What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Day 3 Timer

5 Players Alive / 8 Player Dead
Day 3 has come to an end.

Mafia 8: The Palate Cleanser

  • Thread starter Thread starter Foxxi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Reader mode
Blind Ninja said:
Not really sure where to go myself. We are in a good spot and can likely vote sleep to give better numbers going into tomorrow.
Click to expand...
How is less town better numbers? I was thinking about voting VK first because Val could have a result on you that might be different from what he had on VK.
 
Satsu said:
How is less town better numbers? I was thinking about voting VK first because Val could have a result on you that might be different from what he had on VK.
Click to expand...
Losing 1 at night is better then a mislynch, then sk kill.

we have 7 people alive, and need to find 1. I feel like this is a safe place to vote sleep.
 
No it isn't. Better to yeet. There are 3 chances now and there would be 2 is this ends in sleep.

Sorry BN I can find a reason on everyone else they might not be an SK. but can't find one on you.

Vote: Blind Ninja
 
Yeah, I am not doing this vote unless there is no other option and the only options left are bastardization.

I'd prefer Matthieu as it eliminates the last two PoE of mine, but I'd vote Sleep over BN.
 
Satsu said:
No it isn't. Better to yeet. There are 3 chances now and there would be 2 is this ends in sleep.

Sorry BN I can find a reason on everyone else they might not be an SK. but can't find one on you.

Vote: Blind Ninja
Click to expand...
So you want me gone... which will hurt towns numbers... ( 6v1 down to 5v1) then if another kill goes off tonight, further hurting towns numbers... (5v1 to 4v1)
 
These are very precise numbers. I gave each of your posts a full analysis and weighted scum score, and then compared averages
 
VoidKitten said:
Yeah, I am not doing this vote unless there is no other option and the only options left are bastardization.

I'd prefer Matthieu as it eliminates the last two PoE of mine, but I'd vote Sleep over BN.
Click to expand...
Give someone who will the read the thread an answer to pass to Val before night.

@CWE. Tell Val our biggest sports debate
 
Most o da dead want VK/BN looked at. Da drunk one (who not even be drunk when called upon) said we cruising with the baddies slain.
 
Day has ended. There has been no yeet.

**Sleep( 4 )**- Matthieu(2102), Mazer(2112), Void(2118), BN(2125)
**BN ( 2 )**- Satsu(2106), Listo(2117)

Not Voting: MTR,
**current as of post:** 2125

It is now night 6. Night 6 deadline Wednesday 10/18 @9pm EST. Please submit any night actions you may have in your discord channels.
 
I have so many questions about Matthieu. Why was he killed? Why can he come up with amazing stories but had to ask the most indirect questions ever.
 
Madame Listo not even care anymore. Da spirit of Val checked me da night dey died but never got a result. Val believe BN/VK be a SK duo. Da spirit not give what Mazer wanted but instead gave stuff dat Matthieu be able to confirm.
 
VoidKitten said:
I have so many questions about Matthieu. Why was he killed? Why can he come up with amazing stories but had to ask the most indirect questions ever.
Click to expand...
Strange kill. He was in poe. What kind of question could he ask that would make him more a threat than mtr and mazer confirmed town that cant do anything really.
 
Listo95 said:
Madame Listo not even care anymore. Da spirit of Val checked me da night dey died but never got a result. Val believe BN/VK be a SK duo. Da spirit not give what Mazer wanted but instead gave stuff dat Matthieu be able to confirm.
Click to expand...
I am waiting to hear what MTR says before I jump down your throat.
 
Satsu said:
Strange kill. He was in poe. What kind of question could he ask that would make him more a threat than mtr and mazer confirmed town that cant do anything really.
Click to expand...
Especially with the questions he was asking. They weren't anything that couldn't be inferred.
 
Mazer said:
That's the way the cookie crumbles
Click to expand...
You don't understand. The cookie saga took off.

I asked what kind of cookie and was told it was unidentifiable. I then, obviously knowing our mod, cast the Level 1 spell Identify, on the cookie. I was told that it was probably a cookie. So, probably was good for me and I ate the cookie. I was then told it was dry and the flavor was unidentifiable. I then cursed you out.

