTR, mainly because the tell I used D1 makes me think they're just town. Sure Future could vote their dad no matter their alignments, yet the odds are it's 1 scum in MTR, Future, CWE and Grumpycat.
 
CRichardFoL said:
I don't see myself voting MTR, mainly because the tell I used D1 makes me think they're just town. Sure Future could vote their dad no matter their alignments, yet the odds are it's 1 scum in MTR, Future, CWE and Grumpycat.
Click to expand...
I don't see myself voting MTR, mainly because the tell I used D1 makes me think they're just town. Sure Future could vote their dad no matter their alignments, yet the odds are it's 1 scum in MTR, Future, CWE and Grumpycat.
I added in CWE's flip.
 
Don't have much from the writeup. Seems like most of our info died with Badger, though I do think Kryllian was probably roleblocked which would knock a decent number of scum roles off of him.

I thought maybe Blind was vanilla'd but from what he says not the case. I also think him openly saying he's not clear is probably a good look. Enough for me to not worry about him.

I also can't help but wonder if scum bus drove Xan to try and take him out of the firing range of an inactivity vig, but you could argue they were just trying to get a free kill on Listo. Will see how Xan develops once he starts posting.

I'm on the side if ignoring Future for now because the hammer requirement and the attempted day kill seem to point to his resurrection being a red herring. If he's still in the playerlist after the phase ends, let's try and roleblock him and decide from there.
 
Listo has caught up but doesn't have much to add sadly.

Listo one time found a wounded fox and nursed it back to health intending to return it to the wild. Once doing so the fox eventually returned with a ton of baby foxes and Listo was an adoring fan.
 
Not really sure I like Grumpy's posts today. I think arguing that scum wouldn't bus last phase could potentially be absolving himself of blame as well as trying to move attention away from other partners hiding on the wagon. The "waiting for a wagon to reach 3," thing feels a bit like using Abbi's law as a crutch (and incorrectly because it only counts for the first wagon of the game). And Nightingale has made a good point about him voting Future while having spent most of his time talking about/pushing other options. It's also notable he was pushing for a sleep vote over hammering Future. The one thing that makes me hesitant is I feel I tend to scumread Grumpy a lot so maybe I'm confbiasing myself.

Claws is getting better so far, but not sure I'm sold on flipping that read yet. I kind of like the push on Robo because it feels independent and develops from the Void push, which I think Claws would be more fixated on if he was putting on a front. But if Robo is town, it's kind of an easy read to fall back on.

Nightingale seems towny so far. I like that she dove right into assessing the Future wagon and was constantly questioning the majority requirement when future was rezzed. If it is a red herring, seems like scum would try to push the idea that it's real or feign confusion rather than actively working to put doubt on the plot. I guess if the rez is real maybe it's scum trying to keep him alive longer. We'll have to see, but overall feels fine.
 
Mtr(1) - crich
Xan (2)- Kryll, cwe
listo(1) - robo
psych (1)- badger
matt (1) -dreyski
vk (2) -bn, claws
rock (1)-llettuce
badger(1)- jarrod
future (8)- vk, Jay,gc, val, night,
Grumpy (1)- psych,
jarrod (1) - rock
kryll (1)- Listo
sleep (3) - mtr, future, matt
 
For what it's worth, I'm not keen on pushing MTR either. I think the bit of headbutting with Future is enough to give him some space. I also felt the early pile on is more indicative of him being town with at least one scum flipping on that wagon.
 
FutureHold said:
Sigh if you want to hammer why couldn’t we have hammered the inactives? This is a terrible mistake and Ray really wasted a good ability on me
Click to expand...

LemonDemonGirl said:
True
Unvote:
Click to expand...
This is kind of a weird interaction if partnered. Like it's sort of a non-sequitur, but knowing LDG like I do, this reads a bit more like she felt some kind of pressure to move her vote, and I don't think she'd feel that in reaction to a non-related post from her partner.
 
I'm cautiously reserving judgment on Void. I like the way he was solving the Future wagon, but last time I thought he was playing hella towny, he was scum, so I'm not shielding him any time soon.
 
Jarrod's solving on Void feels genuine too. CRichard also still seems fine.

I don't really have strong feelings on anyone else yet.

Grumpy
Claws
Robo
Xan

I think these are the slots I feel most comfortable voting right now
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Mazer
Christmas Mafia 4 (Mafia 30): The House of MTR 2-God Loves, MTR kills
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
909
Views
10K
Insaner
Insaner
Mazer
Mafia 7: Everyone Loves Listo. Except the Devil
Replies
83
Views
2K
Claws
Claws
VoidKitten
Mafia 31 - Town of the Heart
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
547
Views
4K
Listo95
Listo95
Mazer
Mafia 10: The LemonDemonGirl saves Christmas from Jennifer Lawrence and the Robot Devil
13 14 15 16 17
Replies
2K
Views
24K
Dreyski
Dreyski
Mazer
Christmas Mafia 4 (Mafia 30): The House of MTR 2-God Loves, MTR kills
2
Replies
109
Views
1K
Mazer
Mazer
Back
Top Bottom