Val the Moofia Boss
Scum Hunter
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2023
- Messages
- 594
I thought that was his implication that scum did itBefore I do though, no clue how you read that Matthieu post at SoD as an attempt for a derp clear, he said nothing about assuming who did it only that he didn't the odds of two selected players both being scum
Oh noI mean they are multiplying so thats more like a cult.
Yeah it sounds like it could be a consequence of Claws deathYou mean mechanically? Claws was mentioning a lawyer and it it also in a writeup so maybe.
Otherwise i dont know why it would specifically be cwe. Because he didnt swap when jarrod asked him to?
I don’t think it’s a mass block or action failure as I got a note saying my action was successful. However my vote has been stolen by someone.Interesting result from last night...
The CWE death shows before Night actions.
Appears purple had some fun. Was that targeted at specific people? or just hit people that acted last night? Feels on Mass Block, Bus, % Failure on actions?
A likely storyI don’t think it’s a mass block or action failure as I got a note saying my action was successful. However my vote has been stolen by someone.
EBWOP kraken.Ahh the cracked awakes! Did we disturb ye Father?
GrumpyCat teasing a reveal earlier but seems to be dancing a bit around it whenever asked to share it seems a bit odd.
I cracked a long time agoAhh the cracked awakes! Did we disturb ye Father?
That's wonderful to know!
I was curious who wants this game solved for them by results. Didnt plan to out it anyway.
But since poor toadie was curious too i will tell you.
As a result I know whitch player is almost certainly not scum. I have no reason to out my town lean just like that. Escpecially with that will system it will be outed even if i die.
Oh and just in case n2 thing wont be alignment indicative so pay no attention.
Just thought about this part. Now it becomes more likely as claws would be fine with VK kill so it could pass with two.I'm not suggesting that MTR went "Dudes, I think VK is onto me, we need to kill him!" though. It was more of "Well, here are a couple of good options for our kill. But one of them is kinda sus of one of our guys whereas the others don't seem to have caught on yet. So let's kill the dude that's more right than others".
I like it this poe except tildey.So my poe is BN, Tildey, Future, Matthew
I'm not terribly in the mood to "start" anything to be honest. I've outlined my thoughts as to which group of players should be the main subject of scrutiny for the next couple of days. Beyond that I'm just looking to hear what everyone else has to say.I like it this poe except tildey.
Anyone you would like to start with?
What is this in response to?Calm down it doesnt have to be matthieu
Well, we now know that Foxxi was right about Claws and didn't for so I'm not sure how much I still believe this myself tbhJust thought about this part. Now it becomes more likely as claws would be fine with VK kill so it could pass with two.
Didn't die*Well, we now know that Foxxi was right about Claws and didn't for so I'm not sure how much I still believe this myself tbh
Of course, it could just be the case of both VK and Foxxi being right in their respective susses and scum being limited to picking one. But could also be somewhat of a wifom kill.
Matthieu and Val are good friends that will avoid voting each other as much as possible. I thought it was a preemptive - not matthieu ;>What is this in response to?
Didnt see anything scummy from her and I voted her almost entire last game until she got yeeted. My kind heart doesnt want it now (even if she was scum then).Why don't you like Tildey being in the Poe?
I kind of am.I'm not terribly in the mood to "start" anything to be honest
I pretty much outlined it in the post you are quoting.Didnt see anything scummy from her and I voted her almost entire last game until she got yeeted. My kind heart doesnt want it now (even if she was scum then).
What is the case here? thet she voted Dreyski and not Claws? my thought was that she was more comfortable with taht vote because she knows Dreyski longer than claws? not sure about that though.
Let's just get some wagons going then and see what comes of itI kind of am.
ut I dont want to be a lone vote on someone like d1 so i am looking for a compromise.
True, but I think you have redeeming points and I will argue I do too.But we both did as well didnt we?
I only played 1 game with tildey together and i dont think she is much of a busser so fine argument.
I see no need for us to come to a consensus this early in the day. Just vote whoever you want. Then everyone can pick between the options.Come on dude. You pick 4 names I leave 3 out of them. You pick one from that and vote it. I sheep vote. Such a great deal.