Ultimately, you gave me a shitty and dry cookie.
 
I expect Listo was rolestopped last night. If he wasn't, that is very interesting. But a rolestop makes most sense.

It has to be within Listo or Satsu. Leaning Listo because there is nothing to prove, but the way he came in almost felt pure? Satsu only makes sense if we go the tinfoil route of thinking a SK had cop protections similar to godfather. Mazer and MTR have roles that have interacted with multiple people and I don't know if any role that can perform an action at night could also be the killer.
 
VoidKitten said:
I expect Listo was rolestopped last night. If he wasn't, that is very interesting. But a rolestop makes most sense.

It has to be within Listo or Satsu. Leaning Listo because there is nothing to prove, but the way he came in almost felt pure? Satsu only makes sense if we go the tinfoil route of thinking a SK had cop protections similar to godfather. Mazer and MTR have roles that have interacted with multiple people and I don't know if any role that can perform an action at night could also be the killer.
Click to expand...
In what world does stopping all da actions on Madame Listo make sense.

As Madame Listo said last day, she wants ta follow da will of da dead. And dey want VK/BN gone.
 
Listo95 said:
In what world does stopping all da actions on Madame Listo make sense.

As Madame Listo said last day, she wants ta follow da will of da dead. And dey want VK/BN gone.
Click to expand...
Seeing as we attempted to kill you last night and you are alive, I am assuming that MTR rolestopped you.
 
VoidKitten said:
You don't understand. The cookie saga took off.

I asked what kind of cookie and was told it was unidentifiable. I then, obviously knowing our mod, cast the Level 1 spell Identify, on the cookie. I was told that it was probably a cookie. So, probably was good for me and I ate the cookie. I was then told it was dry and the flavor was unidentifiable. I then cursed you out.

Ultimately, you gave me a shitty and dry cookie.
Click to expand...
Which is a metaphor.



Remember, at the end of the day, every story is ultimately the story of an old man, a young man, and life's greatest lesson
 
Mazer said:
Which one do you think if you had to pick one?
Click to expand...
Da Madame believes it could be either one. Da spirit of Val believes dey be a SK duo. CWE be wanting us ta go after da Schizo SK result. Badger be thinking dey could be lying about what da action is.
 
Even based on da claim VK be makin' dey be havin' no way to guarantee a kill would be attempted on me due to da 2 nights of no actions. Unless it all be a lie ofc.
 
Mazer said:
I would go you or bn before satsu.

Val's check means something. In a world where it didn't for an sk, I have more reason to doubt the double town Mason scenario
Click to expand...
I would go for Listo before Satsu too. I would not go BN before Satsu. You can have reasons to doubt, but I am not doubting a mason modifier in a Foxxi game. It would have been neighbors I think if there was any chance BN was tricking me.
 
And this is why your block concerns me.

You and Blind Ninja are willing to block what I view as the second most probable outcome.
 
Mazer said:
And this is why your block concerns me.

You and Blind Ninja are willing to block what I view as the second most probable outcome.
Click to expand...
Feel free to ask Foxxi after the game. Hell feel free to ask now, but I doubt she'd answer. She would not put masons in a group that could betray one another. Ever.
 
Why should I be at confident in that?

Asking now .....she won't answer

Asking later.....seems kinda problematic




Yesterday you seemed concerned or spiraling (depending on perspective). Today you seem more dead set lock
 
Mazer said:
Why should I be at confident in that?

Asking now .....she won't answer

Asking later.....seems kinda problematic




Yesterday you seemed concerned or spiraling (depending on perspective). Today you seem more dead set lock
Click to expand...
There is no way you can know now. I am just putting this on record so after the game I can point back to it that I was correct.

I made a comment about how I could imagine a way that BN could be evil, but that was pure tinfoil and would be so bastardized and wouldn't even explain why I had two nights of missed actions if it were true.

