What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

Reader mode
Badger said:
Quick reads on a few:

CWE - (before he says it not because he reads me as such) the most obvious town read here unless he’s deviated heavily on his scum game. Would be 1-2-3 kid beating Razor level upset if he was scum.
Blind - By the book, Mr logical. Confident town read even in spite of our earlier interactions.
Psycho - Less confident than the previous two but leaning slight town. No gimmicky obv town tells like the previous games and dipping in and out in spells.
Homely Mazer - Slightly interesting approach as normally his first port of call is to blatantly ask me and/or Claws if town in the first instance but did the more gimmicky approach instead. Town lean but a bit more slight than usual
Claws - His play here pings me slightly as reminds me of other games like the last one where he’s shaded the likes of me but was a scum approach.
Dreyski - Slight town lean and giving him a bit of a pass due to his PC issues.
3puppies - His spreadsheeting NAI. Seems a bit too paranoid over leading N1 No lynches over a Jarrod/Kefka gimmick that was aaaages ago.
Jarrod - He’s a slow burner normally D1, need to see more D2.
Randolph - Not much but hope he can digest the clippings/hairs in good sauce. Normally questions me or Psycho but none of his usual MO here.
Tildey - Slight town lead. Could see more but asking role questions.
Matthieu - Less familiar with his style than others but from what I know voting Sleep early is NAI.
Lora- Seems a bit more serious and less gimmicky than usual. Most players I’d say that’s fine but I’m used to a town gimmicky Lora.
MTR - His activity level so far is a slight good town lean at the moment
Caito - Not confident at all.
Xan - same.
Click to expand...
Can you go a bit more into the Claws read? Is there anything particularly about his play that you think smells of previous games?

That's actually a good shout on Randolph, though.
 
Well, you are all making amazing progress! So many students with signs of the gift - of course I knew you would all excel. Well, most of you anyway. Some of these are certainly.... interesting... fortunes you see. I'm quite certain no one will be replacing he who shall not be named's wand with a string of spaghetti, as amusing as that would be to see!
 
MTR said:
:squint: Don't make me change my vote....
Click to expand...

Don't mean to put you in the "dog house of MTR"

Should it be "House of Tildey & MTR" then, or "house of MTR & Tildey"

Teamwork makes the dream work

Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
 
3puppies said:
Don't mean to put you in the "dog house of MTR"

Should it be "House of Tildey & MTR" then, or "house of MTR & Tildey"

Teamwork makes the dream work

Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
Click to expand...
Last game it was the House that Future built
 
3puppies said:
Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
Click to expand...
to get to the bottom part... 25 ppl with 1/3 scum, 2/3 town would make it 8/16/1

1 for peeves, not counting Nightingale since she is the 26th.

so either a 16/4/4/1 if even teams (5/3 split for scum at worst)

potentially a 14/5/5/1 or 14/6/4/1
 
3puppies said:
Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
Click to expand...

I think scum teams of 3-4 is pretty typical. With there appearing to be two scum teams I can't imagine there being more than 4 each. So maybe two more, at most?
 
3puppies said:
Don't mean to put you in the "dog house of MTR"

Should it be "House of Tildey & MTR" then, or "house of MTR & Tildey"

Teamwork makes the dream work

Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
Click to expand...
it's the House of FutureHold
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

5 - Caito (CWE #14, Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242)
5 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - Blind Ninja (Lora #52)
1 - MTR (Future #63)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Claws (Xanjori #206)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Satsu, Morrison, Listo, Lettuce, Blind Ninja #59

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
Blind Ninja said:
Do we think Lora had the cloak as an ability, or do we think VK did it to ensure Lora had a chance to play the game. Lora died N1 last game and I dont think he's done any Rajah games.
Click to expand...
i would guess it would be an action. Seems a bit extreme, as I haven't seen it when others went on a streak.
 
Look I love that early item. I'd love to have it in my ship. It's a lot of fun when someone knows their town tell, but breaks it out early on day 1. But I've got a business to run, and if I buy it early, I'd be taking a huge risk here.
 
The Homely Man said:
Look I love that early item. I'd love to have it in my ship. It's a lot of fun when someone knows their town tell, but breaks it out early on day 1. But I've got a business to run, and if I buy it early, I'd be taking a huge risk here.
Click to expand...

Hello day 1 no lynch crew ring leader.

We meet again.

:shakefist:
 
EBWOP Void
Claws said:
@Badger im gunna assume that your hufflepuff since thier mascot is a badger if not its a damn shame
Click to expand...
PsychoSoldier said:
Can you go a bit more into the Claws read? Is there anything particularly about his play that you think smells of previous games?