And you pick tildey. hiss ;p
Part of why I voted Tildey was because I sensed you wanted to vote differently.I see no need for us to come to a consensus this early in the day. Just vote whoever you want. Then everyone can pick between the options.
I am an awfull pusher and others dont join my trains. you could look at my previous games or even this one when i voted ldg d1 and got no interest even when one could argue it was as reasonable vote as sleeping. Make me feel stupid and even if i might not be i dont want to feel that way ;pI see no need for us to come to a consensus this early in the day. Just vote whoever you want. Then everyone can pick between the options.
My vote has been stolen as well. Hopefully scum doesn't have a stock pile of stolen votes to use this phase.I don’t think it’s a mass block or action failure as I got a note saying my action was successful. However my vote has been stolen by someone.
Oh boy.I am an awfull pusher and others dont join my trains. you could look at my previous games or even this one when i voted ldg d1 and got no interest even when one could argue it was as reasonable vote as sleeping. Make me feel stupid and even if i might not be i dont want to feel that way ;p
Dont take me wrong i am not complaing really. I am not a bad at mafia. Just my winrate is bad. But that is because when i roll town my teammates tend to be dump f.. Ok exhaleOh boy.
I am not sure why you would think that.or that Claws was town on D2
I don't know about that lol I tend to expect wolves in hard positions to just roll over and die but maybe that's just meI am not sure why you would think that.
General rule in an ordinary mafia game is that in order to win town need to find scum and yeet them.
Scum dont have to do anything other than not get yeeted. Almost evertything Claws did was an AtE beg to not get yeeted. Every post he made was making him scummier.
I played enough games with Claws to know that he will cling onto life with claws and that isnt exattly alignment indicative for him so I could give him a pass on that.
But that should generally ping experienced players as scummy.
If the votes that are stolen aren't connected to the person who stole them then yes.Could scum ever stockpile votes? Otherwise those with double votes should be scum.
EBWOPIf the votes that are stolen aren't connected to the person who stole them then yes.
Not fun at all but being fooled is part of the game so can't really blame Claws.Ok Jarrod, being fooled by claws and having your vote stolen isnt fun right? I could lend you my vote if it is on BN FH Matthieu. Intersted in one of them. i mean like they are scum you feel it.
Well this is interesting, not the usual LDG style vote where she either picks someone for sussing him. I’ve barely mentioned her all game.Vote: Badger
What were you doing last night?
Just glancing as reading between breaks but think this may be the purple effect? I’ll have a deeper look when I finish work. I know you weren’t happy with my content last phase, I think Jarrod was kinda right in that it felt like an extension of D1 and didn’t have much more to add other than agree with you (and well done btw for pushing it) but now we have reveals and flips, there’s stuff to pick at.Multiple people talking about losing their votes is interesting considering when I read the write up more closely it sounds like a lightning rod effect may have taken place...
Well... did you do anything sus?Well this is interesting, not the usual LDG style vote where she either picks someone for sussing him. I’ve barely mentioned her all game.
I obviously can’t go into specifics as don’t want to be modkilled/out myself but I did carry a successful action which I can confirm and had good intentions. What makes you think I’ve done something bad?
You will get my thoughts and list.. sometime today. I don't wanna drop it immediately... I want to see what people genuinely think without my own opinions to parrot at me.Seems odd for you to consider shit like that. See you tommorow unless you want to make something happen instead of waiting till someone tells you who scum is.
where do you stand? Who are your suspects?Just glancing as reading between breaks but think this may be the purple effect? I’ll have a deeper look when I finish work. I know you weren’t happy with my content last phase, I think Jarrod was kinda right in that it felt like an extension of D1 and didn’t have much more to add other than agree with you (and well done btw for pushing it) but now we have reveals and flips, there’s stuff to pick at.
Next you’re gonna say I’m too defensiveNot fun at all but being fooled is part of the game so can't really blame Claws.
If I had a vote I'd already have put it on FutureHold to be honest. His play feels like previous scum games he's played, just trying to blend in and be active like his comment on Drey yesterday.