Doubt me on reading Badger properly. You were right there. Do not doubt me on Foxxi building games when she taught me how to build my games in this style :p
 
VoidKitten said:
I have so many questions about Matthieu. Why was he killed? Why can he come up with amazing stories but had to ask the most indirect questions ever.
Click to expand...
Yeah I don't understand why he was killed over me or listo. Granted the SK has gotten around my rolestop twice and I guess for some reason SK more worried about Matthieu than other one of us which baffles me a bit.
 
Sorry not around earlier. Had a minor medical procedure done and finally getting around to jumping on laptop. About to scarf down some more food. So hungry.
 
MTR said:
Yeah I don't understand why he was killed over me or listo. Granted the SK has gotten around my rolestop twice and I guess for some reason SK more worried about Matthieu than other one of us which baffles me a bit.
Click to expand...
Which I would not be fearin'.
 
VoidKitten said:
I wish it didn't because I think the game would have been over.
Click to expand...
I don't know. I don't think it is him. I am trying to stop tinfoiling over you and BN. Don't feel it is Mazer which goes back to Satsu but that only works if he had some kind of investigation protection since there was the role cop result on him. So needless to say I am frustrated as hell right now.
 
I think from last day progression it makes sense what vk bn did. It is more likely to be Listo.

However mechanically it would still be a better play to go vk or bn first. If listo flips town they can prevent a majority together tommorow. Listo cant do anything on his own.

This should be auto anyway. Do you want to drag this out Listo?
 
Satsu said:
I think from last day progression it makes sense what vk bn did. It is more likely to be Listo.

However mechanically it would still be a better play to go vk or bn first. If listo flips town they can prevent a majority together tommorow. Listo cant do anything on his own.

This should be auto anyway. Do you want to drag this out Listo?
Click to expand...
It is literally NOT Madame Listo.

Vote: BN
 
Okay fuck it Madame Listo is gone for now. I am not scum. I'm a fucking medium who chooses a dead player during the day to talk to during the night. Seriously people, N1 I talked to Rock, he was sus of the VT claims cause he thought he was the sole VT, N2 was crackle who continued to say he was a compulsive SK, but added he couldn't kill town. N3 was Badger who was literally not sure about VK and BN being masons. N4 was CWE, who came in sober and literally still doesn't trust VK. N5 was Val who I couldn't talk to much because I had a fucking early ass shift and day started again pretty much before I got off work. Val literally believes one of VK/BN is the sk.
 
Listo95 said:
Madame Listo not even care anymore. Da spirit of Val checked me da night dey died but never got a result. Val believe BN/VK be a SK duo. Da spirit not give what Mazer wanted but instead gave stuff dat Matthieu be able to confirm.
Click to expand...
Look at dis. Why would a scum Madame lie about Val not havin a result. Da Madame coulda easily said my exact role or even lied about what he said.
 
Listo95 said:
Okay fuck it Madame Listo is gone for now. I am not scum. I'm a fucking medium who chooses a dead player during the day to talk to during the night. Seriously people, N1 I talked to Rock, he was sus of the VT claims cause he thought he was the sole VT, N2 was crackle who continued to say he was a compulsive SK, but added he couldn't kill town. N3 was Badger who was literally not sure about VK and BN being masons. N4 was CWE, who came in sober and literally still doesn't trust VK. N5 was Val who I couldn't talk to much because I had a fucking early ass shift and day started again pretty much before I got off work. Val literally believes one of VK/BN is the sk.
Click to expand...
Just add 1 to all of these in terms of night the chat happened.
 
Listo95 said:
Okay fuck it Madame Listo is gone for now. I am not scum. I'm a fucking medium who chooses a dead player during the day to talk to during the night. Seriously people, N1 I talked to Rock, he was sus of the VT claims cause he thought he was the sole VT, N2 was crackle who continued to say he was a compulsive SK, but added he couldn't kill town. N3 was Badger who was literally not sure about VK and BN being masons. N4 was CWE, who came in sober and literally still doesn't trust VK. N5 was Val who I couldn't talk to much because I had a fucking early ass shift and day started again pretty much before I got off work. Val literally believes one of VK/BN is the sk.
Click to expand...
Unvote:

The fact you broke RP and still fucked up your days makes me feel like this is just really pissed town.
 