That's actually a good shout on Randolph, though.
Click to expand...
This is early and could change but he seems more intent on mocking/tripping people up rather than trying to read the game. Seems a bit Skeletorish when he was cult last game. He could yet prove me wrong.
 
I mean I guess I can get voting sleep cos being D1'd sucks dick, I just dislike it and wont do it until later in the day if needed.

Vote: Psycho

He went and made emotes to distract us from focusing on his scummy game play. :sideeye:
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

5 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291)
5 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, CWE #320)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - Blind Ninja (Lora #52)
1 - MTR (Future #63)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Satsu, Morrison, Listo, Lettuce, Blind Ninja #59

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.

About 11.5 hours left in the day phase.
 
Vote: caito

sleep d1 is for cringe losers who dont want to advance the game state. everyone voting sleep is an extremely sussy baka.
 
Is it paranoid of me to suspect Peeves, the poltergeist, may have an action that only targets players who vote sleep, or perhaps those who don't vote?
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

6 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, CWE #320, Lora #327)
5 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - Blind Ninja (Lora #52)
1 - MTR (Future #63)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Satsu, Morrison, Listo, Lettuce, Blind Ninja #59

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
3puppies said:
Is it paranoid of me to suspect Peeves, the poltergeist, may have an action that only targets players who vote sleep, or perhaps those who don't vote?
Click to expand...

Could be that. Could be neutral. Could be regarding posts.

Look, I can't go full-blown paranoia. Best I can do is mild discomfort.
 
3puppies said:
Is it paranoid of me to suspect Peeves, the poltergeist, may have an action that only targets players who vote sleep, or perhaps those who don't vote?
Click to expand...
I dont think its paranoia actually, I was looking at the fact that the vote count does include "Players not voting" and it made me suspect there may be a mechanic related to it.
 
So hilarious ironic storie time i recently finished bram stokers dragula book yesterday and i shit you not at 2am last night i had a god damn small brown bat flying around my room last night and had to catch him and release him outside
 
*gasps* Oh no.. no no... this is terrible. I see... I see..the grim! These are ill tidings - ill tidings indeed! There is a shadow cast upon us...
 
Claws said:
So hilarious ironic storie time i recently finished bram stokers dragula book yesterday and i shit you not at 2am last night i had a god damn small brown bat flying around my room last night and had to catch him and release him outside
Click to expand...
how is that ironic?
 
Xanjori said:
I dont think its paranoia actually, I was looking at the fact that the vote count does include "Players not voting" and it made me suspect there may be a mechanic related to it.
Click to expand...
are you being obtuse or have you forgotten the vast majority of our games that have always had those not voting in the vote counts. granted, its usually the mods discretion whether or not to keep track of that shit.
 
Claws said:
I dont english
Click to expand...
Surprised Meme GIF
 
Listo is the most difficult MMO-C player for me to read. If I told you now how I read him then is probally the opposite.
PsychoSoldier said:
Any thoughts on Listo while we're here?
Click to expand...
Listo is the most difficult MMO-C player for me to read. If I told you now how I read him then is probally the opposite.
 
Perhaps the posts are counted for points
Claws said:
So hilarious ironic storie time i recently finished bram stokers dragula book yesterday and i shit you not at 2am last night i had a god damn small brown bat flying around my room last night and had to catch him and release him outside
Click to expand...
bats are good to have in the neighborhood, but no fun to have in your home. They have nested in my attic louvres, right against the screens, as they devoured the wasps that tried to nest there. When I ultimately had to rebuild the louvres, it was a frightening experience trying to get them away.

On the plus side, they are a pretty clear sign that the air in your neighborhood is very clean, as bats don't tolerate a poor environment. Having to deal with that at 2:00 AM must have really sucked. How did you catch it?
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

6 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291, Listo #354)
6 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, CWE #320, Lora #327)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - MTR (Future #63)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Morrison, Lettuce, Blind Ninja #59

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
Last edited:
We have several people that are nowhere near the 10 recommended posts of the OP.

Lettuce - 0
Jarrod - 1
PG - 2
Val - 3
Morrison - 4
Caito, Diva, Randolph - 6
Listo - 8
Drey, Future, Kareem - 9

Doubt there will be heavy modkills, but the activity recommendation might in place because someone can do things to lurkers? Maybe Peeves deals with inactivity instead of non-voters?

But with that said

Vote: Jarrod
Come out and play

@llettuce @Jarrod1983 @Peter Griffin @Val the Moofia Boss @morrison @Caito @DivaSmurf @Randolph Game has been going over 48 hours and you lot have participated the least in the game. Care to weigh in?
 
Sure. It’s D1. We all know my thoughts on D1 and the absolute bullshit it is, as well as you don’t actually get anywhere near the info some people swear they do.