I’ll get something together in a few hours when I finish.where do you stand? Who are your suspects?
No.Well... did you do anything sus?
You were gone for most of the last phase, was there a reason you didn't chime in?Vote: Badger
I already gave my thoughts on Future.@MTR
@Mazer
@Val the Moofia Boss
@Matthieu
@Jarrod1983
@Tildey
@Peter Griffin
@Dreyski
@Blind Ninja
@FutureHold
I've removed the people who have already given some reads and thoughts or - and badger, whi just promised to in a bit... for the rest of you: I would like your thoughts on who you think is suspicious and why please.
But then you know that and say it, do it's all a circle.Do you think im going that hard to defend my teammate? Im not that dense. I know when the flip occurs, puts the spotlight on me. I dont want that heat as scum.
I late vote in almost all games these days, aside from D1 matt vote for tradition
I don't know that you were wrong about Insaner being a potential TMI yesterday. I also think Jarrod was more confident in claws than I think he would normally be.I don't even know where to begin with this...
Okay. So. If claws told his team to bus him why would they jump on the drey wagon? If you're discarding that world and deciding the drey wagon is clean that means that any voting scum actually are bussing claws...? And you think the drey wagon is clean but then have both BN and Tildey who were voting drey in your poe?
And maybe it's just me, but your paragraph about BN sounds extremely bitter...
How confident are you in that group of 3?I am an awfull pusher and others dont join my trains. you could look at my previous games or even this one when i voted ldg d1 and got no interest even when one could argue it was as reasonable vote as sleeping. Make me feel stupid and even if i might not be i dont want to feel that way ;p
Ok then you do you.
Hey Nightingale would you want to vote someone out of BN FH Matthieu? I have reason to think there is scum there. Not mechanical stuff.
And it's possible that there were compound effects out there. Like maybe they targeted someone who would be ok in that scenarioLighting rod could also be why there was no kill - pulled both the kill and whatever protections we may have onto the same target probably
That doesn't make sense. How could I have been hiding? It was 4-4 when I voted Claws so tipped the balance in his favour because I thought he was scum. If I was scum I wouldn't do that.I already gave my thoughts on Future.
I feel great about you and Mazer.
Drey is likely clean but not 100% clearing him.
Badger could have been scum hiding on Claws train for future street cred.
Tildey I feel like could be scum and was curious if she could help Claws stay in that late hour of D2.
Everyone else I'm watching with curiosity at this point.
You asked a question, I answered honestly and you still voted me? Any more reason as to why?Alright.
Vote: Badger
So two stolen votes this phase. Did someone else have their vote stolen last phase when I had mine stolen?My vote has been stolen as well. Hopefully scum doesn't have a stock pile of stolen votes to use this phase.
Me.So two stolen votes this phase. Did someone else have their vote stolen last phase when I had mine stolen?
So you had vote stolen twice?
Not a bad point.That doesn't make sense. How could I have been hiding? It was 4-4 when I voted Claws so tipped the balance in his favour because I thought he was scum. If I was scum I wouldn't do that.
I'm not saying there wasn't scum on that train but why would I put my team-mate in danger like that. If anything there could have been more hiding by not voting or voting Dreyski.
You voted last phase XD
Misread what you said. Just once.So you had vote stolen twice?
Okay cool. Just trying to wrap my head around some of the known information.Misread what you said. Just once.
....or did he?You voted last phase XD
Also, love to get your thoughts on those folks.Misread what you said. Just once.
That's the Badger itch. I need to get on there so I look good one way or another and with Foxxi pushing so hard I wouldn't put it past you.That doesn't make sense. How could I have been hiding? It was 4-4 when I voted Claws so tipped the balance in his favour because I thought he was scum. If I was scum I wouldn't do that.
I'm not saying there wasn't scum on that train but why would I put my team-mate in danger like that. If anything there could have been more hiding by not voting or voting Dreyski.
I already put my thoughts out on everybody, no matter how right, wrong or indifferent they are.Also, love to get your thoughts on those folks.
Also would love to hear from Jarrod there. And anyone else.
My love and invitations extend to all.