Is it as easy as the SK has a godfather-esque passive? I'd expect scum to at least have one too, if so. I tend to try and keep some form of parity.

Listo just feels like the better choice. The outburst feels towny. Why go this entire time without RP, then drop the RP, then pick it back up? Was he actually threatened by Satsu saying its an autowin?
 
It's decent meta reads.

My struggle with listo is his arguments are basically "because this person said to". Because I typically expect listo to solve more.

The argument against listo is its possible for him to make up this role. The argument he does make that he could have said Val said his exact role hold little water for me, because a self report is easily dismissed.

Mtr and I both have actions that went off on the same night as kills. Double actions seem very implausible.

Void and blind Ninja have a weird set up for balance. I currently don't credit voud's world building element, because it only came up when he was closer to danger. Maybe he can tell me where I am wrong after game. The other factor is val's changing info. I've made enough typos over the years that I hate to really bring it up too much or overhead. But it's knowledge and we're getting winnowed down.

But now they took an action on the same night as a kill. Unless they guessed mtr would rolestop matt. Which I still find less probable.

That said, I'd buy a secret action is hidden in two people, before I'd buy that 1 person acts twice in a night

@MTR can you repeat targets?

If satsu is sk, that means val's read on him was irrelevant, and even him eventually clearing other people was at least moderately less relevant. Which makes him an interesting kill choice. Killing Matt is also interesting as it speaks to elimination of knowledge roles over cleared town. Which is also interesting.

Listo does require me to accept that he planned from the start his claim. Which I wouldn't expect from some. But seeing listo's knowledge base in told has earned great respect for his strategy. He could definitely choose an unlikely to be duplicated role and know instantly he needed to claim.

His reaction feels ok today, but it's not enough for me to take off board. ATE is not sufficient by itself.
 
If ya really think da Madame be thinkin' dat far ahead she be sorry to disappoint. Most she'd be thinkin' bout be da kill targets and in what order ta get da best chances of win. Also da fact she 100% woulda killed VK after last game -.-
 
VoidKitten said:
Maybe it was Mazer who called his cookies delicious. I remember him being afraid, but I thought he ate it. I can't be bothered to actually go look.
Click to expand...
Foxxi said my cookies were delicious. Everyone else I specified a cookie. You I didn't. Crumbs.

And then foxxi and I had some laughs and discussed Robin Hood.

The animated one. It's a treasure.


robin hood animation GIF by Disney
 
The only way it looks worse for Listo is if you consider day action versus night action.

When he said he chose during the day, it made me come up with a really tinfoil role of a Psychic SK, which fit well except for one thing so its not really something I am pushing.

That being said, I really like this role I came up with thinking about it and totally want to use it in some form.
 
Listo95 said:
If ya really think da Madame be thinkin' dat far ahead she be sorry to disappoint. Most she'd be thinkin' bout be da kill targets and in what order ta get da best chances of win. Also da fact she 100% woulda killed VK after last game -.-
Click to expand...
Do you have any holes in my thoughts on anyone else?
 
Mazer said:
Foxxi said my cookies were delicious. Everyone else I specified a cookie. You I didn't. Crumbs.

And then foxxi and I had some laughs and discussed Robin Hood.

The animated one. It's a treasure.


robin hood animation GIF by Disney
Click to expand...
Wow for the first part.

100% agree on animated Robin Hood.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Foxxi
Mafia 29: The Killing Itch
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
652
Views
4K
3puppies
3
Foxxi
Mafia 22: <Insert Title Here>
18 19 20 21 22
Replies
2K
Views
12K
LemonDemonGirl
LemonDemonGirl
Foxxi
Mafia 26 - The Monster Mash
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
583
Views
4K
Tildey
Tildey
VoidKitten
Mafia 27 - Town of the Undead
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
807
Views
9K
Val the Moofia Boss
Val the Moofia Boss
Foxxi
  • Locked
Mafia 26 - The Monster Mash
Replies
15
Views
425
Foxxi
Foxxi
Back
Top Bottom