Wake me up when we are past it and you’ll get more outta me
 
Caito said:
Sure. It’s D1. We all know my thoughts on D1 and the absolute bullshit it is, as well as you don’t actually get anywhere near the info some people swear they do.


Wake me up when we are past it and you’ll get more outta me
Click to expand...
So you dont feel like engaging in discussions and want to coast past d1.

Only time info comes from d1 is when people interact.

Unvote:
Vote: Caito
 
So many shy students... it can be scary, yes - having the gift makes other people... uncomfortable- I know! But even I have learned you cannot hide away from others *all* the time.... I fear for the fates of my quiet little seers-to-be.
 
Blind Ninja said:
We have several people that are nowhere near the 10 recommended posts of the OP.

Lettuce - 0
Jarrod - 1
PG - 2
Val - 3
Morrison - 4
Caito, Diva, Randolph - 6
Listo - 8
Drey, Future, Kareem - 9

Doubt there will be heavy modkills, but the activity recommendation might in place because someone can do things to lurkers? Maybe Peeves deals with inactivity instead of non-voters?

But with that said

Vote: Jarrod
Come out and play

@llettuce @Jarrod1983 @Peter Griffin @Val the Moofia Boss @morrison @Caito @DivaSmurf @Randolph Game has been going over 48 hours and you lot have participated the least in the game. Care to weigh in?
Click to expand...
There we go, 10 posts
 
Satsu said:
Listo is the most difficult MMO-C player for me to read. If I told you now how I read him then is probally the opposite.

Listo is the most difficult MMO-C player for me to read. If I told you now how I read him then is probally the opposite.
Click to expand...
oh yeah?
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

7 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, CWE #320, Lora #327, Blind Ninja #374)
6 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291, Listo #354)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - MTR (Future #63)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Morrison, Lettuce

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
Caito said:
Want me to kill him?
Click to expand...
Is this a suggestion that instead of getting yeated, you have an ability to mis-direct a kill attempt directed your way? Or are you just amusing yourself on the way out?


I share your thoughts on D1 info. I am not ready to change my vote to sleep because it might not matter, but I would consider it if you could convince me
 
Just amusing myself.


Let’s be honest, I’m out in this game early no matter what. Both Tildey and CWE have an axe to grind, plus whatever else y’all thought of me after my glorious ending in my last outing. So by all means, kill me.


Just a shame you won’t let me get a phase or two of work done to make your lives easier. But that won’t be my problem.
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

8 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, CWE #320, Lora #327, Blind Ninja #374, Future #389)
6 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291, Listo #354)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Morrison, Lettuce

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
Unvote: caito
:squint:

Your right (Vote) Caito. Shooting you is more fun. Plus that train is dirty.

I get my reason (he's breathing), what's everyone else's? And don't just say to lynch someone day 1.
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

7 - Caito (Tildey #80, Val #90, Kareemah #239, Satsu #242, Lora #327, Blind Ninja #374, Future #389)
6 - Sleep (Matthieu #37, Caito #43, Randolph #82, Badger #280, Jarrod #291, Listo #354)
2 - Badger (Peter Griffin #9, Claws #45)
2 - Future (MTR #10, DivaSmurf #134)
1 - Xanjori (Dreyski #78)
1 - Val (3puppies #113
1 - Listo (Psycho #177)
1 - Psycho (Xanjori #325)

Not Voting: The Homely Man, Morrison, Lettuce, CWE #393

With 25 players alive, majority is 13 votes on a single player.
 
3puppies said:
Perhaps the posts are counted for points

bats are good to have in the neighborhood, but no fun to have in your home. They have nested in my attic louvres, right against the screens, as they devoured the wasps that tried to nest there. When I ultimately had to rebuild the louvres, it was a frightening experience trying to get them away.

On the plus side, they are a pretty clear sign that the air in your neighborhood is very clean, as bats don't tolerate a poor environment. Having to deal with that at 2:00 AM must have really sucked. How did you catch it?
Click to expand...
I threw a blanket up at it mid flight it and then carefully picked it up with gloves gently it wasnt hurt flew away outside as soon as i let go
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

VoidKitten
Mafia 31 - Town of the Heart
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
547
Views
4K
Listo95
Listo95
Foxxi
Mafia 29: The Killing Itch
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
652
Views
4K
3puppies
3
VoidKitten
Mafia 27 - Town of the Undead
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
807
Views
10K
Val the Moofia Boss
Val the Moofia Boss
VoidKitten
Mafia 23 - The Town of Rings
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
1K
Views
9K
Val the Moofia Boss
Val the Moofia Boss
Foxxi
Mafia 26 - The Monster Mash
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
583
Views
4K
Tildey
Tildey
Back
Top Bottom